Key takeaways
- Most disputes are won or lost before the booking date: on what the guest was shown, agreed to and sent.
- Keep a standard evidence pack for every charged no-show: booking record, terms shown, consent, confirmation, reminders and proof the table was not used.
- Where a guest authorised a charge without an exact amount, their bank must refund if it exceeded what they could reasonably expect, so always state the figure.
- Refund quickly when your evidence is thin or you resold the table; fighting weak cases costs more than it recovers.
How a no-show dispute reaches you
A guest who is unhappy about a no-show charge rarely calls you first. They call their bank or tap "dispute" in their banking app. The bank then asks your payment provider for evidence, and your provider asks you, usually with a short deadline. If you cannot show quickly that the guest agreed to the charge and broke the terms, the money goes back.
There is also a statutory route. Under the Payment Services Regulations, where the guest authorised a payment without the exact amount being specified and the amount charged exceeded what they could reasonably have expected, they are entitled to a refund from their own bank[1]. They must ask within 8 weeks of the money being debited, and the bank must either refund or justify refusing within 10 business days[2]. Card scheme dispute rules sit alongside this and have their own deadlines, which your provider can tell you.
Why it is worth getting right
A lost dispute does more than reverse the fee. Providers often add a dispute charge, the time spent gathering evidence is time out of service, and a pattern of disputes can lead a provider to review your account. With thin cash buffers across the sector, small sums matter: in October 2026, 20% of accommodation and food businesses had no cash reserves, against 14.4% of all businesses[3].
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Accommodation and food | 20% |
| All businesses | 14.4% |
The evidence pack
Build the same pack for every no-show you charge, at the time you charge it, not when the dispute arrives three weeks later.
- The booking record: date and time made, channel (online, phone, walk-in), name, party size, contact details.
- The terms shown at booking: a dated screenshot or saved copy of the booking page or policy text in force that day.
- Proof of consent: the ticked box or button, or for phone bookings a note of the exact sentence read to the guest and their agreement.
- The confirmation sent: a copy of the email or text with the charge stated, and its delivery status.
- The reminder log: when reminders were sent, and any replies or silence.
- Proof the table went unused: the table plan or till record showing it never opened, and the time you released it.
- The charge notice: the message you sent the guest when you applied the charge.
Most booking platforms can export most of this. Check now, before you need it, what yours keeps and for how long.
Matching evidence to the reason for the dispute
| What the guest tells their bank | What usually wins it |
|---|---|
| I did not authorise this charge | Consent record, terms shown at booking, confirmation with the amount |
| I cancelled in time | Cancellation log showing no cancellation, or one after the deadline, with timestamps |
| The amount was more than I expected | The exact per-head or per-table figure shown at booking and in the confirmation |
| I was never told about a charge | Dated copy of the booking page and the confirmation text or email |
| We arrived but were turned away | Table plan, release time, staff note and the hold period stated in your terms |
Phone bookings need extra care
Online bookings leave a trail by default. Phone bookings do not, unless you build one. When taking a booking that carries a charge, staff should read one fixed sentence, for example "There's a £15 per person charge if you cancel within 24 hours or don't arrive. Is that OK?", wait for a yes, and note it on the booking with their initials and the time.
Then send the written confirmation straight away, with the same sentence in it. If Ava answers your phone, each call is logged with a summary and transcript, which gives you a record of what was said on the call.
What your payment provider can and cannot do
Your booking or payment provider sits between you and the guest's bank. It passes the dispute to you, collects your evidence and submits it, but it does not decide the outcome and it cannot make a weak case strong. Ask it three questions before you rely on it: how long you have to respond to a dispute, what evidence it can export for you automatically, and whether it charges a fee per dispute whatever the result.
Also ask how card-on-file charges are flagged. A charge that the provider marks as a merchant-initiated payment against a stored card, with the booking reference attached, is easier for the guest's bank to understand than an anonymous card-not-present payment taken days after the event. If your provider cannot attach a booking reference to the charge, add it to the description the guest will see on their statement.
Keep reminders clean
Your reminder log is evidence that the guest knew about the booking and the deadline. Keep those messages purely about the booking. Under PECR, marketing texts and emails to individuals need prior consent[4]; a reminder that also promotes a new menu muddies both your compliance and your evidence. Send offers separately, to people who agreed to receive them.
Writing the response
Open with a five-line summary
Booking date, party size, terms agreed, reminders sent, and the fact that nobody arrived or cancelled.
Attach evidence in the same order
Number each attachment and refer to it in the summary, so the reviewer does not have to search.
Quote your terms exactly
Paste the policy text as shown at booking, not a summary of it.
Stay factual
Leave out comments about the guest's character or other no-shows. Reviewers decide on evidence, not frustration.
Submit early
Do not wait for the deadline. Late responses are usually lost by default.
Example summary: Table for 6 booked online on 2 November for 16 November at 7.30pm. Guest ticked to accept a £15 per person no-show charge (attachment 1, booking page as shown that day). Confirmation sent 2 November (attachment 2). Reminders sent 15 and 16 November with no reply (attachment 3). Table released at 7.50pm and not used (attachment 4). Charge of £90 applied 17 November and guest notified (attachment 5).
Example: one dispute from start to finish
Example: a guest disputes a £60 charge for a table of four, saying they never agreed to a fee. The restaurant receives the notice from its provider on a Monday with seven days to respond. The duty manager exports the booking record, the dated booking page showing the charge next to the card field, the confirmation email and two reminder texts, and the table plan showing the table released at 8.15pm. She writes a five-line summary and submits on Tuesday.
Two weeks later the provider reports the dispute was decided in the restaurant's favour. The same month, a second dispute arrives where the confirmation email had not stated the amount because of a template error. The manager refunds that one immediately, fixes the template, and adds a monthly check of a test booking to the closing routine.
When to refund instead of fighting
Some disputes are not worth defending. The CMA's guidance says charges are more likely to be fair when they reflect the trader's real loss, including any ability to reduce it by finding another customer[5]. If you resold the table, your evidence is patchy, or the guest has a credible emergency, refunding promptly and politely is usually better business than a fight.
- You cannot find proof the guest saw the charge before booking.
- The confirmation did not state the amount.
- The table was refilled within the hour.
- The guest called to cancel and the call was missed.
- The guest is a regular whose goodwill is worth more than the fee.
A prevention checklist
- State the exact charge next to the card field and in the confirmation.
- Save a dated copy of your booking page and policy each time you change them.
- Use a fixed consent sentence for phone bookings and log the yes.
- Send a reminder before the free cancellation window closes.
- Charge within a day of the no-show and tell the guest the same day.
- Store each evidence pack where anyone on the management team can find it.
Clear wording does most of the work. If yours needs attention, start with writing a cancellation policy guests will accept, and check the figure itself against how much a no-show fee should be.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a guest have to dispute a no-show charge?
Under the Payment Services Regulations, a guest claiming a refund for a charge whose amount was not specified must ask their bank within 8 weeks. Card scheme dispute rules have their own time limits, which your payment provider can confirm.
Do we need a signature to prove consent?
No. For online bookings a ticked box or confirmation button with the terms shown is normal. For phone bookings, a fixed consent sentence, a staff note of the guest's agreement and an immediate written confirmation are the practical equivalent.
What if the guest says they cancelled by phone?
Check your call records and cancellation log. If a call came in and was missed, or there is any doubt, refunding is usually the right decision.
Should we charge the card straight after a no-show?
Charge within a day or so and notify the guest the same day. A prompt, polite notice stating the terms often prevents a dispute altogether.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). Payment Services Regulations 2017, regulation 79: refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2017). Payment Services Regulations 2017, regulation 80: requests for refunds for payment transactions initiated by or through a payee (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2026). Unfair contract terms: guidance on the unfair contract terms provisions in the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CMA37) (opens in a new tab) ↑