Staffing, pay and employment law

Dismissing staff fairly: probation and unfair dismissal

Fair reasons to dismiss, how probation reviews protect you, notice periods and what changes when unfair dismissal rights start at 6 months in 2027.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. The change every operator needs to plan for
  2. What makes a dismissal fair
  3. Reasons that are unfair from day one
  4. Probation that actually protects you
  5. Notice and final pay
  6. Why getting it right matters for the team
  7. The capability route for poor performance
  8. Holding the dismissal meeting
  9. Before you dismiss: a final check
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • A dismissal is fair only if the reason is fair, such as capability or conduct, and you act reasonably throughout the process.
  • From 1 January 2027, employees can claim unfair dismissal after 6 months’ service instead of 2 years.
  • Some reasons are automatically unfair from day one, including pregnancy, asserting minimum wage or working time rights, and whistleblowing.
  • Run probation as a series of recorded reviews and make the decision before the six-month mark.

The change every operator needs to plan for

For years, many hospitality businesses relied on the two-year qualifying period. If a new chef or server did not work out in their first year, the employer could part company with limited legal risk, provided the reason was not automatically unfair. That window is closing. From 1 January 2027, employees can claim unfair dismissal after 6 months in a job instead of 2 years[1].

In a sector with high turnover, that brings a large share of the workforce into protection much sooner. The practical response is not to dismiss faster. It is to recruit carefully, run probation properly and use a fair process for any dismissal, whatever the length of service.

6 months

service needed to claim unfair dismissal from 1 January 2027[1]

What makes a dismissal fair

Fairness depends on two things: your reason and how you act. GOV.UK lists the fair reasons as the employee’s capability or conduct, redundancy, something that prevents them legally doing the job, and other substantial reasons[2]. A fair reason is not enough on its own. A tribunal will look at whether you genuinely believed the reason was fair, carried out proper investigations where appropriate, followed the relevant procedures and gave the employee the chance to appeal[2].

The fair reasons and what each usually requires before a decision.
Fair reasonHospitality exampleWhat a fair process looks like
ConductDrinking on shift, theft, abuse of guests or colleaguesInvestigation, disciplinary hearing, decision in writing, appeal
CapabilityA chef who cannot reach the standard after training and supportClear standards, training, review meetings, time to improve, warnings
Legal barA worker’s right to work in the UK endsCheck the facts, explore whether the bar can be resolved, then decide
RedundancyClosing a site or cutting a lunch service permanentlyGenuine reduction in need, fair selection, consultation, alternatives
Some other substantial reasonA restructure of shift patterns the employee will not acceptBusiness reason, consultation, alternatives considered

Even where summary dismissal seems the only option, for example after a serious assault on a colleague, you must still follow a fair procedure as you would for any other disciplinary matter[2]. Gross misconduct can justify dismissal without notice, but it does not justify skipping the hearing.

Reasons that are unfair from day one

Some reasons make a dismissal automatically unfair regardless of service. They include pregnancy and maternity; family reasons such as parental leave or time off for dependants; acting as an employee or trade union representative; being a part-time or fixed-term employee; pay and working hours, including the Working Time Regulations, annual leave and the National Minimum Wage; and reporting certain types of wrongdoing[3].

In hospitality the riskiest of these are usually the everyday ones. A server who complains that breaks are not being given, a kitchen porter who questions whether their pay meets the minimum wage, or a bartender who asks about holiday pay is asserting a statutory right. Dismissing them shortly afterwards, even for an unrelated reason, invites the argument that the complaint was the real cause. Keep records of performance concerns as they arise, not after the complaint.

Rule of thumb: if someone has recently raised a concern about pay, hours, breaks, holiday, safety, pregnancy or discrimination, pause before any dismissal and take advice.

Probation that actually protects you

Probation is not a legal status that allows dismissal without process. It is an agreed period of closer review, usually with shorter notice. Its value lies in the record it creates: if you can show clear standards, regular feedback and support, any decision at the end is far easier to defend.

  1. Set the standard on day one

    Give the starter a role checklist: the steps of service, food safety tasks, till procedures, timekeeping and behaviour expected.

  2. Review at four weeks

    A short recorded meeting: what is going well, what needs to improve, what support you will give.

  3. Review at three months

    Check progress against the same checklist. If there are concerns, say so plainly and set targets with a date.

  4. Decide by five months

    Confirm, extend once for a defined reason, or end the employment, all before six months’ service.

  5. Confirm in writing

    Write to the employee with the outcome and reasons, even when confirming, so the record is complete.

Example: Tom, a fictional commis chef, starts in March. At his four-week review the head chef notes good knife skills but repeated lateness. At three months the lateness has stopped but his mise en place is still incomplete before service, so the head chef sets a target and pairs him with the sous chef for two weeks. At five months the target is met and probation is confirmed in writing. Had it not been met, the head chef would have held a capability meeting with the same record to rely on.

Notice and final pay

Statutory minimum notice is at least a week for service between one month and two years, a week for every year employed between two and 12 years, and 12 weeks for 12 or more years[4]. The contract can give more, but not less. Probation clauses commonly set one week on both sides.

Final pay should include wages to the end of notice or pay in lieu where the contract allows it, accrued but untaken holiday, any tips owed under your tipping policy, and pension contributions on qualifying earnings. Do not deduct for uniforms or shortages unless the contract allows it and the minimum wage is not affected.

Why getting it right matters for the team

A rushed dismissal costs more than a claim. Replacing a trained cook or experienced server takes time in a tight market. Vacancies in accommodation and food services were an estimated 70,000 in July to September 2026, down from a peak of 177,000 in April to June 2022 but still in the same range as the 86,000 seen before the pandemic[5]. Payrolled hospitality employment also fell by 72,000 in the twelve months to August 2025[6], which means fewer experienced people looking for work in some areas.

Vacancies in accommodation and food servicesONS vacancy survey estimates; 2026 figure provisional
Vacancies in accommodation and food servicesColumn chart. Oct to Dec 2019: 86,000; Apr to Jun 2022 (peak): 177,000; Jul to Sep 2026: 70,000.050,000100,000150,000200,000Oct to Dec 2019: 86,00086,000Oct to Dec 2019Apr to Jun 2022 (peak): 177,000177,000Apr to Jun 2022 (peak)Jul to Sep 2026: 70,00070,000Jul to Sep 2026Vacancies in accommodation and food servicesColumn chart. Oct to Dec 2019: 86,000; Apr to Jun 2022 (peak): 177,000; Jul to Sep 2026: 70,000.050,000100,000150,000200,000Oct to Dec 2019: 86,00086,000Oct to Dec2019Apr to Jun 2022 (peak): 177,000177,000Apr to Jun2022(peak)Jul to Sep 2026: 70,00070,000Jul to Sep2026

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Oct to Dec 201986,000
Apr to Jun 2022 (peak)177,000
Jul to Sep 202670,000

Fair treatment is visible to everyone else on the rota. Staff who see a colleague dismissed without warning start looking for other jobs. Staff who see a clear process, applied consistently, are more likely to trust the next difficult conversation.

The capability route for poor performance

Many hospitality dismissals are really about performance rather than misconduct: a server who cannot manage a section, a chef who cannot keep up on a busy pass, a supervisor who cannot run a close. Treating these as misconduct is a common error. Performance problems call for a capability process, which is about support and time to improve before any decision.

  1. Describe the gap in concrete terms, such as tickets backing up on the grill section on Friday nights, not a general attitude problem.
  2. Check the basics: was the person trained, given the right tools and enough staff on the section?
  3. Agree a written improvement plan with specific targets, support such as buddy shifts, and a review date a few weeks away.
  4. Review on that date. If the gap has closed, record it. If not, hold a formal capability meeting, with the right to be accompanied, and consider a warning with a further review period.
  5. Consider alternatives before dismissal, such as a different section, fewer responsibilities or a move to a role that suits their strengths.

Holding the dismissal meeting

If the decision is dismissal, tell the person face to face in a private room, away from service, with a second manager present to take notes. Keep it short and clear. Do not reopen the evidence; that was done at the hearing.

Script: ‘Thank you for coming in. Having considered everything from the hearing, I have decided to end your employment because of the reasons set out in this letter. Your last day is Friday. You will be paid for your notice period and any holiday you have not taken. You have the right to appeal, and the letter explains how. Is there anything you want to ask me now?’

Hand over the letter at the meeting, recover keys, fobs and any issued equipment, and agree how personal items in lockers will be returned. Turn off system access the same day, including EPOS logins and rota apps.

Before you dismiss: a final check

  • Is the reason one of the fair reasons, and can you evidence it?
  • Has the employee recently raised a concern that could make the reason look automatically unfair?
  • Did you investigate, put the evidence to them and hear their side at a meeting where they could be accompanied?
  • Have you treated similar cases the same way?
  • Have you considered alternatives such as a final warning, retraining or a different role?
  • Is the decision letter ready with reasons, notice, final pay and the right of appeal?
  • Is the person who will hear the appeal independent of the decision?

Frequently asked questions

Can I dismiss someone during probation without a process?

Probation does not remove the need to act fairly, and some reasons are automatically unfair from day one. From January 2027, anyone with 6 months’ service can also claim unfair dismissal, so a recorded process is the safe course.

What are the fair reasons for dismissal?

Capability or conduct, redundancy, something that legally prevents the person doing the job, and some other substantial reason.

How much notice do I have to give?

At least a week for service from one month to two years, then a week per year of service up to 12 weeks, unless the contract gives more.

Is dismissing someone for raising a minimum wage complaint unfair?

Yes. Dismissal for reasons relating to pay and working hours, including the National Minimum Wage, is automatically unfair regardless of service.

References

  1. Acas (2027). Employment Rights Act 2025: what is changing and when (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. GOV.UK (2026). Dismissing staff: fair dismissals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Dismissing staff: unfair dismissals (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. GOV.UK (2026). Making staff redundant: giving staff notice (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). VACS02: Vacancies by industry (October 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Low Pay Commission (2025). National Minimum Wage: Low Pay Commission Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo