Licensing and premises compliance

Challenge 25 and age checks for staff

Write a Challenge 25 policy, train staff on accepted ID and refusal scripts, and keep a refusals log that stands up if your venue is ever tested.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. What the law requires and what Challenge 25 adds
  2. Your staff may be the same age as the customers
  3. Writing the policy
  4. Accepted and unacceptable ID
  5. How to check, and how to refuse
  6. Groups, proxy sales and table service
  7. Why the refusals log matters
  8. Training that sticks
  9. Challenge 25 checklist
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Every licence that authorises alcohol must have an age verification policy; Challenge 25 is the common, safer choice of age.
  • Acceptable ID must show a photograph and date of birth and carry a holographic mark or ultraviolet feature.
  • Staff have a defence only if they took reasonable steps, such as asking for ID that would convince a reasonable person.
  • A written policy, regular training and a refusals log are what show due diligence after a failed test purchase.

What the law requires and what Challenge 25 adds

The mandatory licensing conditions require the premises licence holder to ensure an age verification policy is adopted, and the designated premises supervisor to ensure alcohol is supplied in line with it. The policy must require anyone who appears to be under 18, or under an older age set by the policy, to produce identification bearing their photograph, date of birth and either a holographic mark or an ultraviolet feature before being served[1].

Challenge 25 is a policy that sets that older age at 25. The logic is simple: people are poor at judging age, so asking everyone who looks under 25 creates a buffer that catches most 16 and 17 year olds. It also gives staff a rule that does not depend on them deciding whether someone looks 18.

It matters because the stakes are high for staff and the business. Selling alcohol to anyone under 18 is an offence, and a premises licence holder commits a separate offence if alcohol is sold to under-18s on two or more occasions within three consecutive months[2][3].

Your staff may be the same age as the customers

Age checks are often carried out by very young staff. In the ONS analysis of the night-time economy, 18.6% of workers in the night-time cultural and leisure grouping, which includes restaurants and pubs, were aged 16 to 19, compared with 3.0% of the whole workforce[4]. Asking a customer of your own age for ID can feel awkward, which is exactly why a clear rule and a practised script help.

Share of workers aged 16 to 19, 2022ONS, The night-time economy, UK: 2022
Share of workers aged 16 to 19, 2022Comparison. Night-time cultural and leisure workers (including restaurants and pubs): 18.6%; Whole UK workforce: 3%.18.6%Night-time cultural and leisure workers(including restaurants and pubs)Night-time cultural and leisure workers (including restaurants and pubs): 18.6%3%Whole UK workforceWhole UK workforce: 3%Share of workers aged 16 to 19, 2022Comparison. Night-time cultural and leisure workers (including restaurants and pubs): 18.6%; Whole UK workforce: 3%.18.6%Night-time cultural and leisureworkers (including restaurants andpubs)Night-time cultural and leisure workers (including restaurants and pubs): 18.6%3%Whole UK workforceWhole UK workforce: 3%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2022[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Night-time cultural and leisure workers (including restaurants and pubs)18.6%
Whole UK workforce3%

Training is also patchy across the sector. Only 42% of accommodation and food SME employers provided any training in 2025, among the lowest shares of any sector[5]. Age verification training is the one piece of training no licensed venue can skip.

Writing the policy

  1. Set the age

    State that anyone who appears to be under 25 will be asked for ID before being served alcohol.

  2. List acceptable ID

    Name the documents you accept and state that each must show a photograph and date of birth and carry a hologram or ultraviolet feature.

  3. Cover groups and proxy sales

    Say staff may ask everyone in a group for ID, and will refuse if they believe an adult is buying for someone under 18.

  4. Say how refusals are recorded

    Every refusal is written in the refusals log with date, time, staff member and reason.

  5. Cover training

    Set out how new staff are trained before they serve alcohol, and how often refresher training happens.

  6. Sign and display

    The DPS signs and dates the policy. Display Challenge 25 signs at the entrance and at every point of sale.

Accepted and unacceptable ID

Checking ID against the mandatory age verification condition
DocumentMeets the mandatory criteria?Staff check
PassportUsually yes: photo, date of birth and security featuresPhoto matches; date of birth gives 18 or over; not expired
Photocard driving licenceUsually yes: photo, date of birth and hologramTilt to see the hologram; check the date of birth
Proof-of-age card with the PASS hologramUsually yesHologram present; photo matches
Military ID or other official photo IDCheck each type for a hologram or UV featureIf unsure, refuse
Student, work or gym cardUsually no hologram or UV featureDo not accept as proof of age
Photocopy or photo of ID on a phoneNoDo not accept

The test is the condition itself: photograph, date of birth and either a hologram or an ultraviolet feature[1]. Digital ID is being explored by government, but check with your licensing authority before accepting any digital alternative to physical ID.

How to check, and how to refuse

  • Take the ID in your hand. Do not check it while the customer holds it.
  • Look at the photo, then the face, then the photo again.
  • Check the date of birth against a date-of-birth calculator or a card at the till showing the date someone must have been born on or before to be 18 today.
  • Tilt the card to see the hologram and feel for tampering.
  • Ask a question if unsure, such as the star sign or postcode, and watch for hesitation.
  • Refuse politely if in any doubt.

Refusal script: Sorry, our policy is that we ask anyone who looks under 25 for photo ID, and I am not able to accept this one. I cannot serve you alcohol tonight, but I am happy to get you a soft drink.

Keep the tone calm and the reason about the policy, not the person. If the customer becomes aggressive, call the manager and record it. Staff should never feel they must serve to avoid confrontation.

Groups, proxy sales and table service

Most age-check training focuses on a single customer at a bar. The harder situations are groups, adults buying for younger friends or family, and table service where drinks are ordered by one person and shared around the table.

  • Groups at the bar: if one person in a group looks under 25 and the order is for the group, staff can ask everyone for ID before serving.
  • Proxy sales: buying alcohol on behalf of someone under 18 is itself an offence. If staff believe an adult is buying for an under-18, they should refuse the sale and log it.
  • Table service: servers should check ID when they take the drinks order and watch where drinks go when they are delivered to the table.
  • Families: the rules on drinking with a meal for 16 and 17 year olds are narrow; if in doubt, staff should refer to a manager rather than guess.
  • Deliveries and click-and-collect: if you sell alcohol for delivery, the age check has to happen at the door, and drivers need the same training and refusal script.

Put these scenarios into the role play. Staff who have practised refusing a group of their own age once are far more likely to do it on a busy Saturday.

Why the refusals log matters

If a member of staff is charged with selling to someone under 18, the defence is that they believed the person was 18 or over and either took all reasonable steps to establish their age or nobody could reasonably have suspected from their appearance that they were under 18. Asking for evidence of age counts as taking reasonable steps if that evidence would have convinced a reasonable person. Where someone is charged because of another person's act or default, it is a defence that they exercised all due diligence to avoid the offence[2].

For the business, due diligence is demonstrated with paperwork: the policy, the training records and a refusals log that shows staff are actually challenging. A log with no entries for months at a busy venue is a warning sign to any licensing officer.

  1. Date and time.
  2. Staff member's name.
  3. Description of the customer.
  4. Reason: no ID, unacceptable ID, suspected proxy sale or appears drunk.
  5. Outcome and any incident.
  6. Manager's initials at the end of each week.

Training that sticks

Train before a new starter serves alcohol, with a short session covering the law, the policy, the ID checks and the refusal script. Practise with role play using real examples of acceptable and unacceptable ID. Refresh at regular intervals, and immediately after any failed test purchase or near-miss.

Example: a fictional students' bar in Durham introduced a monthly ten-minute briefing before the Friday shift, rotating through topics: checking holograms, refusing groups, spotting proxy sales and handling hostility. The DPS initialled the refusals log each Monday and praised good refusals in the staff chat. Over a term, refusals logged per week went up, which the DPS took as a sign that staff were challenging more consistently, not that more underage customers were arriving.

Challenge 25 checklist

  1. Written policy signed by the DPS.
  2. Challenge 25 signs at the entrance and every till.
  3. Date-of-birth calculator or card at every till.
  4. Training records for every member of staff who sells alcohol.
  5. Refusals log in use and reviewed weekly.
  6. Process for staff to call a manager when a customer argues.
  7. Refresher training after any incident.

For what happens if a test purchase goes wrong, see test purchases and underage sales, and for the reviews that can follow repeated failures, licence reviews.

Frequently asked questions

Is Challenge 25 a legal requirement?

The law requires an age verification policy covering anyone who appears under 18, or an older age the policy sets. Challenge 25 is not mandatory, but it is widely used because it gives staff a safer margin.

What ID can I accept for alcohol sales?

ID must show the person's photograph and date of birth and carry a holographic mark or ultraviolet feature. Passports, photocard driving licences and PASS-hologram cards usually meet this; student and work cards usually do not.

Can I be fined personally for selling to someone under 18?

Yes. Selling alcohol to anyone under 18 is an offence for the person who makes the sale. The defence is that they took reasonable steps, such as checking ID that would convince a reasonable person.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2014). The Licensing Act 2003 (Mandatory Licensing Conditions) (Amendment) Order 2014, Schedule (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). Licensing Act 2003, section 146: sale of alcohol to children (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). Licensing Act 2003, section 147A: persistently selling alcohol to children (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2022). The night-time economy, UK: 2022 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo