No-shows, deposits and cancellations

Do deposits put guests off booking?

Do booking deposits cost you bookings? Where they put guests off, where they do not, and a simple test to measure the effect on your own booking flow.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The honest answer
  2. The market you are testing in
  3. Where deposits put people off
  4. Where deposits barely matter
  5. Show the cost at the start
  6. Design a test you can trust
  7. Reading the result
  8. When to stop a test early
  9. Ways to reduce the friction
  10. What staff should say when a guest hesitates
  11. The question of regulars
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • There is no reliable public UK study of how deposits affect restaurant bookings, so the only trustworthy answer is a test on your own booking flow.
  • Deposits put people off most when they are a surprise, the refund rule is unclear, or the booking is casual; they matter least for special occasions and peak dates.
  • Show any deposit or fee at the start of the booking flow: the total price, including fees a guest must pay, belongs in the offer itself.
  • Judge a deposit by lost covers, not by bookings alone: fewer bookings with far fewer no-shows can still mean more guests seated.

The honest answer

Some guests will not book when asked for a deposit. Others will book more carefully and turn up. Which effect wins depends on your venue, your guests and how the deposit is presented, and there is no reliable public UK study that settles it for restaurants. Claims you see from booking-software sellers are worth reading with that in mind.

The good news is that you can measure the effect for your own venue in four to six weeks. This guide explains where deposits tend to cause friction, how to reduce it, and how to run a test you can trust.

The market you are testing in

Guests are spending on eating out, but they are choosing carefully. Spending on restaurants and hotels was among the household categories with the largest increases in the financial year ending 2025, up £2.80 a week, or 6%[1]. At the same time, demand is patchy month to month: in September 2026, 30.7% of trading accommodation and food businesses reported a fall in domestic demand compared with August, while 4.4% reported a rise[2].

Change in domestic demand, September against August 2026Trading accommodation and food businesses; the rest were unsure or did not answer.
Change in domestic demand, September against August 2026Bar chart. Demand fell: 30.7%; Stayed the same: 35.4%; Demand rose: 4.4%.Demand fellDemand fell: 30.7%30.7%Stayed the sameStayed the same: 35.4%35.4%Demand roseDemand rose: 4.4%4.4%Change in domestic demand, September against August 2026Bar chart. Demand fell: 30.7%; Stayed the same: 35.4%; Demand rose: 4.4%.Demand fellDemand fell: 30.7%30.7%Stayed the sameStayed the same: 35.4%35.4%Demand roseDemand rose: 4.4%4.4%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Demand fell30.7%
Stayed the same35.4%
Demand rose4.4%

In a market like that, an unexpected hurdle in the booking flow can send a guest to the place next door. A well-explained deposit on a night that sells out anyway is a very different matter.

Where deposits put people off

  • Surprise: the deposit appears only at the payment step, after the guest has chosen a time and filled in their details.
  • Uncertain refunds: the guest cannot tell, in a sentence, when they would get their money back.
  • Casual bookings: a Tuesday supper for two, booked an hour ahead, feels too small for a payment.
  • Regulars: guests who have booked weekly for years read a new deposit as a lack of trust.
  • Awkward payment: a long card form on a phone, with no quick payment option.
  • Group organisers paying for everyone: a large up-front sum can stop the booking until they have collected money from the group.

Where deposits barely matter

Some bookings already feel like a commitment, and guests expect to pay something. Deposits tend to cause little resistance for special occasions, Christmas parties, New Year's Eve, Mothering Sunday, tasting menus, afternoon tea and private dining. They also suit first-time visitors and tourists who book well ahead, because the deposit signals that the booking is real on both sides.

That is why many venues use deposits selectively, by date, party size or menu, rather than everywhere. The test below lets you find where the line sits for you.

Show the cost at the start

The single biggest friction point is surprise, and it also carries legal risk. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, an invitation to purchase must include the total price, and the total price includes any fees or charges the consumer will necessarily incur[3]. A mandatory booking fee that appears only at the last step is the kind of thing that rule targets. A refundable deposit set against the bill is not a fee in the same sense, but the same principle applies: say it first.

The CMA's guidance on unfair terms makes the same point about deposits: the trader should make clear at the earliest opportunity that a deposit is required and in what narrow circumstances it would not be refunded[4]. In practice, put one line next to the date and time picker: "Tables of six or more: £10 per person deposit, refunded if you cancel 48 hours ahead."

Design a test you can trust

  1. Pick the slots

    Choose one clear group, such as Friday and Saturday dinners for parties of four or more.

  2. Alternate weeks

    Run the deposit on alternate weeks, or on Fridays only with Saturdays as the comparison, for four to six weeks.

  3. Keep everything else fixed

    Same reminders, same menu, same booking page apart from the deposit. Avoid weeks with bank holidays or big local events.

  4. Measure the whole funnel

    Count people who start a booking, completed bookings, no-shows, late cancellations and covers seated.

  5. Decide on lost covers

    Compare covers seated and lost covers per available slot, not just the number of bookings.

The five numbers to collect in a deposit test.
MeasureWhere to get itWhat it tells you
Booking startsBooking page analytics or platform reportHow many people considered booking
Completed bookingsBooking systemHow many went through with it
No-shows and late cancellationsBooking outcomes, using fixed definitionsWhether the deposit changed behaviour
Covers seatedTill or table planThe result that pays the bills
Phone enquiries about the depositCall log or a tally by the phoneWhether the wording is confusing

Reading the result

Example: over six weeks, Fridays with a £10 per person deposit for parties of four or more get 61 completed bookings and 2 no-shows. Saturdays without it get 70 bookings and 9 no-shows. Fewer bookings, but more parties actually arrived on deposit nights once no-shows are taken out, and the kitchen knew what was coming. The owner keeps the deposit for large parties at weekends and drops it for parties of four.

If the deposit cuts completed bookings sharply and no-shows only a little, it is costing you guests. Try a lighter tool, such as a card hold, or limit the deposit to larger parties. If completed bookings barely move and no-shows fall, keep it. For the definitions to use, see measuring your no-show rate properly.

When to stop a test early

Most tests should run their full course, because a single quiet week can mislead. Stop early only if something is clearly broken: the payment step is failing, guests are ringing in confusion about the wording, or completed bookings on test nights have collapsed in a way that cannot be explained by the calendar. Fix the cause, then restart the clock rather than stitching the two halves together.

Keep a short diary alongside the numbers. Note the weather, local events, staff shortages and anything unusual on each test night. When the results come in, the diary often explains the odd week that would otherwise skew the conclusion.

Ways to reduce the friction

  • Use a card hold instead of a deposit for mid-risk bookings.
  • Apply deposits by party size and date, not to every table.
  • Offer quick payment methods so the deposit takes seconds on a phone.
  • Put the refund rule in one sentence beside the payment button.
  • Let guests transfer a booking to a friend instead of losing the deposit.
  • Keep a phone option for guests who prefer to talk it through.

What staff should say when a guest hesitates

Some of the effect of a deposit comes down to the conversation around it. A guest who hesitates on the phone is often deciding whether you are reasonable, not whether they can afford it. Give staff a calm answer that explains the reason and the way out.

  • "It comes off your bill on the night, so it isn't an extra charge."
  • "If plans change, just let us know 48 hours ahead and it's refunded in full."
  • "We only ask for it on Saturday evenings, so if another night suits, there's no deposit."
  • "If you'd rather not pay online, I can take the booking now and send you a secure link."

Track how often guests hesitate and how often they still book. If many drop out at the same point in the conversation, the wording or the amount is the problem, not the idea of a deposit.

The question of regulars

Regulars are the guests most likely to be annoyed by a new deposit and least likely to be the problem. Many venues exempt guests with a good booking history, or waive deposits for bookings made in person or by phone with a known guest. If your system cannot do that automatically, a short note on the booking page saying regulars can call to book without a deposit goes a long way.

Watch the pub trade especially, where a Sunday lunch regular is the business. No-shows at pubs covers lighter-touch options that suit them.

Frequently asked questions

Do deposits reduce restaurant bookings?

They can, especially for casual bookings or when the deposit is a surprise late in the booking flow. They often reduce no-shows by more than they reduce bookings for large parties and peak dates. Test on your own slots to find out.

Is there UK research on how guests feel about deposits?

There is no reliable public study for UK restaurants. Survey figures from software suppliers exist but are not independent, so a short test on your own bookings is the better guide.

Do we have to show a booking fee upfront?

Yes. The total price shown when you invite guests to book must include fees they will necessarily pay. Show any deposit and its refund rule at the start of the booking flow too.

How long should a deposit test run?

Four to six weeks is usually enough, avoiding bank holidays and big local events, with everything apart from the deposit kept the same.

References

  1. Office for National Statistics (2025). Family spending in the UK: financial year ending 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2024). Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 230: omission of material information from invitation to purchase (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Competition and Markets Authority (2026). Unfair contract terms: guidance on the unfair contract terms provisions in the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CMA37) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo