Key takeaways
- You must complete a check before you can challenge, and a challenge before you can appeal to the Valuation Tribunal.
- A challenge on the 2026 list is due within 4 months of a check decision, or within 16 months of the check if it is about changes in the area.
- The strongest evidence is rent and valuation data for similar nearby premises at 1 April 2024, plus accurate floor areas and photographs.
- Keep paying the bill while a case runs; any reduction is refunded or credited later.
Is it worth challenging?
Business rates are a fixed cost that does not shrink when trade does, so a wrong valuation costs you every year of the list. They are also not the only pressure: in November 2026, accommodation and food businesses ranked energy prices as their main concern (25.2%), ahead of falling demand and inflation, with business rates at 9.8%[1]. That ranking is a reminder to spend your time where the money is. A challenge is worth the effort when there is a clear, evidenced reason the value is wrong, not simply because the bill feels high.
Good reasons usually fall into four groups. The facts are wrong, such as floor areas, the layout or the description. The value is out of line with similar premises nearby. Something physical has changed, such as part of the building being closed off. Or the area has changed, for example long-running roadworks that cut footfall. A bad trading year on its own is not a ground.
1 April 2024
The rental valuation date behind every rateable value on the 2026 list[2]
The three stages and their deadlines
The process in England has three stages, each of which must be completed before the next. You need a business rates valuation account with the Valuation Office Agency to start, and setting one up can take time, so do it now even if you have not decided to challenge.
| Stage | What happens | Time limit on the 2026 list |
|---|---|---|
| Check | You confirm or correct the facts the agency holds: floor areas, layout, use, parking, rent details. | Start once you have an account; complete before challenging. |
| Challenge | You argue the value is wrong, with grounds, evidence and a proposed rateable value. | Within 4 months of the check decision; within 16 months of the check for changes in the area; or if no check decision after 12 months. |
| Appeal | An independent tribunal hears the case if you disagree with the challenge decision. | Follow the deadline in the challenge decision letter. |
The challenge time limits come from the agency's guidance: within 4 months of a check decision, within 16 months of your check submission if the challenge concerns a change in the surrounding area such as roadworks, or once 12 months have passed without a check decision[3]. Appeals go to the Valuation Tribunal for England[3].
Stage one: the check
A check is about facts, not opinions. Log in, find the property and go through every item the agency holds. For a restaurant, the details that move the value most are usually the size of each area, how each area is used, and any parking or outdoor space. For a pub, the agency may also hold trading information, and the figures you submitted will affect the value.
- Measure the property yourself or use a recent plan, and compare area by area.
- Photograph anything that reduces value: low ceilings, columns, basement areas with poor access, or space you cannot trade from.
- Confirm the rent, rent-free periods and lease terms if you rent, because the agency will ask for them.
- Correct the description if it is wrong, for example a café listed as a larger restaurant.
If the agency agrees the facts were wrong, it may change the value at the check stage and the case ends there. If it does not, or the change is not enough, you move to a challenge.
Stage two: the challenge
A challenge must include your reason, evidence that the valuation is wrong, a supporting statement, a proposed rateable value with a start date, and rent details if the property is rented[3]. You must submit all evidence together, so build the file before you start the form. Evidence can include valuations of similar local properties, legal decisions and supporting documents such as photographs[3].
Comparable valuations are often the most persuasive evidence. Look up three to five similar premises on the same or similar streets and set out, in a short table, their rateable values per square metre against yours. If yours is clearly higher with no reason such as a better corner position or larger frontage, that is your case. Avoid comparing a pub with a restaurant, or a high street unit with a retail park, because the agency will discount the comparison.
Propose a realistic figure. Example: a challenge asking for half the value, with evidence that supports a 10% reduction, is weaker than one that asks for the 10% and shows why.
A sample supporting statement
Example. This short statement shows the tone that works: factual, specific and tied to evidence. Adapt the details to your own case.
- Grounds: the rateable value is higher than comparable restaurants on the same parade and does not reflect the restricted basement kitchen.
- Evidence: valuations of four comparable units on the parade, at an average rate per square metre below ours; a floor plan; photographs of the basement access.
- Rent: lease from 2023 at a rent close to the comparables, with a three-month rent-free period.
- Proposed value: a figure in line with the comparables, effective from 1 April 2026.
Pubs and other trade-valued premises
For pubs, the valuation generally follows the level of trade a reasonably efficient operator could achieve, so the debate is about that level of trade, not just floor area. Useful evidence includes the effect of a local factor that any operator would face, such as the loss of a car park or a new restriction on opening hours, and trading information for comparable pubs if you can get it. Check also that your property is in the right multiplier band: properties below £51,000 use the lower small hospitality multiplier and those from £51,000 to £499,999 the standard one[4]. A value just over £51,000 costs more than the extra value alone suggests, because the whole bill moves to the higher multiplier.
After the decision
If the agency agrees with you, it changes the rating list and your council issues an amended bill, usually with a credit for overpaid instalments. Check the new figure, the effective date and the multiplier band on the amended bill, because a reduction that takes you below £51,000 also changes the multiplier[4]. If the agency rejects the challenge or offers less than you think is right, read the reasons carefully before deciding whether to appeal. Many decisions turn on one piece of evidence the agency found weaker than you did, and sometimes a better comparable is all that is needed. An appeal is a formal hearing, so weigh the likely saving over the remaining years of the list against the time it will take. Whatever the outcome, keep the file: the evidence you gathered will be useful at the next revaluation, and the comparables rarely change much from one list to the next.
Agents, fees and keeping control
You can run a check and challenge yourself, and for a single small venue with a clear error many owners do. For larger or trade-valued premises, a surveyor who specialises in rating can help. Be cautious with unsolicited calls offering to cut your rates, ask for an upfront fee, and check that any adviser is a member of a recognised professional body. Agree in writing how fees are calculated, especially for success fees based on savings over several years.
Whoever runs the case, keep paying your bill while it is open. If the value is reduced, the council recalculates the bill and refunds or credits the overpayment. The retail, hospitality and leisure multipliers are 5p below the national ones from April 2026[5], so any reduction in value is multiplied by a lower figure than before, and the cash saving from a challenge is a little smaller than it would have been under the old rates. Work out the realistic saving before you commit to paying an adviser.
Related reading
Before you challenge, make sure the rest of the bill is right using how business rates are worked out for pubs and restaurants and business rates relief for hospitality. If you are reviewing all your fixed costs, cutting energy use in a commercial kitchen and employer National Insurance: managing the higher bill cover the other big lines.
Frequently asked questions
Can I challenge my rateable value because trade has fallen?
Not on that ground alone. Valuations are based on rental values at the valuation date and what a reasonably efficient operator could achieve, so you need evidence such as wrong facts, out-of-line comparables or a physical or local change.
How long do I have to challenge after a check?
On the 2026 list, within 4 months of the check decision. If the challenge is about changes in the area, you have 16 months from the check submission.
Do I have to keep paying while I challenge?
Yes. Keep paying the bill as issued. If the value is reduced, the council recalculates and refunds or credits the difference.
Do I need an agent to challenge?
No. You can do it yourself through a business rates valuation account. A specialist can help with complex or trade-valued premises, but agree fees in writing first.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs and Valuation Office Agency (2026). Help with the 2026 business rates revaluation (opens in a new tab) ↑
Valuation Office Agency (2026). Challenge the valuation (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Treasury (2026). Business Rates Multipliers: Qualifying Retail, Hospitality or Leisure (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Treasury (2026). Business Rates Multipliers: Qualifying Retail, Hospitality or Leisure (opens in a new tab) ↑