Food safety, hygiene and allergens

Appealing a hygiene rating and asking for a re-visit

Appeal, right to reply or re-rating visit? How each FHRS route works, the deadlines that apply, and how to prepare so a lower score is short-lived.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Three routes, three different jobs
  2. Read the report before you decide anything
  3. How to appeal in five steps
  4. Using the right to reply
  5. Requesting a re-rating visit
  6. Why a 3 or a 4 now costs more than it used to
  7. A 30-day plan between request and visit
  8. Mistakes that slow the recovery
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • There are three routes after a disappointing score: an appeal if the rating is unfair, a right to reply if you want to explain, and a re-rating visit once you have fixed the problems.
  • An appeal must be in writing within 21 days of being told the rating, so read the report the day it arrives.
  • A re-rating visit is unannounced and is judged on everything, not only the items you fixed, so treat it like a full inspection.
  • Diners are getting stricter: just over half of people who know the scheme now say 4 is the lowest rating they would generally accept.

Three routes, three different jobs

Under the Food Hygiene Rating Scheme in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, an officer scores three things: how hygienically food is handled, the physical condition of the premises, and how you manage food safety[1]. The sticker shows a single number from 0 to 5, so a weak result on one element can pull the whole score down. When that happens you have three tools, and picking the wrong one wastes weeks.

FHRS options after an inspection, from the Food Standards Agency business guidance
RouteUse it whenTime limitWhat it changes
AppealYou think the rating does not reflect what the officer found, or the scoring was applied inconsistentlyIn writing within 21 days of being notifiedThe rating itself, if the appeal succeeds
Right to replyThe rating is fair but you want diners to know what you have done sinceAny time before your next inspectionAdds your comment next to the rating online; the score stays
Re-rating requestYou have fixed every issue the officer raisedRequest in writing; timing rules differ by nationA new rating after an unannounced visit, which can go up or down

The time limits above come from the Food Standards Agency guidance for businesses[2]. In Northern Ireland the same three rights are written into statute, in separate sections of the Food Hygiene Rating Act on appeals, re-rating requests and the right of reply[3].

Read the report before you decide anything

Officers must tell you your rating in writing either at the inspection or within 14 days, counting weekends and public holidays[2]. Ratings of 0 to 4 are published three to five weeks after the inspection date, which gives you a short window to act before the score is visible online[2]. Spend the first evening with the report and sort every point into one of three piles.

  • Facts you agree with: missing probe records, a cracked seal on a fridge door, no handwash soap at the pass. These go on the fix list.
  • Facts you dispute: an item the officer recorded that you can show was wrong, such as a cleaning record that existed but was not found at the time. Gather the evidence now.
  • Scoring you dispute: the facts are right but you believe the score given for that element is out of line with the national scoring guidance. This is the only basis on which an appeal is likely to work.
  • Anything unclear: phone or email the officer and ask. A short, polite question often resolves what would otherwise become a failed appeal.

An appeal is not a complaint about the officer and it is not a chance to show improvements made after the visit. Improvements belong in a right to reply or a re-rating request.

How to appeal in five steps

  1. Diary the deadline

    Write the 21-day appeal deadline on the kitchen calendar the day the rating letter arrives[2]. Late appeals are not considered.

  2. Ask for the scoring breakdown

    Make sure you have the officer's scores for each of the three elements, not only the final number. Your argument has to be about a specific element.

  3. Write to the council in plain terms

    Set out which element you dispute, what the officer recorded, why you think the score does not match that finding, and what evidence you attach. Keep it to one or two pages.

  4. Attach evidence from the day

    Records dated before the inspection carry weight. Photos or invoices dated afterwards show improvement, not that the original score was wrong.

  5. Wait for the decision

    The council should tell you the outcome within 21 days of receiving the appeal[2]. While you wait, the rating online may show that an appeal is pending.

Example: a fictional gastropub in Leicester receives a 3. The report says there were no records of fridge checks. The head chef finds a completed fortnight of temperature sheets that had been filed in the wrong folder and were not shown on the day. That is a factual dispute worth raising, but the chef also accepts the officer's points about worn chopping boards. The appeal argues only the management score and attaches the dated sheets.

Using the right to reply

The right to reply has no deadline: you can submit it at any time up to your next inspection, and your comment stays on the ratings website until you are given a new rating[2]. It is useful when the score is fair, the problem was specific and short-lived, and you have already fixed it. Keep it factual and calm, because guests will read it next to the number.

Example wording: “At our inspection the officer found gaps in our cooling records and a damaged fridge seal. Since then we have replaced the seal, retrained all kitchen staff on our cooling procedure and introduced a twice-daily temperature log signed by the shift lead. We have asked for a re-rating visit.” Avoid blaming staff, the officer or a supplier; it reads badly and helps nobody.

Requesting a re-rating visit

Once every item is fixed, you can ask for a new inspection. The timing depends on where you trade and whether your council charges[2].

  • England, council does not charge: the visit will not usually happen in the first three months after the inspection. Ask during those three months and you can expect the visit within six months of the inspection; you can only have one free re-rating visit between planned inspections.
  • England, council charges or you ask after three months: you can expect the visit within three months.
  • Wales and Northern Ireland: every council charges a fee under the statutory schemes, and the visit happens within three months of your written request. You must also be displaying your current sticker in a prominent place.
  • Everywhere: you will not be told the date or time of the visit, and the new rating can be higher, the same or lower.
Key FHRS timescales after an inspectionPublication happens three to five weeks after inspection; the chart shows the upper end.
Key FHRS timescales after an inspectionColumn chart. Written rating notice (latest): 14 days; Appeal window: 21 days; Appeal decision (latest): 21 days; 0–4 ratings published (latest): 35 days.0 days10 days20 days30 days40 daysWritten rating notice (latest): 14 days14 daysWritten rating notice(latest)Appeal window: 21 days21 daysAppeal windowAppeal decision (latest): 21 days21 daysAppeal decision(latest)0–4 ratings published (latest): 35 days35 days0–4 ratings published(latest)Key FHRS timescales after an inspectionColumn chart. Written rating notice (latest): 14 days; Appeal window: 21 days; Appeal decision (latest): 21 days; 0–4 ratings published (latest): 35 days.Written rating notice (latest)Written rating notice (latest): 14 days14 daysAppeal windowAppeal window: 21 days21 daysAppeal decision (latest)Appeal decision (latest): 21 days21 days0–4 ratings published (latest)0–4 ratings published (latest): 35 days35 days

Source: Food Standards Agency, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Written rating notice (latest)14 days
Appeal window21 days
Appeal decision (latest)21 days
0–4 ratings published (latest)35 days

Because the visit is unannounced, the kitchen has to be inspection-ready every service from the day you send the request. Write a short evidence pack for each point in the original report: what was wrong, what you changed, the date, and where the proof lives. Leave it in the office where any shift lead can hand it to an officer.

Why a 3 or a 4 now costs more than it used to

Diners use the scheme more than ever. In 2025, 55% of consumers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland had checked a food business's rating in the previous year[4]. Among people who know the scheme, 52% said 4 was the lowest rating they would generally accept, up from 39% in late 2020[4].

52%

of people who know the scheme say 4 is the lowest rating they would generally accept (2025)[4]

That shift is why moving from a 3 to a 5 is worth the effort of a structured re-rating plan, and why an appeal on weak grounds is a poor use of the time you have. For the wider picture of how officers score, see what happens at an environmental health inspection.

A 30-day plan between request and visit

A re-rating request is a promise that the kitchen now runs to a standard every day, not just on the day you tidy up. A simple plan keeps the whole team working to the same target until the officer arrives.

  1. Week 1: fix every physical item in the report, keep the invoices and take dated photos. Book any pest, extraction or refrigeration engineers you need and file their reports.
  2. Week 2: rewrite the safe methods or procedures that were weak so they describe what the kitchen really does, then brief every shift on the changes in a ten-minute huddle.
  3. Week 3: run your own mock inspection with someone who did not do the fixes. Score the three elements honestly and write down anything you would mark down.
  4. Week 4: close the gaps from the mock, check that every record for the month is complete and signed, and make sure the opening and closing checks are being done by whoever is on, not only by the head chef.
  5. Every day after that: treat each service as the inspection day. Keep the evidence pack current and tell new starters where it is.

Example: the fictional Leicester gastropub above sends its re-rating request in week four, once its own mock inspection finds nothing new. The kitchen manager adds a line to the shift handover sheet, “officer could visit today”, so the standard does not drift during a busy weekend.

Mistakes that slow the recovery

  1. Appealing about improvements made after the visit instead of requesting a re-rating.
  2. Requesting a re-rating before every point is fixed, then scoring the same or lower on an unannounced visit.
  3. Removing or hiding the sticker in Wales or Northern Ireland, which is an offence and blocks a re-rating request there.
  4. Letting the right to reply sound defensive or vague.
  5. Fixing the physical items but not the records, so the management score stays low.

Frequently asked questions

Can I appeal a food hygiene rating because I have fixed the problems?

No. An appeal is for a rating you believe was wrong at the time of the inspection. If you have fixed the problems since, use the right to reply and request a re-rating visit instead.

How long do I have to appeal?

You must appeal in writing within 21 days of being notified of the rating, and the council should tell you the result within 21 days of receiving the appeal.

Do I have to pay for a re-rating visit?

In Wales and Northern Ireland, councils charge a fee for every re-rating visit. In England some councils charge and some do not; if yours does not, the visit will not usually happen in the first three months after the inspection.

Could a re-rating visit lower my score?

Yes. The officer assesses the whole business on the day, not just the points you fixed, so the new rating can go up, stay the same or go down.

References

  1. Food Standards Agency (2026). Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Food Standards Agency (2026). Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (FHRS): guidance for businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2016). Food Hygiene Rating Act (Northern Ireland) 2016 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Food Standards Agency (2025). Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (FHRS): Food and You 2 report, wave 11 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo