No-shows, deposits and cancellations

Refunding deposits: when you must and when you can keep them

When a restaurant must refund a booking deposit and when it can keep it: venue cancellations, illness, frustrated contracts, partial refunds and vouchers.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The principle behind every refund decision
  2. When you must refund
  3. When nobody is at fault
  4. Venues cancel more often than they think
  5. When you can usually keep the deposit
  6. The grey areas
  7. How to refund well
  8. Bookings taken through a platform or third party
  9. Vouchers and credit instead of refunds
  10. What front-of-house staff should know
  11. A worked example
  12. Write your refund rules down
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. References

Key takeaways

  • If you cancel or cannot provide what was booked, refund in full and quickly; keeping the deposit then is very hard to defend.
  • If neither side is at fault and the booking cannot go ahead, the Frustrated Contracts Act generally lets the guest recover sums paid, with a possible allowance for your expenses.
  • Keep a deposit only in the circumstances your terms clearly set out, and only when it reflects a real loss.
  • Offer vouchers as an option, never as the only answer when the venue is the one cancelling.

The principle behind every refund decision

A deposit is not income until the meal is served. Until then it is the guest's money held against a promise: theirs to turn up, yours to provide the table. Most refund questions are answered by asking who broke that promise, whether anyone did, and what your terms said would happen.

Get this right and refunds become routine admin. Get it wrong and a few pounds turn into a chargeback, a complaint to trading standards or a review that stays on your profile for years.

When you must refund

  • You cancel the booking, close for the night, or cannot provide what was booked, such as the private room or the set menu.
  • The guest cancels inside the free cancellation window your terms allow.
  • Your terms were not shown before booking, or did not say the deposit could be kept in these circumstances.
  • The booking cannot go ahead because of something neither of you caused, such as a government closure order or a fire next door.

The first case is the clearest. The Consumer Rights Act grey list names terms that let a trader keep a consumer's payment when the consumer cancels, without giving the consumer equivalent compensation when the trader cancels[1]. The CMA's guidance adds that where a trader's breach removes the value of the contract, the consumer is normally entitled to a swift, full refund of prepayments, and possibly compensation[2].

When nobody is at fault

Some bookings fail through no fault of either side: a local power cut, a flood, a closure order. In law the contract may then be frustrated. In England and Wales, under the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, sums paid before that point are generally recoverable, but a court may allow the business to keep some or all of the money, up to the expenses it incurred in performing the contract, if it considers that just[3].

Scotland and Northern Ireland apply their own rules, with a similar starting point. In practice that means a full refund is the default, and keeping part of a deposit needs real, documented costs, such as a bespoke cake already made or specially ordered produce. Most venues simply refund, because the sums are small and the goodwill is not.

Venues cancel more often than they think

Refunds are not only about guests letting you down. Staff shortages, weather and building problems close kitchens and rooms every week somewhere. In October 2026, 10.3% of accommodation and food businesses said labour shortages were affecting turnover and 10.6% cited weather conditions[4].

Factors hitting turnover, accommodation and food, October 2026Share of businesses. Both can force a venue to cancel bookings.
Factors hitting turnover, accommodation and food, October 2026Comparison. Weather conditions: 10.6%; Labour shortages: 10.3%.10.6%Weather conditionsWeather conditions: 10.6%10.3%Labour shortagesLabour shortages: 10.3%Factors hitting turnover, accommodation and food, October 2026Comparison. Weather conditions: 10.6%; Labour shortages: 10.3%.10.6%Weather conditionsWeather conditions: 10.6%10.3%Labour shortagesLabour shortages: 10.3%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Weather conditions10.6%
Labour shortages10.3%

Plan for your own cancellations as carefully as for guests'. Decide in advance who contacts affected guests, how refunds are processed and what you offer as well, such as a priority rebooking.

When you can usually keep the deposit

You are on firmest ground when all of these are true: the guest saw the terms before booking, the terms say clearly when the deposit is kept, the guest cancelled after the notice period or did not arrive, and the amount reflects a real loss. The CMA expects the circumstances for keeping a deposit to be clear and narrow, and the deposit itself to be modest, normally a small percentage of the price[2].

Even then, keeping it is a right, not a duty. If you resell the table, the case for keeping the full deposit weakens, because your loss has shrunk.

The grey areas

Common borderline cases and a fair default for each. Your written terms come first.
SituationUsual approachWhy
Guest falls ill on the dayOffer to move the booking; keep the deposit only if terms allow and you cannot resellYour terms decide, but flexibility keeps the guest
Bereavement or family emergencyRefund or move the bookingThe goodwill is worth far more than the deposit
Rail strike or severe weather, venue openMove the booking or refund if most guests are affectedNot frustration, but keeping deposits looks harsh
Party arrives smaller than bookedKeep deposits only for missing guests beyond your stated allowanceMatches the loss to the gap
Guest arrives 45 minutes lateSeat them if you can; if the table was released under your terms, refund or keep as the terms sayThe hold period should be stated at booking
You moved them to a worse table or roomPartial refund or a gesture on the nightYou did not provide what was booked

How to refund well

  1. Use the original payment method

    Refund to the card or account the deposit came from. It is quicker and leaves a clean record.

  2. Act within days, not weeks

    Set a target, such as five working days, and say it in your terms.

  3. Tell the guest what you have done

    Send a short message with the amount, the date and how long their bank may take.

  4. Record the reason

    Note why the refund was made, so you can see patterns and adjust your terms.

  5. Offer a way back

    Where you cancelled, offer a priority rebooking or a small gesture next time.

Bookings taken through a platform or third party

If guests book through a reservations platform or an events site, check who actually holds the deposit and who processes refunds. Sometimes the money sits with the platform until the booking date; sometimes it is paid straight to you. Either way, the guest sees your name on the booking and will hold you responsible for a slow or refused refund.

Make sure the refund rules configured on the platform match the terms on your own website. If the platform automatically refunds anyone who cancels 24 hours ahead but your website promises 48 hours, guests who read your website will feel misled when the platform keeps their money, and you will be the one answering the complaint.

Vouchers and credit instead of refunds

Credit notes and vouchers can work well when the guest asks to move the booking. They keep the money in the business and the guest in the diary. They should be the guest's choice, though. If you are the one cancelling, offering only a voucher looks like keeping their money for your convenience. Offer the refund first and the voucher as an alternative, and give the voucher a sensible expiry date.

If you do issue vouchers, keep a simple register: the guest's name, the amount, the date issued, the expiry date and the original booking it replaced. Without one, vouchers get honoured twice, refused by staff who do not recognise them, or forgotten until a guest turns up with a screenshot and a grievance. Review the register monthly and remind guests before their voucher runs out.

What front-of-house staff should know

Most refund conversations start at the door or on the phone, not in the office. Staff do not need to make refund decisions, but they do need to know enough not to make promises the business cannot keep or refuse refunds the guest is entitled to.

  • The one-line version of your deposit terms, word for word.
  • Who can authorise a refund outside the terms, and how to reach them during service.
  • That a guest whose booking the venue cancelled always gets a full refund, without argument.
  • How to log a refund request so it is not lost between shifts.
  • To say "I'll make sure the manager sees this today" rather than "no refunds" when unsure.

A short briefing at the start of each busy season, with two or three real examples from last year, is usually enough to keep everyone consistent.

A worked example

Example: a restaurant takes a £20 per person deposit for a table of six on a Saturday. On Friday, two chefs call in sick and the owner reduces covers for the night. The table is cancelled by the venue, so all £120 is refunded the same day, with an offer of a table the following Saturday. Separately, a couple who booked a £10 per person table cancel at 4pm on the day, inside the 24-hour window; the table is resold at 7pm, and the owner refunds their deposit too, noting both decisions in the booking system.

Write your refund rules down

Guests and staff should be able to predict a refund decision from your terms. Add three sentences to your policy: when the deposit is refunded, when it is kept, and what happens if you cancel. Then make sure the person processing refunds can see those sentences. For the wider policy, see writing a cancellation policy guests will accept, and for peak dates, deposits for Christmas and other peak dates.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to refund a deposit if the guest is ill?

Not necessarily; your terms decide. Many venues offer to move the booking instead, and refund if they cannot resell the table, because a sick guest who is treated kindly usually comes back.

Can we offer a voucher instead of a refund?

You can offer one, and many guests accept. If the venue cancelled, offer a refund first and the voucher as an option, not instead.

How quickly should we refund a deposit?

As quickly as you can, ideally within a few working days, and say the timescale in your terms. Slow refunds are a common cause of disputes and poor reviews.

What if we cancel because of a power cut?

Refund in full. A booking that cannot go ahead through no fault of the guest should not cost them anything.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, Schedule 2: consumer contract terms which may be regarded as unfair (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Competition and Markets Authority (2026). Unfair contract terms: guidance on the unfair contract terms provisions in the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CMA37) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1943). Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943, section 1 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo