Key takeaways
- At around £60,000 of profit, the total tax on the two routes is close once all taxes are counted; the decision rests on more than tax.
- Companies pay 19% Corporation Tax on profits up to £50,000 and 25% above £250,000, with marginal relief in between.
- Dividends above the £500 allowance are taxed at 10.75%, 35.75% or 39.35% in 2026/27, depending on your income tax band.
- Limited liability is real but narrower than it looks: landlords and lenders usually ask directors for personal guarantees.
The choice in plain terms
As a sole trader, you and the business are the same legal person. Profits are your income, taxed through Self Assessment, and you are personally responsible for every debt. As a limited company, the business is a separate legal person. It pays Corporation Tax on its profits, and you take money out as salary, dividends or both. The company, not you, owes its debts, unless you have signed a guarantee.
Many cafés, takeaways and small restaurants start as sole traders because it is simple and cheap to run. Many move to a company as profits grow, as they take on a lease and staff, or when they want to bring in a partner or investor. Small operators dominate the sector: about 53% of UK restaurant and mobile food service enterprises had 0 to 4 employees in 2026[1], so this is a decision most owners face at some point.
How each route is taxed
A sole trader pays income tax on profits. In 2026/27 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, the first £12,570 is covered by the Personal Allowance, income from £12,571 to £50,270 is taxed at 20%, from £50,271 to £125,140 at 40%, and above that at 45%[2]. The Personal Allowance is reduced by £1 for every £2 of income over £100,000[2]. Sole traders also pay Class 4 National Insurance on profits. Scotland has different income tax bands, so Scottish owners should run their own figures.
A company pays Corporation Tax. The rate is 19% on profits of £50,000 or less and 25% on profits over £250,000, with marginal relief for profits between the two[3]. Money you then take as dividends is taxed on you personally: there is a £500 dividend allowance, and dividends above it are taxed at 10.75% for basic rate taxpayers, 35.75% for higher rate and 39.35% for additional rate in 2026/27[4]. If you pay yourself a salary, the company pays employer National Insurance at 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year[5][6].
Source: HM Revenue & Customs, 2026[3]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Small profits rate (up to £50,000) | 19% |
| Main rate (over £250,000) | 25% |
Worked example at £60,000 of profit
Example. A café makes £60,000 of profit before paying its owner, who has no other income and lives in England. The figures use 2026/27 rates and are simplified; they ignore pension contributions and any other income.
| Line | Sole trader | Limited company (salary £12,570, rest as dividends) |
|---|---|---|
| Profit before owner pay | £60,000 | £60,000 |
| Employer National Insurance on salary | Not applicable | £1,136 |
| Corporation Tax at 19% | Not applicable | £8,796 |
| Income tax on profits | £11,432 | Not applicable |
| Dividend tax (after £500 allowance) | Not applicable | £3,977 |
| Class 4 National Insurance | Payable on profits | Not applicable |
| Tax and NI shown above | £11,432 plus Class 4 | £13,909 |
In the company column, the salary of £12,570 uses the Personal Allowance. Employer National Insurance is 15% of the £7,570 above £5,000[5][6]. The company's remaining profit of £46,294 is under £50,000, so Corporation Tax is 19%[3]. The £37,498 left is paid as a dividend; after the £500 allowance, the rest falls in the basic rate band and is taxed at 10.75%[4]. In the sole trader column, £37,700 is taxed at 20% and £9,730 at 40%[2]. Once Class 4 National Insurance is added to the sole trader column, the two totals are close at this level of profit.
The example shows why the old rule of thumb, that a company always saves tax, no longer holds for many small cafés. Higher dividend tax rates, the employer National Insurance threshold of £5,000 and the cost of running a company have narrowed the gap. Your accountant may suggest a different salary level; the right figure depends on your circumstances, including whether the company can claim the Employment Allowance, which is not available where the director is the only employee paying secondary National Insurance.
Where a company still helps on tax
- Retained profits: if you do not need all the profit to live on, profit left in the company is taxed at Corporation Tax rates rather than your personal rates, until you take it out. That can fund a refit or a second site.
- Higher profits: as profits rise into the higher rate band, the difference between the routes can widen, depending on how much you draw.
- Family ownership: shares can be held by more than one family member who works in or invests in the business, subject to tax rules on income shifting.
- Pension contributions: a company can pay employer pension contributions for the director, which can be tax-efficient.
Beyond tax: the factors that often decide it
| Factor | Sole trader | Limited company |
|---|---|---|
| Personal liability | Unlimited: you owe the business's debts | Limited, unless you sign personal guarantees |
| Leases and loans | Signed in your own name | Company signs; landlords and banks often want director guarantees |
| Paperwork | Self Assessment; Making Tax Digital for Income Tax above the threshold | Annual accounts, confirmation statement, Corporation Tax return, payroll for director |
| Privacy | Accounts are private | Accounts and directors are on the public register |
| Accountancy costs | Lower | Usually higher |
| Bringing in partners or investors | Harder; usually a partnership | Simpler: issue or transfer shares |
| Selling the business | Sell the assets and goodwill | Sell the shares or the assets |
Liability is the factor owners most often overestimate. A company protects you from many trade debts, but a landlord will usually want a personal guarantee or a rent deposit on a new lease, and a bank will often want a guarantee for a loan. Directors also have legal duties, and can become personally liable if they keep trading when they know the company cannot pay its debts. If liability is your main reason for incorporating, read the guarantees you would be asked to sign before deciding.
What about partnerships?
If two or more people run the venue together without a company, they are usually a partnership. Each partner pays income tax on their share of the profits, much like a sole trader, and in an ordinary partnership each partner can be liable for all of the partnership's debts, not just their share. That surprises many couples and friends who open a café together. A written partnership agreement is essential: who puts in what money, how profits are split, who makes decisions and what happens if one partner wants to leave. A limited liability partnership gives partners limited liability but brings public filing similar to a company. For most small venues with more than one owner, the real choice is between a well-drafted partnership agreement and a company with a shareholders' agreement.
If you decide to incorporate
Forming a company is quick, but making the change cleanly takes planning. Open a business bank account in the company's name and move card takings, delivery platform payouts and supplier payments to it from a set date. Ask your landlord to assign the lease or grant a new one to the company, and expect them to ask for a guarantee. Transfer or apply for the premises licence and food business registration in the right name, and tell your insurer. Set up payroll for yourself as director, register the company for VAT if the business is registered, and agree with your accountant how the assets and goodwill will be transferred and valued. Keep a record of the date everything moved, because HMRC and your accountant will need it for both the final sole trader return and the company's first accounts.
Decision guide
Start simple if testing an idea
A market stall, a pop-up or a first small café with low commitments often suits sole trading. You can incorporate later.
Incorporate before signing big commitments
If you are about to sign a lease, take on staff or borrow, consider forming the company first so contracts are in its name.
Run the tax figures for your profit
Ask your accountant to model both routes at your expected profit, with the salary and dividend split they recommend.
Count the running costs
Add the extra accountancy and admin of a company to the comparison.
Think about the exit
If you plan to sell, bring in investors or pass the business on, a company is usually easier.
If you switch from sole trader to company, the business assets and goodwill are transferred to the company, which has tax consequences of its own; take advice before you do it. Related reading: choosing an accountant for your restaurant, capital allowances on kitchen equipment and refits, funding a restaurant: loans, asset finance and investors and insurance for restaurants and pubs.
Frequently asked questions
Is a limited company always better for tax?
No. At around £60,000 of profit the totals are close once employer National Insurance, Corporation Tax and dividend tax are counted. A company helps more when you leave profits in the business.
What rate of tax do I pay on dividends in 2026/27?
After the £500 dividend allowance, dividends are taxed at 10.75% in the basic rate band, 35.75% in the higher rate band and 39.35% in the additional rate band.
Does a limited company protect me from the lease?
Only partly. The company signs the lease, but landlords often ask directors for a personal guarantee or a rent deposit.
Can I change from sole trader to limited company later?
Yes. Many venues start as sole traders and incorporate as they grow. Transferring the business has tax consequences, so take advice first.
References
Office for National Statistics (2026). UK business: activity, size and location, 2026 (workbook) (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Corporation Tax rates and reliefs (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Tax on dividends (opens in a new tab) ↑
ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑
HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑