Takeaway, delivery and collection

Phone orders vs app orders: which make more money?

Margin per order by channel for a UK takeaway: phone, own delivery, app delivery and app collection, worked through an Example with VAT and staff time.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The question behind the question
  2. What to count for every channel
  3. A worked Example
  4. Why the per-order view is not the whole answer
  5. Moving regulars to direct ordering
  6. The hidden costs of the phone
  7. Measure your own mix for four weeks
  8. Deciding your channel mix
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. References

Key takeaways

  • Per order, a phone or direct collection order usually leaves far more contribution than a marketplace delivery order once commission is counted.
  • App orders still earn their place when they bring customers who would never have phoned. The loss comes when regulars drift from phone to app.
  • Hot takeaway food is standard-rated for VAT, so always work margins from net sales, not the till total.
  • The phone only wins if it is answered. A missed call on a Friday is a lost order or a push towards the app.

The question behind the question

Delivery, takeaway and click-and-collect accounted for 20.9% of consumer spending with restaurants in September 2026, and deliveries took nearly three quarters of that[1]. Inside that total, the channels are moving in opposite directions: delivery sales rose 5.8% like-for-like while takeaway and click-and-collect revenue fell 6.3%, its 18th consecutive monthly fall[2].

Consumer spending with restaurants by where it was eaten, September 2026Eaten-in share is the remainder of the at-home figure
Consumer spending with restaurants by where it was eaten, September 2026Donut chart. Delivery, takeaway and click-and-collect: 20.9%; Eaten in: 79.1%.Delivery, takeaway and click-and-collect: 20.9%Eaten in: 79.1%20.9% at home
  • Delivery, takeaway and click-and-collect 20.9%
  • Eaten in 79.1%

Source: NIQ (CGA by NIQ), 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Delivery, takeaway and click-and-collect20.9%
Eaten in79.1%

So the real question for a takeaway or restaurant is not whether apps are good or bad. It is which orders you want through which door, and what each door costs. The only way to answer that is to work out contribution per order by channel using your own numbers.

What to count for every channel

Contribution per order is what is left from the net sale after the costs that only exist because that order happened. Fixed costs such as rent and the chef's salary do not belong in this calculation; they are paid whatever the channel.

  • VAT: catering supplies, including hot takeaway food, are standard-rated[3]. On an order of hot food, one sixth of the total is VAT and never yours.
  • Food and packaging cost: the same dish costs the same to make whichever channel it came through, though some kitchens use sturdier packaging for delivery.
  • Commission and service fees: whatever your platform contract charges, often a different rate for delivery by the platform's riders, delivery by your own riders, and collection.
  • Payment fees: card or online payment charges on direct orders.
  • Staff time: the minutes spent taking a phone order, at your actual hourly rate. The National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour from April 2026[4].
  • Delivery cost: your own driver's pay, fuel or mileage per drop, less any delivery charge you collect.
  • Refunds and errors: the share of orders refunded or remade, which tends to be higher on the busiest channel.

A worked Example

Example: a fictional takeaway with an average order of £25 including VAT, food and packaging at 32% of net sales, and illustrative commission rates. These rates are assumptions for the arithmetic, not any platform's actual terms; use the figures in your own contract.

Example: contribution per £25 order by channel for a fictional takeaway, using assumed rates
Line (Example figures)Phone, collectedPhone, own driverApp, platform deliveryApp, collection
Order value incl. VAT£25.00£25.00£25.00£25.00
Less VAT on hot food (one sixth)£4.17£4.17£4.17£4.17
Net sales£20.83£20.83£20.83£20.83
Food and packaging (32%)£6.67£6.67£6.67£6.67
Commission (assumed 30% delivery, 15% collection, on order value)£0.00£0.00£7.50£3.75
Payment fee (assumed)£0.40£0.40£0.00£0.00
Staff time, 3 minutes at £12.71 an hour£0.64£0.64£0.00£0.00
Own driver cost per drop (assumed)£0.00£3.50£0.00£0.00
Contribution per order£13.12£9.62£6.66£10.41

In this Example a phone order collected by the customer leaves roughly twice the contribution of an app delivery order. Even after paying its own driver, the phone delivery order beats the app delivery order. App collection sits in between.

Run the same table with your own contract rates, average order value and food cost. Change one line at a time to see which assumption moves the answer most; for most takeaways it is the commission rate.

Why the per-order view is not the whole answer

If every app order were a customer who would otherwise have phoned, the case would be simple. They are not. Apps put you in front of people who have never heard of you, and in the Example an order from a new customer that leaves £6.66 is still better than no order at all.

The useful split is between incremental orders and displaced orders.

Not every app order is equal: four types and how to handle them
Order typeWhat it meansHow to treat it
Incremental app orderA customer who found you on the app and would not have ordered directWelcome it; it covers fixed costs and may become a regular
Displaced app orderA regular who used to phone or collect and now taps the appWin them back to a direct channel
Peak overflowAn order that would have been a missed call on a busy nightFine on the app if the phone cannot be answered
Promotion-driven orderAn app order triggered by a discount you fundCheck the true cost; see our guide to app promotions

Example: if the fictional takeaway above takes 400 app delivery orders a month and a quarter of them come from regulars who used to phone and collect, moving those 100 orders back to the phone would add about £646 a month in contribution (100 x the £6.46 difference) without a single new customer.

Moving regulars to direct ordering

  1. Put a printed card in every bag with your direct number and online ordering link, and a reason to use it, such as a free side on direct orders.
  2. Make direct ordering as easy as the app: a short online menu, saved details and quick collection times.
  3. Ask phone and website customers for permission to send offers. Under PECR you need prior consent for marketing texts and emails, unless the soft opt-in applies to customers whose details you obtained in a sale and who are offered a simple way to opt out[5].
  4. Check your platform agreement before marketing to customers whose details came through the app; terms often restrict it.
  5. Offer a modest loyalty reward on direct orders rather than matching app discounts, so the margin advantage is not given away.

The hidden costs of the phone

Phone orders have their own leaks, and an honest comparison counts them. Orders taken on a noisy line are misheard. Allergen questions are answered from memory. Calls ring out during the rush. For food sold by phone, allergen information must be provided both before the purchase is completed and when the food is delivered[6], so the person on the phone needs a written allergen matrix, not a guess.

  • Missed calls: if the phone is not answered on a Friday, the customer opens an app or another takeaway. Track rings versus answered calls.
  • Order errors: read every order back, including modifiers and address, before ending the call.
  • Staff distraction: the person on the phone is not packing, cooking or serving; at peak that has a cost in speed and errors.
  • Payment risk: cash on delivery orders can go uncollected; card payment over the phone or a payment link is safer.

If the phone is the channel you want customers to use, it has to be answered every time. Some takeaways cover peak calls with a second line or a dedicated person, and use an AI phone assistant such as Ava to handle routine questions about opening times, collection and how to order, logging each call with a summary so the person taking orders is not tied up with enquiries.

Measure your own mix for four weeks

Most owners have a feel for which channel is busiest but not for what each one actually earns. Four weeks of simple tracking replaces the feel with numbers, and it costs nothing but a spreadsheet.

  1. Export orders by channel

    Pull order counts and gross sales for each app, your own website and the till for phone and walk-in orders. Most platforms and EPOS systems export weekly.

  2. Pull the real fees

    Use the statements, not the rate card. Statements show commission, service fees, refunds charged back to you and any promotion costs you funded.

  3. Time the phone

    For one busy night and one quiet night, note how long each phone order takes from ring to hang-up, and how many calls ring out unanswered.

  4. Ask new or regular

    For two weeks, ask phone and collection customers whether they have ordered through an app before, and check app order names against your regulars list.

  5. Fill in the table

    Rebuild the Example table with your own averages for each channel, then rank the channels by contribution per order and by total contribution.

The ranking by total contribution is often different from the ranking per order. A channel with thin margins and high volume can still matter more to the business than a richer channel few customers use. The aim is to know both numbers before deciding where to push customers.

Deciding your channel mix

There is no single right mix, but the decision criteria are the same for every operator. Keep apps if a meaningful share of their orders are incremental and the kitchen can fulfil them well. Push direct ordering hardest with regulars and local customers. Reconsider app delivery for dishes that travel badly or have thin margins. Review the mix every quarter with real data.

For more on building the menu that works across channels, see takeaway menu design for phone and online ordering, and for handling the busiest night of the week, Friday night takeaway rush.

Frequently asked questions

Are phone orders always more profitable than app orders?

Per order, usually yes, because there is no commission. But an app order from a customer who would never have called is still extra profit, so judge apps on the incremental orders they bring as well as the margin.

Should I charge more on delivery apps?

Many operators price app menus higher to cover commission. Check your platform agreement for any rules on price parity, and tell regulars that ordering direct is better value.

Do I charge VAT on takeaway food?

Hot takeaway food and catering are standard-rated. Most cold takeaway food is zero-rated, with exceptions. Work out margins on net sales after VAT and take advice on mixed orders.

Can I text app customers about offers?

Only with valid consent or under the PECR soft opt-in for your own customers, and only if your platform agreement allows you to use their details. Always give a simple way to opt out.

References

  1. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) (2026). Restaurants' delivery sales strengthen in September after tough summer (Hospitality at Home Tracker) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) (2026). Restaurants' delivery sales strengthen in September after tough summer (Hospitality at Home Tracker) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Catering, takeaway food and VAT (VAT Notice 709/1) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage rates (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo