Key takeaways
- Two sittings give predictable covers and staffing but create kitchen peaks and can feel rigid to guests.
- Open booking spreads arrivals and suits relaxed dining, but needs accurate durations and careful slot control to avoid gaps.
- Many venues do best with a hybrid: sittings on the busiest nights, open booking the rest of the week.
- Trial a change for at least four weeks and judge it on covers, kitchen ticket times and guest comments together.
Two ways to sell the evening
With fixed sittings, you sell the dining room in blocks: for example a first sitting at 6pm that must finish by 8.15, and a second sitting from 8.30. Every table turns once at a known time. With open booking, guests choose from slots throughout the evening, often every 15 minutes, and each booking holds a table for a set duration based on party size.
Both models are common in restaurants and food-led pubs. Neither is better in general. The right one depends on your kitchen, your team, your guests and how much demand you have on each night of the week.
Staffing and cost shape the choice
Every model is a staffing plan in disguise. Median hourly pay in April 2026 was £15.19 for chefs, £13.02 for kitchen and catering assistants and £12.81 for both waiting and bar staff[1][2]. Teams are also hard to fill: 11.6% of accommodation and food businesses reported a shortage of workers in mid-October 2026[3], and 10.3% said labour shortages were hitting turnover[4].
Some venues are trading fewer hours to cope. In a February 2026 survey by UKHospitality and other trade bodies, 42% of venues said the April cost rises would make them reduce trading hours[5]. When the evening is shorter, how you fill the hours you do open matters more. And evenings carry real weight in the economy: night-time spending between 6pm and 6am made up a third of total time-stamped spending in a sample week[6].
Side by side
| Factor | Two sittings | Open booking |
|---|---|---|
| Covers on a full night | Predictable: every table turns once | Can be higher if durations are tight and demand is steady, lower if gaps appear |
| Kitchen flow | Two sharp peaks as each sitting orders at once | Orders spread across the evening |
| Front-of-house staffing | Clear shifts, but intense change-overs | Steadier pace, harder to plan breaks |
| Guest choice | Limited to two or three start times | Many start times |
| Guest pace | A firm end time for the first sitting | Pace set by the duration, usually more relaxed |
| Late arrivals | Eat into a fixed window | Can push back later bookings |
| Walk-ins | Hard to fit between sittings | Easier to slot into gaps |
| Admin | Simple to run and explain | Needs good durations and slot rules |
What each does to the kitchen
Sittings concentrate demand. Forty covers sit down within twenty minutes and order within the next fifteen. A strong brigade with a menu built for it can handle that, and the predictable rhythm helps prep and staffing. A small kitchen with a long à la carte menu can fall behind in the first half hour and never catch up, so the second sitting starts late.
Open booking spreads the load, but only if you control the slots. If the booking system lets every table book at 7.30, you have a sitting by accident. Most systems let you cap covers per 15-minute slot. Set the cap from what your kitchen can plate comfortably, not from how many tables are free.
Staffing each model
The two models need different rotas. With sittings, the busiest moments are predictable: the first half hour of each sitting and the change-over between them. You can bring in an extra runner for those windows and plan breaks around them. With open booking, the pace is steadier but rarely quiet, so breaks and side work need more careful scheduling.
- Sittings: schedule the strongest host for the change-over, when the first sitting is paying and the second is arriving.
- Sittings: prep the bar for a wave of aperitifs at the start of each sitting.
- Open booking: stagger section starts so each server's tables do not all arrive at once.
- Open booking: give one person responsibility for watching slot caps and releasing tables.
- Both: brief the team on the night's covers by time, not just the total.
If your team is small or stretched, the model that suits your people may matter more than the one that looks best on paper.
What each does to covers
Example: a fictional 60-cover restaurant runs two sittings on Saturdays, 6pm and 8.30pm. On a full night that is 120 covers, regardless of how fast tables eat. With open booking from 5.30 to 9.30 and durations of two hours for twos and fours, the same room can reach a similar total if bookings arrive in a steady stream, and more if early twos finish quickly and the table is resold at 8.45.
Example: on a softer night, the picture flips. With sittings, a half-full first sitting cannot be made up later. With open booking, guests who would never book a 6pm sitting take 7.15 instead, so total covers can be higher on quieter nights. That is why many venues use sittings only when they are sure of filling both.
What guests notice
- Sittings feel organised when explained clearly, and some guests like knowing the evening's shape.
- A first sitting can feel rushed if the end time is not mentioned until dessert.
- Second-sitting guests sometimes wait while first-sitting tables are cleared; a drink at the bar helps, a crowded doorway does not.
- Open booking feels more relaxed, but guests notice if the room fills and empties unevenly or the kitchen is slow at 8pm.
- Either way, say the rules when guests book and again in the confirmation, not at the table.
Our guide to limiting table times and telling guests politely covers wording for both models.
Late arrivals and no-shows
Sittings expose late arrivals: a party arriving 30 minutes late into a two-hour first sitting has lost a quarter of its time, and the kitchen still needs to finish them before 8.30. Set a clear holding time, say 15 minutes, and tell guests in the reminder. With open booking, late arrivals can push into the next booking, so hosts need a rule on when to release a table.
No-shows cost more under sittings, because the empty table cannot be resold until the next sitting. Deposits or card guarantees for peak sittings and a day-before reminder with an easy cancel link reduce the risk. If you consider holding extra bookings to cover no-shows, read when overbooking works and when it backfires first.
Hybrid models that often work best
- Sittings on Friday and Saturday only, open booking from Sunday to Thursday.
- A fixed early sitting for pre-theatre or families, then open booking from 8pm.
- Sittings for large tables only, with smaller tables on open booking around them.
- Open booking with a cap per slot, which behaves like soft sittings without telling guests they must leave.
- Seasonal sittings in December, when demand is high and parties are large.
Which suits your restaurant
- Do you regularly fill the room twice on your busiest nights? If yes, sittings can lock in those covers.
- Can your kitchen plate a full room's first orders in under 20 minutes? If not, open booking with slot caps is safer.
- Are your durations based on real data? Open booking depends on them; see setting turn times.
- Do many guests want to eat between 7 and 8pm? Sittings at 6 and 8.30 may push them elsewhere.
- Is your offer a fixed menu, such as a tasting menu? Sittings suit a set pace.
- Do you rely on walk-ins? Open booking leaves more room for them.
How to trial a change
Pick the nights
Change one or two nights a week, not the whole week.
Brief the team
Walk the kitchen and floor through the new rhythm before the first service, including what to say to guests.
Update the booking rules
Set the slots, durations or sitting times in your booking system, and rewrite the booking page and confirmation.
Measure four weeks
Track covers, average spend, kitchen ticket times, late seatings and guest comments against the same nights before the change.
Decide and write it down
Keep, change or reverse, and record why, so the next manager does not repeat the experiment.
Example: a hybrid that stuck
Example: a fictional 80-cover bistro ran open booking every night but saw the kitchen buckle between 7.15 and 8pm on Saturdays. It trialled sittings at 6pm and 8.30pm on Saturdays only for four weeks. Covers were flat, kitchen ticket times at peak fell, and two guests mentioned feeling hurried at the end of the first sitting.
Example: the bistro kept Saturday sittings, moved the first-sitting end time from 8.15 to 8.20, added a line about it to the booking page and confirmation, and kept open booking with a cap of 16 covers per 15-minute slot on other nights. For the guest-data side of any booking change, see who owns guest data on booking platforms.
Frequently asked questions
Do two sittings make more money than open booking?
Only when both sittings fill. On busy nights they lock in two turns per table; on quieter nights open booking usually sells more covers because guests can choose a time that suits them.
How long should a first sitting be?
Long enough for most parties to finish comfortably at your menu's pace, plus time to reset. Many venues use around two hours plus a short reset, but base it on your own timings.
How do we stop open booking turning into a 7.30 rush?
Cap the number of covers that can book in each 15-minute slot, based on what your kitchen can plate comfortably.
Should we tell guests about sitting times?
Yes, when they book, in the confirmation and in the reminder. Guests accept an end time far more readily when they know about it in advance.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). ASHE 2026 provisional, Table 14.6a: hourly pay excluding overtime by occupation (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). ASHE 2026 provisional, Table 14.6a: hourly pay excluding overtime by occupation (waiting staff) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (worker shortages) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (challenges to turnover) (opens in a new tab) ↑
UKHospitality, BBPA, BII and Hospitality Ulster (2026). April cost increases will force two-thirds of hospitality to cut more jobs (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2022). The night-time economy, UK: 2022 (opens in a new tab) ↑