Key takeaways
- Let the guest finish before you say anything beyond "I'm listening". Most complaint calls go wrong in the first minute.
- Log the facts while they talk: date, time, table, dishes, staff and what they want to happen.
- A sincere apology is not, of itself, an admission of negligence in England and Wales. Say sorry for the experience; do not speculate about causes.
- End every call with one clear next step, a named person and a time, and do not trade refunds for review changes.
Why complaint calls matter
A guest who rings to complain is giving you a second chance. Many unhappy guests never say anything; they leave a review or simply do not come back. A caller wants something from you, which means there is still something you can do.
Expectations are high. Consumer confidence that restaurants ensure food is safe to eat rose from 73% in 2023 to 84% in 2025[1]. Guests arrive expecting things to go right, so when something goes wrong, it feels like a broken promise rather than bad luck.
Source: Food Standards Agency, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2023 | 73% |
| 2025 | 84% |
The legal baseline is simple too. Every contract to supply a service, including a meal, includes a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill[2]. Most complaints are not legal disputes, but it helps staff to know that the guest's expectation of a properly cooked meal served with care is backed by law.
The first minute
Most complaint calls are won or lost in the first minute. The guest has usually rehearsed what they want to say. Let them say it.
- Introduce yourself by name: "This is Priya, I'm one of the supervisors."
- Say you are listening, then listen: "I'm sorry to hear something went wrong. Please tell me what happened."
- Do not interrupt, explain, or correct details while they are talking.
- Make short listening sounds so they know you are still there.
- Write down what they say as they say it.
- When they finish, summarise it back: "So you were booked for 7.30 on Saturday, the mains took over an hour, and the steak was cold when it came. Have I got that right?"
That summary does more than any apology. It shows the guest they have been heard, and it gives you an accurate record.
Log the facts
Log every complaint in the same format, whether it comes by phone, email or at the table. A consistent log helps you respond fairly and spot patterns.
| Field | Example entry |
|---|---|
| Date and time of the call | Tue 10 Nov, 11.15am |
| Guest name and contact number | Example guest, mobile on file |
| Date and time of the visit | Sat 7 Nov, 7.30pm booking |
| Table, party size and server | Table 14, 4 covers, server Josh |
| What happened, in their words | Mains took over an hour, steak cold |
| What they want | Partial refund and an apology from the manager |
| What was said on the call | Apologised for the experience, manager to call |
| Next step, owner and deadline | Manager Ellie to call by 4pm today |
| Outcome | Filled in when resolved |
Check the guest's details against the booking and the till record before the manager calls back. It is easier to resolve a complaint when you already know what was ordered and when.
Apologise without admitting liability
Staff often avoid apologising because they fear it admits fault. In England and Wales, the law is clear that an apology, an offer of treatment or other redress does not of itself amount to an admission of negligence or breach of statutory duty[3]. You can and should say sorry.
What to avoid is speculation about causes. There is a difference between "I'm so sorry your evening went like that" and "the chef must have used the wrong oil". The first is an apology. The second is a guess that might be wrong and that you might later regret.
| Situation | Say | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Slow service | "I'm sorry you waited so long. That's not the evening we want for anyone." | "Saturday was mad, we were short-staffed." |
| Food quality | "I'm sorry the steak wasn't right. Thank you for telling us." | "Nobody else complained." |
| Rude staff | "I'm sorry you were spoken to like that. I'll make sure the manager looks into it." | "That doesn't sound like Josh." |
| Illness | "I'm sorry you've been unwell. I want to take some details so our manager can look into it properly." | "It can't have been our food." |
| Allergen issue | "Thank you for telling us. This is serious and I'm passing it to the manager now." | "We did tell you it might contain nuts." |
| Booking error | "I'm sorry we didn't have your table. Let me see what happened." | "You must have booked somewhere else." |
Agree one clear next step
End every complaint call with one clear next step, a named person and a time. Vague promises ("someone will be in touch") make an unhappy guest angrier.
Decide who owns it
Simple complaints can be resolved by a supervisor. Refunds, compensation, illness, allergen incidents and disputes go to the manager.
Say what happens next
"Our manager, Ellie, will call you by 4pm today to talk about how we can put this right."
Confirm the number
Read it back, and check it is a good time to call.
Keep the promise
The manager calls when promised, even if only to say they need more time.
Agree the remedy
Offer what is fair for what went wrong, such as a partial refund, a replacement visit or a written apology.
Close the log
Record the outcome and anything the team should change.
For services not performed with reasonable care and skill, the Consumer Rights Act gives consumers remedies such as repeat performance or a price reduction. In practice, offering to put things right promptly and fairly usually resolves the complaint long before anyone thinks about the law.
Complaints that need extra care
Some complaints carry more risk than a slow main course, and the person who answers should recognise them and pass them on at once.
Illness after a meal needs careful notes and no speculation. Record the dishes, the time symptoms started, what they were, who else ate the same food and whether the guest has seen a doctor. Pass it to the manager the same day. The manager may need to check food safety records, speak to the kitchen and inform the insurer, depending on your policy.
An allergic reaction is more urgent still. If the guest is describing a reaction that is happening now, tell them to call 999 or seek medical help before anything else. Afterwards, record which dishes were eaten, what was said about allergens at the time, and who served them, and pass it to the manager immediately.
Complaints about how a guest was treated because of a disability, race, religion or another personal characteristic should also go straight to the manager. Listen, record exactly what the guest says happened, and do not defend the member of staff on the call.
Damage or loss, such as a coat stained by a spilt drink or a bag that went missing, needs the details and any photos the guest can send, and a clear statement of who will decide what happens next.
Follow up in writing
After the manager's call, send a short written follow-up. It confirms what was agreed and shows the guest the complaint was taken seriously.
Example: "Dear Ms Example, thank you for speaking to me today about your visit on Saturday. I'm sorry the evening didn't go as it should have. As agreed, I've refunded the cost of your main courses to your card, and we'd love to welcome you back. I've also spoken to the kitchen team about the timings that night. Kind regards, Ellie, General Manager."
Keep it brief and specific. Do not repeat the whole complaint or add explanations the guest did not ask for.
Reviews: what you must not do
Many complaint callers have already left a review, or are about to. It is tempting to offer a free meal if they will take it down. Do not.
CMA guidance treats concealed incentivised reviews, such as a review written in exchange for money or a freebie without saying so, as banned content[4]. Asking a guest to change a review in exchange for compensation risks the same problem. Put things right because it is right, and let the guest decide what to write. If they update their review on their own, that is their choice.
- Do reply publicly to the review, briefly and politely, saying you are sorry and have been in touch.
- Do not argue or share private details in a public reply.
- Do not make any offer conditional on the review being changed or removed.
Abusive callers and protecting staff
Most unhappy guests are reasonable. A few are not. Staff should know they do not have to take abuse. Since 30 October 2026, employers must take all reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment of their staff and can be liable for harassment by third parties such as customers unless they have done so[5].
- Give staff one calm line: "I want to help, but I'll have to end the call if you keep speaking to me like that."
- Give them permission to end the call if the abuse continues.
- Log the call, with the number and what was said, and pass it to a manager.
- Have the manager follow up in writing if appropriate, and check on the member of staff.
Learn from the log
Once a month, read through the complaint log with the management team. Look for patterns rather than individual mistakes: slow mains on Saturdays, a dish that keeps coming back, confusion about deposits, calls about the same staff member. Fix the cause, then tell the team what changed and why. A complaint that leads to a fix is the most useful feedback you will get all month.
Frequently asked questions
Should the person who answers deal with the complaint?
They should listen, log the details and apologise for the experience. Anything involving a refund, compensation, illness or a dispute about what happened should go to the manager, with a callback the same day.
Can we offer a free meal if the guest changes their review?
No. Offering something in exchange for removing or changing a review, without that being clear to readers, risks breaching consumer protection law. You can put things right for the guest; you cannot make it conditional on what they write.
What if the guest says they were ill after eating with us?
Take it seriously and stay calm. Record the details (date, dishes, symptoms, when they started, who else ate the same food), do not speculate about the cause, and pass it to the manager immediately. Your manager may need to inform your insurer and review your food safety records.
What if the caller is abusive?
Staff can say once, calmly, that they want to help but will end the call if the abuse continues, and then end it if it does. Log the call and pass it to a manager. Employers have duties to protect staff from harassment, including by customers.
References
Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2 Annual Report: Wave 11 (2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49: service to be performed with reasonable care and skill (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2006). Compensation Act 2006, section 2: apologies, offers of treatment or other redress (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Acas (2026). Employment Rights Act 2025: what is changing and when (opens in a new tab) ↑