Key takeaways
- Every card fee has three layers: interchange to the card issuer, scheme fees to the card network, and the provider's own margin. Only the last is truly negotiable.
- Interchange on UK consumer debit cards is capped at 0.2% of the transaction value.
- Compare providers on your own statement: total fees divided by card turnover gives your effective rate.
- You cannot add a surcharge for consumer card payments, and card tips must reach staff without deductions.
What you are actually paying for
For most venues, card payments are now the main way guests pay, so card fees are a cost on almost every sale. They are also one of the least understood. A statement may show dozens of lines, with different rates for debit, credit, business cards, contactless and online payments. Before you compare providers, it helps to know what each layer is.
- Interchange: paid by your provider to the bank that issued the guest's card. It is set by the card schemes and, for consumer cards, capped by regulation. Interchange on UK consumer debit card transactions is capped at 0.2% of the transaction value[1].
- Scheme fees: charged by the card networks for using their systems. They are smaller per transaction but come in many forms.
- Acquirer or provider margin: what your payment provider charges on top for processing, settlement, terminals and support. This is the part you can negotiate.
Business and commercial cards, cards issued outside the UK, and online or keyed transactions usually carry higher interchange than a contactless UK debit card. A venue near a business district, or in a tourist area with many overseas guests, will pay a higher average rate than a neighbourhood café, even with the same provider.
The main pricing models
| Model | How it works | Suits | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blended or flat rate | One percentage for all cards, sometimes plus a fixed fee per transaction | Small venues wanting simplicity | You pay the same on cheap debit cards as on expensive credit and overseas cards |
| Interchange plus (or plus plus) | Actual interchange and scheme fees passed through, plus a fixed provider margin | Venues with steady, larger card turnover | Statements are harder to read; check the margin is fixed |
| Tiered | Different rates for qualified, mid-qualified and non-qualified transactions | Rarely the best choice | Hard to predict which tier a transaction falls into |
| Subscription | A monthly fee plus a small margin per transaction | Higher-turnover venues | Paying the subscription in quiet months |
Flat rates are easy to understand, which is why they are popular with new cafés and pop-ups. As card turnover grows, interchange plus pricing often becomes cheaper, because the venue benefits directly from low debit card interchange. Ask for both models on the same quote.
Work out your effective rate
The fairest comparison is your effective rate: all card-related charges in a month divided by the value of card payments taken. Include everything, not just the transaction percentage.
Gather three months of statements
Use typical months, including one busy and one quiet month.
Total every charge
Transaction fees, terminal rental, monthly minimums, authorisation fees, refund fees, chargeback fees, PCI compliance or non-compliance charges and any other service fees.
Total your card turnover
The value of card payments processed in the same months.
Divide charges by turnover
This is your effective rate. Use it to compare with every quote.
Ask providers to quote on your data
Send each provider the same anonymised statement and ask for a total monthly cost, not just a headline rate.
Example. A pub takes £30,000 a month by card. Its statement shows £390 of transaction fees, £25 terminal rental, a £15 PCI non-compliance fee because a questionnaire was never completed, and £20 of other charges, a total of £450. The effective rate is 1.5%. A competing provider quotes 1.1% all-in with no terminal rental and no minimum, about £330 a month. The saving is £120 a month, or £1,440 a year, before the cost of completing the PCI questionnaire that was causing an avoidable fee.
What a fee difference means at your turnover
Most venues are small businesses, so a fraction of a percentage point still matters. In 2026, 12,480 UK pub and bar enterprises had turnover of £100,000 to £249,000 and 10,055 had £250,000 to £499,000[2]. The most common band for restaurants and mobile food service enterprises was £100,000 to £249,000, covering about 45% of them[3].
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| £100,000 to £249,000 | 12,480 |
| £250,000 to £499,000 | 10,055 |
Example. For a venue taking £250,000 a year by card, every 0.1 percentage point of effective rate is £250 a year. Moving from an effective 1.6% to 1.1% saves £1,250 a year, enough to cover a good part of a new terminal, a staff training day or a month's energy standing charges.
Online, phone and pre-authorised payments
Card payments taken away from the terminal usually cost more, so check how each provider prices them. Deposits taken through a booking system, pre-payments for private dining, gift card sales online and delivery or click-and-collect orders are often card-not-present transactions, which typically carry higher interchange and higher fraud risk than a contactless tap at the table. Some booking systems use their own payment provider, which means your deposits are processed on different terms from your terminals. List every place the venue takes card payments, find out which provider handles each, and include them all in your effective rate. Taking card details over the phone is the riskiest route: use a secure payment link rather than writing numbers down, and never store card security codes.
Hidden costs and contract terms
- Contract length and exit fees: some terminal agreements run for several years with large early termination charges. Ask for a rolling monthly contract if you can.
- Terminal rental versus purchase: compare the total rental over the contract with buying the terminal outright.
- Minimum monthly charges: if your card turnover is low in winter, a minimum can push your effective rate up sharply.
- Settlement time: next-day settlement helps cash flow. Some providers charge extra for it, or hold funds longer for new accounts.
- Chargeback fees: disputed transactions carry a fee as well as the risk of losing the payment.
- PCI DSS fees: providers often charge a monthly fee if you have not completed your annual security questionnaire.
- Price change clauses: check how much notice the provider must give before increasing fees.
A short script for renegotiation
Example. "We process about £30,000 a month with you, mostly UK debit cards. Our effective rate over the last three months is 1.5% including terminal rental and other fees. We have a written quote at 1.1% all-in with next-day settlement. We would prefer to stay. Can you move us to interchange plus pricing with a fixed margin, remove the terminal rental and confirm next-day settlement, in writing, by the end of the month?"
Providers expect this conversation. Retention teams often have more room than sales teams, so ask to be put through to them if the first answer is no.
Rules on surcharges and tips
You cannot pass card fees on as a surcharge. Regulation 6A of the Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 bars a business from charging consumers fees for paying with a card-based payment instrument that is not a commercial card[4]. If you want to recover card costs, build them into menu prices.
Card tips need care too. By law, all tips must be passed to workers without deductions[5], so you cannot deduct card processing fees from tips paid by card. Count card fees on tips as a business cost when you compare providers, particularly if tipping on card is common in your venue.
Security is part of the cost
A cheap provider that leaves you exposed to fraud is not cheap. In 2025, 30% of UK food or hospitality businesses identified a cyber breach or attack in the previous 12 months[6]. Complete your annual PCI DSS questionnaire, keep terminals and payment software updated, never write down or store card numbers taken by phone, and train staff not to hand terminals to strangers claiming to be engineers. Ask each provider what fraud tools and support they include.
Related reading: cashless venues: pros, cons and legal points covers whether to stop taking cash, insurance for restaurants and pubs covers cyber insurance, and capital allowances on kitchen equipment and refits explains relief if you buy terminals outright. If you are preparing a venue for sale, selling a restaurant or pub: valuation basics explains why long payment contracts can put buyers off.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good card fee rate for a restaurant?
It depends on your card mix and turnover. Work out your effective rate, total card charges divided by card turnover, and compare it with written all-in quotes based on your own statements.
Can I charge customers extra for paying by card?
No. You cannot charge consumers a surcharge for paying with a consumer card. Build card costs into your prices instead.
Is interchange plus pricing better than a flat rate?
Often for venues with larger card turnover and many UK debit payments, because you benefit from low debit interchange. Flat rates suit small venues that value simplicity.
Can I deduct card fees from tips paid by card?
No. All tips must be passed to workers without deductions, so card processing fees on tips are a business cost.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Regulation (EU) 2015/751 on interchange fees for card-based payment transactions, Article 3 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (workbook) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (workbook) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2012). The Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012, regulation 6A (opens in a new tab) ↑
GOV.UK (2026). Tips at work (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology (2025). Cyber security breaches survey 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑