Key takeaways
- Agency and app workers are convenient but cost more per hour and know less about your venue; a bank of your own casual staff is usually cheaper for regular gaps.
- Agency workers have some rights from day one and equal treatment on pay, holiday and pension after 12 weeks in the same job.
- Since 6 April 2026, the agency that contracts with you, or you as end client if there is no agency, is responsible for PAYE where an umbrella company employs the worker.
- Compare the full cost of your own staff, including employer National Insurance at 15%, before assuming agency is expensive.
Three ways to fill a gap
When the rota has holes, hospitality employers usually reach for one of three options. A traditional staffing agency supplies workers for shifts or longer assignments and charges you an hourly rate. A staffing app or shift marketplace lets you post a shift and have it picked up by a worker on the platform, often within hours. A bank of your own casual staff, on your payroll, gives you people who already know the venue and can be offered extra shifts.
Each solves a different problem. The mistake is using the most expensive option for the most predictable gaps. Hospitality reports worker shortages more often than the wider economy, with 11.6% of accommodation and food businesses reporting a shortage of workers in October 2026[1], so some reliance on outside staff is often unavoidable. The aim is to use it deliberately.
How the options compare
| Factor | Staffing agency | Shift app or marketplace | Your own casual bank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Speed | Same day to a few days | Often hours | Depends on who is free; quick if the list is maintained |
| Hourly cost | Highest: worker pay plus agency margin | High: worker pay plus platform fee | Lowest: wage plus your on-costs |
| Knowledge of your venue | Low unless you get the same people | Low; may vary every shift | High |
| Quality control | Agency vets; you can reject workers | Ratings systems; less control | Your own recruitment and training |
| Who employs the worker | Agency, or an umbrella company in its supply chain | Varies: platform, umbrella company or self-employed | You |
| Your legal duties | Day-one rights, 12-week equal treatment, supply chain checks | Check the platform’s model and status of workers | Full employer duties |
| Best for | Events, longer cover, specialist roles | Last-minute single shifts | Regular peaks, holidays, predictable gaps |
Working out the real cost
Agency and app rates look high next to an hourly wage, but your own staff cost more than their wage. Since 6 April 2025, employer National Insurance has been 15%, up from 13.8%, and the secondary threshold fell from £9,100 to £5,000 a year[2]. In 2026 to 2027 that threshold is £96 a week[3]. Add holiday pay, pension contributions where staff are enrolled, and the time spent recruiting and training, and the gap narrows.
Source: ICAEW Library & Information Service, 2025[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Before 6 April 2025 | 13.8% |
| From 6 April 2025 | 15% |
Example: a casual server works 20 hours in a week at £12.71 an hour, so gross pay is £254.20. Employer National Insurance is 15% of the pay above £96, which is about £23.73. Add accrued holiday and any pension, and the true cost per hour is meaningfully above the wage. Compare that with the agency’s or app’s all-in hourly charge for the same shift. If the difference is small and the gap is one-off, outside cover may be sensible. If you are buying the same shift every week, a bank worker is almost always cheaper.
Ask every agency or app for an all-in hourly rate that includes their margin, the worker’s holiday and any other charges, and for what changes after 12 weeks. Compare like with like.
Agency worker rights you need to know
Agency workers have a worker’s employment rights from the day they start, and the same rights as your permanent staff to use shared facilities and services[4], such as a staff room, staff meals area or lockers. After 12 weeks in the same job they qualify for equal treatment: pay must match a permanent colleague doing the same job, they must be automatically enrolled into a pension and they are entitled to paid holiday each year[4].
The 12 weeks can build up even if someone works only a few shifts each week, so a regular agency bartender every Friday and Saturday will reach equal treatment. The agency is responsible for applying it, but it needs your pay information to do so. Expect the hourly charge to rise when it applies, and plan for that in your budget.
Umbrella companies and PAYE
Many agency and some app workers are paid through umbrella companies. New PAYE rules apply to labour supply chains that include umbrella companies, for money paid to workers on or after 6 April 2026[5]. Under the rules, responsibility for making sure PAYE is operated correctly sits with the agency that has the contract with you as the end client or, if there is no agency involved, with you[5]. HMRC can recover underpaid tax from the responsible party.
Map the chain
For each supplier, find out whether workers are supplied by an agency, an umbrella company, or both.
Ask for compliance evidence
Ask the agency how it checks umbrella companies in its chain and what it does if one fails to operate PAYE.
Avoid direct umbrella deals
If you contract with an umbrella company directly, with no agency in between, you take on the responsibility yourself. Get advice first.
Watch for warning signs
Unusually low rates, workers saying their take-home pay looks odd, or payslips with unexplained deductions are reasons to ask questions.
Review contracts
Update supplier terms so the agency confirms compliance and tells you about any change in the supply chain.
Shift apps: what to check
Staffing apps vary widely in how they engage workers. Some employ workers themselves, some use agencies or umbrella companies, and some describe workers as self-employed. Before you use one, find out which model applies, who pays the worker, who handles holiday pay and right to work checks, and what happens if a worker cancels or does not arrive. Read the platform’s terms on cancellation charges, minimum booking lengths and fees for taking on a worker permanently.
- Who is the worker’s employer or engager, and who operates PAYE?
- Who checks right to work, and can you see evidence?
- What training or food safety knowledge do workers have?
- Can you request the same workers again?
- What is the fee if you hire a worker directly?
- What are the cancellation and no-show terms on both sides?
Getting the best from outside staff on shift
Agency and app workers arrive knowing nothing about your menu, your till or your allergen procedure. How you brief them in the first ten minutes decides whether they help or slow the team down. Treat every outside worker as a new starter on a very short induction.
- Meet them at the door, introduce them to the shift leader and give them a named buddy for the shift.
- Show fire exits, the staff area and where to take breaks.
- Explain the allergen rule clearly: never answer an allergen question from memory, always fetch the shift leader or check the matrix.
- Give them a defined role, such as running food for one section or working the glass wash, rather than a full section.
- Explain age verification and refusals if they will serve alcohol.
- At the end of the shift, give the agency or app honest feedback, and ask for the good workers again.
Requesting the same people repeatedly is the biggest quality lever you have. A worker who has done five shifts with you is far more useful than five different workers who have done one each, and some will be interested in joining your bank or permanent team.
Building your own bank
A bank of casual staff is the most cost-effective way to cover predictable gaps. It takes work to set up and maintain, but it pays back quickly. Start with former staff who left on good terms, students who worked last summer, and people who applied for roles you filled with someone else.
Give each bank worker a written statement, a right to work check, a short induction and access to your rota app. Offer them shifts first before going to an agency, and keep the list current: remove people who never accept shifts and add new names each season. Bank workers who are offered regular work become a pipeline for permanent roles.
Example: a fictional pub group spends heavily on agency bar staff every weekend. It builds a bank of twelve casuals across its three sites, all trained on the same till and drinks specs. Within a quarter, agency use falls to events and emergencies only, and four bank workers move into permanent roles.
A simple decision rule
- Predictable, recurring gap: recruit permanent staff or use your bank.
- Holiday or sickness cover of a week or more: bank first, agency second.
- Single last-minute shift: bank, then app or agency.
- Large event or function: agency for numbers, with your own staff in key roles.
- Specialist cover such as a head chef: specialist agency on a defined assignment.
Frequently asked questions
Do agency workers get the same pay as my staff?
After 12 weeks in the same job they qualify for equal treatment, including the same pay as a permanent colleague doing the same job, automatic pension enrolment and paid holiday.
Who is responsible for PAYE if an umbrella company pays the worker?
From 6 April 2026, the agency that contracts with you, or you as the end client if there is no agency involved.
Are staffing apps cheaper than agencies?
Sometimes per shift, but the model varies. Compare the all-in hourly charge, cancellation terms and who carries employer responsibilities.
What is a staff bank?
A pool of your own casual workers, on your payroll, who are offered extra shifts before you use an agency or app.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑
ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Your rights as an agency worker: equal treatment (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). PAYE rules for labour supply chains that include umbrella companies from 6 April 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑