No-shows, deposits and cancellations

Card holds vs deposits vs prepayment: which to use

Card holds, deposits and full prepayment compared: how each works, the cash and dispute trade-offs, and which suits which booking at your venue.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Three tools that make different promises
  2. Side by side
  3. How a card hold works, and where it goes wrong
  4. What deposits do to behaviour and cash
  5. When full prepayment makes sense
  6. Decision criteria
  7. Setting up a card hold properly
  8. What to say to guests about each one
  9. Objections you will hear, and fair answers
  10. A mixed policy that works for many venues
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • A card hold costs the guest nothing at booking and only deters; a deposit brings cash forward; prepayment removes the risk but adds the most friction.
  • With a card hold, state the exact charge at booking. Charges that exceed what the guest could reasonably expect can be refunded by their bank under the Payment Services Regulations.
  • Never write down or keep a card security code; PCI DSS does not allow it once the transaction is authorised.
  • Most venues need a mix: nothing for small midweek tables, card holds for larger or peak bookings, deposits or prepayment for set menus and events.

Three tools that make different promises

Card holds, deposits and prepayment are often discussed as if they were the same thing at different strengths. They are not. Each changes who holds the money, when, and how a disagreement plays out, so choosing well starts with being precise about what each one is.

  • Card hold (card on file): the guest gives card details when booking, usually stored by your payment or booking provider as a token. Nothing is taken unless the guest breaks your terms, for example by not arriving.
  • Deposit: a part payment taken when the booking is made and set against the final bill. It is kept only in the circumstances your terms describe.
  • Prepayment: the full price, or most of it, paid at booking. Common for tasting menus, supper clubs, afternoon tea and ticketed events.

Side by side

How the three options compare in practice. Fees and features vary by provider.
QuestionCard holdDepositPrepayment
Money taken at bookingNonePart of the billAll or most of the bill
Friction for the guestMedium: card details, no paymentHigher: a paymentHighest: full payment
Cash flow for youNo change until a chargeSome cash in advanceMost cash in advance
Deterrent strengthModerateStrongStrongest
If the guest disputesYou must justify a later chargeGuest asks for money backGuest asks for money back
Refund adminRare: you seldom chargeRegular: refunds for early cancelsRegular, and larger sums
Best fitLarge tables, peak nightsPeak dates, set menusTasting menus, tickets, events

How a card hold works, and where it goes wrong

With a card hold you are not taking a payment at booking; you are getting permission to take one later. Two rules shape how safe that later charge is.

First, the security code. PCI DSS does not allow card verification codes to be kept once the specific transaction they were collected for has been authorised, and they are not needed for card-on-file charges[1]. A booking book or spreadsheet with card numbers and security codes in it is a breach waiting to happen. Use a provider that stores a token and never see the full number yourself.

Second, the amount. Under the Payment Services Regulations, where a guest authorised a payment without the exact amount being specified, and the amount charged exceeded what they could reasonably have expected, they are entitled to a refund from their own bank[2]. They must ask within 8 weeks of the money leaving their account[3]. The practical lesson: state the exact charge, per head or per table, at the moment the guest gives their card, and repeat it in the confirmation. A guest who was told the figure can hardly say it was unexpected.

What deposits do to behaviour and cash

A deposit asks the guest to commit money, which changes behaviour more than a card hold does: people who have paid tend to cancel properly rather than drift away. It also brings cash forward, which matters more than it used to. In October 2026, 20% of accommodation and food businesses had no cash reserves and 13.2% had less than a month's worth, against 14.4% and 7.8% across all businesses[4].

Cash reserves, October 2026Share of trading businesses. Deposits and prepayment bring cash forward; card holds do not.
Cash reserves, October 2026Column chart. No cash reserves: Accommodation and food 20%, All businesses 14.4%; Less than a month: Accommodation and food 13.2%, All businesses 7.8%.0%5%10%15%20%No cash reserves · Accommodation and food: 20%20%No cash reserves · All businesses: 14.4%14.4%No cash reservesLess than a month · Accommodation and food: 13.2%13.2%Less than a month · All businesses: 7.8%7.8%Less than a monthCash reserves, October 2026Column chart. No cash reserves: Accommodation and food 20%, All businesses 14.4%; Less than a month: Accommodation and food 13.2%, All businesses 7.8%.0%5%10%15%20%No cash reserves · Accommodation and food: 20%20%No cash reserves · All businesses: 14.4%14.4%No cash reservesLess than a month · Accommodation and food: 13.2%13.2%Less than a month · All businesses: 7.8%7.8%Less than a month
  • Accommodation and food
  • All businesses

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemAccommodation and foodAll businesses
No cash reserves20%14.4%
Less than a month13.2%7.8%

The cost is admin and goodwill. Every early cancellation means a refund, and every kept deposit is a potential complaint. Keep deposits proportionate and explain them early; the legal side is covered in are restaurant booking deposits legal and fair.

When full prepayment makes sense

Prepayment works when the experience is fixed in advance: a single sitting, a set menu, food bought or made for each guest, or a limited number of seats that sell out. In those cases a no-show is close to a total loss and guests already expect to pay up front, as they would for a theatre ticket.

It works badly for flexible à la carte dining, where guests expect to choose on the night and the venue cannot easily say what a missing guest cost. If you prepay, let guests transfer their booking to a friend, and say clearly how refunds work when they give enough notice.

Decision criteria

  1. How much do you lose if the table does not arrive? The bigger and more fixed the loss, the firmer the tool.
  2. Is food bought or prepared per booking? If yes, a deposit or prepayment is easier to justify.
  3. How hard is the slot to resell? A Saturday in December resells only if you hear early; a Tuesday rarely resells at all.
  4. Who are your guests? Regulars who book weekly will resent a deposit; first-time visitors and tourists expect one.
  5. What can your booking software do? A card hold you cannot charge cleanly is worse than none.
  6. How much admin can you absorb? About 53% of restaurant and mobile food enterprises have 0 to 4 employees[5], and a small team handling refunds every week will soon resent the system.

Setting up a card hold properly

  1. Pick a provider that tokenises

    Card details go straight to the payment provider. Staff never see, write down or read back the full number or the security code.

  2. State the charge exactly

    Show the per-head or per-table amount next to the card field, with the notice period, in one sentence.

  3. Repeat it in writing

    Put the same sentence in the confirmation email or text so the guest has a durable record.

  4. Send a reminder before the deadline

    Remind guests before the free cancellation window closes, with a link to cancel.

  5. Charge promptly and keep records

    If you charge, do it within a day or two and keep the booking record, the terms shown and the reminder log in case the guest disputes it.

What to say to guests about each one

The words staff use matter as much as the tool. Guests accept card holds and deposits far more readily when the reason is given in a sentence and the way out is obvious. Keep one line for each option and use it every time, on the phone, on the booking page and in the confirmation.

  • Card hold: "We just need a card to secure tables of six. Nothing is taken today. If plans change, let us know by 5pm the day before and there is no charge."
  • Deposit: "For December we take a small deposit per person, which comes off your bill on the night. It is refunded in full if you cancel at least 72 hours before."
  • Prepayment: "The tasting menu is paid when you book, because we buy and prepare for each guest. If you cannot make it you are welcome to send a friend in your place."

Avoid apologising for the policy or blaming other guests. Phrases like "because people keep letting us down" make the person in front of you feel suspected. Explain what it protects, such as the table, the food and the staff, and move on to the booking.

Objections you will hear, and fair answers

  • "I never give my card over the phone." Offer a secure link instead, or keep a small allocation of tables that do not need a card.
  • "Other places don't ask for this." Agree that policies differ, give the reason in one sentence and offer a quieter night without the requirement.
  • "What if I'm ill?" Say what your terms allow, and offer to move the booking rather than charge where you can.
  • "Can I pay the deposit when I arrive?" No; a deposit taken on arrival protects nothing. Offer the card hold if your system supports both.

A mixed policy that works for many venues

Example: a 45-cover gastropub takes no card details for tables of one to five from Monday to Thursday. It uses a card hold with a stated per-head charge for tables of six or more and for Friday and Saturday evenings, takes a deposit for December and Mother's Day, and sells its monthly supper club as prepaid tickets. Staff have one sentence for each, and the booking system applies the right one automatically.

Review the mix every quarter. If no-shows on card-hold bookings stay high, move those slots to a deposit; if a deposit is putting people off on quieter nights, step back to a card hold. For how to set the amount, see how much a no-show fee should be, and for the wider plan, reducing no-shows in layers.

Frequently asked questions

Is a card hold the same as taking a deposit?

No. A card hold takes no money at booking; it gives you permission to charge a stated amount later if the guest breaks your terms. A deposit is money paid at booking and set against the bill.

Can we write guests' card details in the booking diary?

You should not. Card data needs secure handling, and PCI DSS does not allow card security codes to be kept after authorisation. Use a booking or payment provider that stores a token instead.

Can a guest get a no-show charge back from their bank?

If the amount was not specified when they authorised it and it exceeded what they could reasonably expect, the Payment Services Regulations give them a refund right if they ask within 8 weeks. Stating the exact charge at booking is your best protection.

Which option do guests prefer?

Guests generally find a card hold less off-putting than paying up front, but preferences vary by venue and occasion. Test changes on a few booking slots and compare completed bookings and no-shows before rolling out.

References

  1. PCI Security Standards Council (2015). Can card verification codes/values be stored for card-on-file or recurring transactions? (FAQ 1280) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). Payment Services Regulations 2017, regulation 79: refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). Payment Services Regulations 2017, regulation 80: requests for refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (workbook) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo