Guest experience and reviews

Answering complaints by email after the visit

Triage, reply times and adaptable templates for complaint emails at UK restaurants and pubs, plus what to offer, what to avoid and when to escalate.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why the email reply matters more than the original mistake
  2. Step one: triage
  3. The structure of a good reply
  4. Templates to adapt
  5. What to offer, and why
  6. What not to do
  7. When the same complaint is also a public review
  8. Example: one week's inbox
  9. Keep a log and learn from it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Sort every complaint email into a category first; allergen reactions, illness and staff conduct go straight to the manager, not to a template.
  • A good reply thanks, names the specific problem, explains without excuses, says what changed and makes a clear offer.
  • Consumer law gives guests rights to repeat performance or a price reduction when a service falls short[1]; a fair offer early usually ends the matter.
  • Never tie a refund or voucher to removing or changing a review: concealed incentivised reviews are banned content[2].

Why the email reply matters more than the original mistake

A guest who takes the time to write after the visit is giving you a chance the silent unhappy guest never does. They may also post a review, tell friends or come back. How you answer often decides which. A prompt, specific, human reply turns many complainants into neutral or even loyal guests; a slow, defensive or copied reply confirms their view and gets quoted.

Email also leaves a written record. Whatever you say may be forwarded, screenshotted or read out in a review. Write every reply as if the guest's friends will read it, because they may.

Step one: triage

Complaint triage: who replies and how fast
CategoryExamplesWho repliesTarget reply time
SafetyAllergic reaction, suspected food poisoning, injury, foreign objectGM or owner, after checking recordsSame day; acknowledge within hours
Staff conductRudeness, discrimination, harassmentGM, after speaking to staffAcknowledge same day; full reply within three working days
BillingOvercharged, service charge, deposit disputeManager with access to the EPOSWithin one working day
Food and service qualityCold food, slow service, wrong orderManager on duty that nightWithin one working day
FacilitiesNoise, temperature, toilets, accessGMWithin two working days

Safety complaints are different in kind. Do not use a template. Check the allergen records, the dish's recipe and what the server noted, speak to the kitchen, and reply in your own words. Reactions are increasingly common: among people with a food hypersensitivity, the share who had a bad or unpleasant reaction in the past year rose from 42% in 2021 to 59% in 2025[3]. If someone was harmed, inform your insurer and, where required, your local authority, and keep everything you have.

People with a food hypersensitivity who had a bad reaction in the past year
People with a food hypersensitivity who had a bad reaction in the past yearComparison. 2021: 42%; 2025: 59%.42%20212021: 42%59%20252025: 59%People with a food hypersensitivity who had a bad reaction in the past yearComparison. 2021: 42%; 2025: 59%.42%20212021: 42%59%20252025: 59%

Source: Food Standards Agency, 2025[3]

Show the data
ItemValue
202142%
202559%

The structure of a good reply

  1. Thank them, briefly

    One line. 'Thank you for writing to us about your dinner on Saturday.' No paragraph about how much you value feedback.

  2. Name the specific problem

    Show you read it. 'Your mains took over forty minutes and nobody told you why.' Use their details, not a summary.

  3. Explain without excuses

    If there is a real reason, give it in a sentence. 'We were two chefs down and should have cut bookings.' Never blame the guest, the weather or the team member by name.

  4. Say what has changed

    Name one concrete action. 'We now cap bookings at 7.30pm when the kitchen is short.' This is what makes the apology believable.

  5. Make a clear offer

    State it plainly and how to accept. Avoid vague promises such as 'we'd love to make it up to you'.

  6. Sign with a real name

    A named manager, a direct email and, for serious complaints, a phone number.

Templates to adapt

Slow service: 'Dear Ms Patel, thank you for writing about Saturday evening. Your mains took over forty minutes and nobody explained why, which isn't acceptable. We were short in the kitchen and should have reduced bookings. We've since changed how we pace bookings when we're short. I've refunded the cost of your two main courses to your card; you should see it within five working days. I'd be glad to welcome you back. Sam Okafor, General Manager.'

Billing error: 'Dear Mr Hughes, you're right: the bill included a bottle of wine that your table didn't order. I'm sorry, especially as you had to raise it on the night. I've refunded the bottle to your card today. We've retrained the team on checking bills against the table before printing. Sam Okafor, General Manager.'

Food quality: 'Dear Alex, thank you for telling us the lamb arrived overcooked and the replacement took too long. I've shared your email with our head chef, who has changed how that dish is held at the pass. I'd like to invite you and your guest back for dinner on us, on any weekday in the next three months; reply to this email and I'll book it personally. Sam Okafor, General Manager.'

Allergen concern: 'Dear Ms Ward, thank you for telling us. I'm very sorry you were unwell, and I'm treating this as a priority. I've checked the order, the recipe and our allergen records, and I'd like to talk you through what we found. Could you share a phone number and a time to call today? If you sought medical treatment, please tell us, and please keep any receipts.' Then follow your incident procedure.

These are frames, not scripts. Change the details every time. A guest who receives the same reply as the last review they read will notice.

What to offer, and why

Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, if a service does not conform to the contract, the consumer's rights are to require repeat performance or to a price reduction[1]. A restaurant cannot redo a ruined anniversary dinner, so in practice the remedy is usually money back for the part that went wrong, sometimes with an invitation to return. Match the offer to the failure.

  1. Minor issue, otherwise good visit: apology and explanation; a small gesture is optional.
  2. One element clearly failed: refund that element, such as the dish, the course or the drinks.
  3. Several failures or a ruined occasion: refund a larger part of the bill, with an invitation back.
  4. Billing error: refund the error in full, at once, with no conditions.
  5. Safety incident: no standard offer; deal with it personally and through your insurer.

Refunds to the original card are cleaner than vouchers. A voucher assumes the guest wants to return; some do not, and a voucher-only offer can read as a sales tactic.

What not to do

  • Do not make any offer conditional on deleting or changing a review. CMA guidance treats concealed incentivised reviews, such as a review written in exchange for money or a freebie without saying so, as banned content[2].
  • Do not argue facts by email. If accounts differ, say so politely and offer a call.
  • Do not name or blame individual staff. Say 'our team' and deal with conduct internally.
  • Do not copy and paste. Guests compare replies and post them.
  • Do not promise what you cannot check, such as 'this will never happen again'.
  • Do not disclose other guests' information or staff details.

Fake reviews are a real problem for guests and venues. Government research estimated that 11% to 15% of reviews in three common product categories on UK e-commerce platforms were fake[4]. If you suspect a complaint is fabricated, check your booking and payment records before replying, and respond factually and politely. Do not accuse the guest publicly.

When the same complaint is also a public review

Guests often email and post a review on the same night. Answer the email first, privately and in full. Then reply to the review briefly and publicly: thank them, say you have written to them directly and name the change you made. Keep refunds, personal details and any dispute about facts out of the public reply. Other readers judge you less on the complaint than on the tone of your answer, so keep it short, calm and specific.

Example: one week's inbox

Example (fictional): A 90-cover restaurant receives seven complaint emails in a week. The GM triages them on Monday morning: one possible allergic reaction, two slow-service complaints from the same Friday, two billing queries, one noise complaint and one about a rude remark at the bar. The allergen email gets a call that day and an incident record. Both Friday complaints get individual replies, refunds of the mains and a note to the rota manager. The billing queries are checked against the EPOS and refunded. The conduct complaint is acknowledged the same day and answered after the GM speaks to the bartender.

Two of the seven trace back to one cause: a short kitchen on Friday with a full book. The real fix sits in slow service planning, not in better emails.

Keep a log and learn from it

Record each complaint with the date of visit, category, what was offered and the root cause. Review it monthly. Patterns tell you more than any single email: the same dish, the same night of the week, the same gap in the rota. Keep personal data only as long as you need it and limit who can see it.

Complaint counts are one of the guest experience metrics worth tracking. Disputes about bills often start at the table, so see splitting the bill for prevention.

Frequently asked questions

How quickly should a restaurant reply to a complaint email?

Acknowledge safety and conduct complaints the same day and aim to answer service and billing complaints within one working day. A quick holding reply is better than a slow perfect one.

Should we offer a refund or a voucher?

A refund to the original card for the part that went wrong is usually fairer and clearer. Offer an invitation back as well as, not instead of, money back where the failure was serious.

Can we ask the guest to update their review after we resolve the complaint?

You can mention that you replied publicly, but do not make a refund or offer conditional on changing or removing the review. That risks breaching rules on incentivised reviews.

What if the complaint is about an allergic reaction?

Treat it as a safety incident. Do not use a template, check your records, speak to the guest personally, inform your insurer and follow your incident procedure.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 54: Consumer's rights to enforce terms about services (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2: wave 11 key findings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Department for Business and Trade (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo