Tax, costs and finance

Choosing an accountant for your restaurant

How to choose an accountant for a restaurant, pub or café: services you need, hospitality knowledge to test, questions to ask and how to compare quotes.

Ava research teamPublished 6 min read

On this page
  1. Why the choice matters more in hospitality
  2. Work out what you actually need
  3. Check credentials before anything else
  4. Test for hospitality knowledge
  5. Compare proposals properly
  6. Read the engagement letter
  7. Red flags
  8. Switching accountants
  9. Making the relationship work
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Only 20% of accommodation and food SME employers sought business advice in 2025, the lowest of any sector; of those that did, 47% used their accountant.
  • Anyone can call themselves an accountant. Check membership of a recognised professional body, professional indemnity insurance and anti-money laundering supervision.
  • Test for hospitality knowledge: VAT on hot and cold food, tronc, stock and gross profit, payroll for variable hours and Making Tax Digital.
  • Compare proposals on a written scope of work, not on the headline fee.

Why the choice matters more in hospitality

A good accountant does more than file accounts. In a restaurant or pub, they help you price for margin, read a stocktake, run payroll for staff on variable hours, deal with mixed VAT rates on food and drink, and spot cash problems before they become a crisis. A poor one files late, misses reliefs and leaves you to discover problems through HMRC letters.

Hospitality owners are less likely than most to take advice. Only 20% of accommodation and food SME employers sought business information or advice in 2025, the lowest of any sector[1]. Among those that did, 47% used their accountant, compared with 25% who used business networks or trade associations[2][3]. For many small venues, the accountant is the only adviser they have, which makes choosing well important.

Where accommodation and food SME employers that sought advice went, 2025
Where accommodation and food SME employers that sought advice went, 2025Comparison. Their accountant: 47%; Business networks or trade associations: 25%.47%Their accountantTheir accountant: 47%25%Business networks or trade associationsBusiness networks or trade associations: 25%Where accommodation and food SME employers that sought advice went, 2025Comparison. Their accountant: 47%; Business networks or trade associations: 25%.47%Their accountantTheir accountant: 47%25%Business networks or tradeassociationsBusiness networks or trade associations: 25%

Source: Department for Business and Trade, 2025[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Their accountant47%
Business networks or trade associations25%

Work out what you actually need

Before you ask for quotes, list the work. A new café run by a sole trader needs very different support from a limited company running three pubs.

Accounting services a restaurant, pub or café may need, and who usually needs each one.
ServiceWho usually needs itNotes
Year-end accounts and tax returnEvery businessCompany accounts and Corporation Tax return, or the owner's Self Assessment
VAT returnsVAT-registered businessesFiled through software under Making Tax Digital for VAT
Making Tax Digital for Income TaxSole traders and landlords over the thresholdQuarterly updates plus the end-of-year return
Payroll and auto-enrolmentEvery employerWeekly or monthly runs, RTI submissions, pensions
BookkeepingOwners without time or skills to keep recordsCan be done in-house with software and reviewed monthly
Management accountsBusinesses wanting monthly figuresProfit, gross margin and cash monthly, not just yearly
Tronc administrationVenues with significant tips or service chargeUsually run by a troncmaster; the accountant can advise on set-up
Advice and planningOwners making decisions on structure, funding or saleOften charged separately from compliance work

Making Tax Digital adds to the list for many sole traders. Those with qualifying income over £50,000 should have started using it from 6 April 2026, with the threshold falling to £30,000 from April 2027 and £20,000 from April 2028[4]. If you are a sole trader, ask every accountant how they will handle your quarterly updates and what software they support.

Check credentials before anything else

The word accountant is not a protected title in the UK, so anyone can use it. Chartered and certified titles are protected by the professional bodies that award them. Before you go further with any firm, check three things.

  • Professional body membership: for example ICAEW, ACCA, ICAS, CIMA or AAT for licensed members. Check the individual or firm on the body's online register.
  • Professional indemnity insurance: ask for confirmation of cover. If an error costs you money, this is what protects you.
  • Anti-money laundering supervision: accountancy service providers must be supervised for anti-money laundering, by a professional body or by HMRC. Ask who their supervisor is.

A firm that cannot answer these questions straight away is not one to trust with your business.

Test for hospitality knowledge

Credentials show competence in general. You also need someone who understands how a venue makes and loses money. Ask a few practical questions and listen to the answers.

  1. How do you treat hot and cold takeaway food for VAT, and would the Flat Rate Scheme suit a café like mine?
  2. How should tips and service charges be handled to stay within the law and keep National Insurance correct?
  3. What gross profit do you expect us to make on food and on drink, and how would you check whether we are achieving it?
  4. How do you handle payroll for staff on variable hours, holiday pay accrual and the National Minimum Wage?
  5. Which till, stock and accounting systems do your other hospitality clients use, and can you connect to ours?
  6. What would you look at first if our bank balance kept falling while sales looked steady?

A strong answer is specific and practical. A vague one that turns every question into "we can look at that" suggests little hospitality experience. Ask how many restaurant, pub or café clients the firm has and whether you can speak to one.

Compare proposals properly

Fees vary widely, and a cheap quote that excludes payroll, VAT and advice can cost more over a year than a higher one that includes them. Ask each firm to quote against the same written scope.

Example. A café owner gets two proposals. Firm A quotes a monthly fixed fee of £180 for accounts, VAT and the tax return, with payroll at £5 per employee per run and advice charged by the hour. Firm B quotes £260 a month including accounts, VAT, the tax return, weekly payroll for up to 12 staff and a quarterly review meeting. With 10 staff on weekly payroll, Firm A comes to about £2,160 plus £2,600 for payroll, or £4,760 a year before any advice. Firm B is £3,120 a year including the meetings. The lower headline fee was the more expensive option.

Ask what is excluded as well as what is included. Typical extras are payroll, management accounts, HMRC enquiries, catch-up bookkeeping and one-off advice.

Read the engagement letter

A professional firm will send an engagement letter before starting. Read it before you sign. It should set out:

  • The services included, and those that are not.
  • Who does what: which records you provide, by when, and in what form.
  • Deadlines the firm will work to for each return.
  • How fees are calculated, when they are billed and how extra work is approved.
  • How to raise a complaint and how to leave, including handing over records to a new adviser.

Red flags

  • No engagement letter, or one that does not say what is included.
  • Returns filed late, or filed without you seeing the figures first.
  • Advice that sounds too good to be true, such as schemes to avoid VAT or National Insurance that rely on staff being treated as self-employed.
  • Reluctance to give you access to your own records or software.
  • Slow replies in the weeks before deadlines, when you most need them.
  • Accounts that show a gross profit very different from your own stocktake, with no explanation.

Any one of these is worth a conversation. Two or more is a reason to look elsewhere.

Switching accountants

Changing firms is more straightforward than many owners expect. Your new accountant will contact the old one for professional clearance and a handover of the information they need, such as the last accounts, tax computations and any open matters with HMRC. You should also update agent authorisations with HMRC so the new firm can act for you, and change access to your accounting software and payroll. Time the switch to avoid the weeks around a VAT deadline or the year-end if you can. Make sure any fees owed to the old firm are settled or in dispute through its complaints process, because unpaid fees can slow the handover. Keep your own copies of past returns and accounts, so you never depend on one firm to know your business history.

Making the relationship work

  1. Agree a calendar

    List every deadline for the year: VAT, payroll, Making Tax Digital updates, year-end, Corporation Tax and Self Assessment. Agree who acts when.

  2. Share data automatically

    Give the accountant read access to your accounting software and bank feed, so they see the same figures you do.

  3. Meet quarterly

    Ask for a short review of gross margin, labour cost and cash. Bring your questions about pricing, staffing and investment.

  4. Review once a year

    Check whether the service still fits. A growing business may need management accounts, or a different firm.

Cash buffers in hospitality are thin, and many small venues are run by one or two people: about 53% of UK restaurant and mobile food service enterprises had 0 to 4 employees in 2026[5]. A good accountant becomes part of that small team. For decisions you are likely to discuss with them, see sole trader vs limited company for a café or restaurant, capital allowances on kitchen equipment and refits, funding a restaurant: loans, asset finance and investors and when and how to raise menu prices.

Frequently asked questions

Does my restaurant accountant need to be chartered?

Not necessarily, but they should belong to a recognised professional body, hold professional indemnity insurance and be supervised for anti-money laundering. Chartered status is one good sign of training.

What questions should I ask an accountant before hiring?

Ask about VAT on hot and cold food, handling tips and tronc, expected gross profit on food and drink, payroll for variable hours, and which hospitality systems they work with.

Is a fixed monthly fee better than hourly billing?

A fixed fee makes costs predictable, but only if the scope is clear. Check what is excluded, such as payroll, management accounts and HMRC enquiries.

Can my accountant handle Making Tax Digital for me?

Yes, many will submit quarterly updates as your agent. You remain responsible for the records, so agree who records, reviews and submits each quarter.

References

  1. Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Check if you need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (workbook) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo