Key takeaways
- Fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews are a banned practice under the DMCC Act: automatically unfair and illegal.
- A review is not fake just because you disagree with it; it is fake if it is not based on a genuine experience.
- Incentives are lawful under the Act only if disclosed and the review stays genuine, but Google prohibits incentivised reviews altogether.
- Breaches can lead to penalties of up to the higher of £300,000 or 10% of worldwide turnover.
What changed in the law
The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 added a new banned practice relating to reviews. It sets out behaviour that is automatically unfair and illegal, covering fake reviews and concealed incentivised reviews, and it requires traders not to publish consumer reviews, or information derived from them, in a misleading way[1]. Traders that publish reviews must also take steps to prevent fake reviews and hidden incentives appearing[1].
For a restaurant or pub this covers far more than Google and Tripadvisor. It applies to testimonials on your website, quotes on your menus and flyers, star ratings in your booking widget and reviews you share on social media. The guidance makes clear that consumer reviews can appear in analogue forms too, such as within marketing letters[1].
10%
of worldwide turnover, or £300,000 if higher: the maximum monetary penalty for breaching a banned practice[2]
What counts as a fake review
The guidance defines a fake review as a consumer review that purports to be, but is not, based on a person's genuine experience. Fake reviews can be positive or negative[1]. Two points are especially useful for venues:
- A review is not fake just because the business it is about does not like or agree with it, as long as it reflects the reviewer's genuine experience[1].
- A review is not fake because the reviewer did not pay. A review of a meal bought as a gift by a friend can still be genuine[1].
- A five-star review written by your partner, your head chef or a marketing agency is fake if they are posing as an ordinary guest.
- A one-star review from a rival who never ate with you is fake, and so is one from a former employee posing as a guest.
So the guest who hated your tasting menu and said so at length is entitled to their review, even if their account of the evening differs from yours. Your remedy there is a good reply, not a takedown request. Our guide to responding to negative Google reviews covers the reply.
Practices that are now banned
| Practice | Legal position | Restaurant example |
|---|---|---|
| Writing or commissioning fake reviews | Banned | Paying an agency for a batch of five-star reviews |
| Concealed incentivised reviews | Banned | Free dessert for a review, with no label saying it was incentivised |
| Offering a benefit to change a negative review | Banned | Gift card if the guest edits out their complaint |
| Asking for five-star reviews in exchange for freebies on social media | Banned | 'Leave us five stars and get a free cocktail' |
| Suppressing genuine negative reviews you publish | Can mislead and infringe the law | Deleting critical reviews from your website's review feed |
| Asking all guests in general for honest reviews | Allowed | A card with the bill asking for feedback |
| A disclosed incentive for an honest review | Allowed by the Act, but often banned by platforms | Prize draw entry for any review, clearly labelled |
Several of these come straight from the regulator's own list of examples, including contacting a customer who left a negative review and offering a refund or gift card if they change it, sharing a social post asking for five-star reviews in exchange for free products, and buying reviews generated by software such as bots[1].
Incentives: the law and the platforms disagree
Under the Act, traders may incentivise customers to leave a review, for example by paying them or offering future discounts or free products, but to comply they must tell consumers the review has been incentivised, and the review must still reflect the reviewer's genuine experience[1]. Concealed incentivised reviews, written in exchange for money or a freebie without saying so, are banned content[3].
The platforms are stricter. Google's policy treats content posted because of an incentive offered by a business as fake engagement and prohibits offering incentives such as payment, discounts or free goods and services[4]. In practice, that means no incentives at all for Google reviews, even disclosed ones. Check each platform's rules before running any review promotion, and assume the stricter rule applies.
Safe default for venues: ask every guest the same way, offer nothing in return, and never pick only the happy ones. That keeps you inside both the law and every major platform's policy.
If you publish reviews yourself
Many venues show reviews on their own website or booking page. Once you do, you are a publisher of consumer reviews and must take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews[5]. For a single restaurant, proportionate steps are modest but real.
Write a short reviews policy
Say where reviews come from, how they are checked, how incentivised reviews are labelled, and how people can report a suspicious one.
Show reviews fairly
Display genuine negative reviews alongside positive ones, or pull in a full feed from a platform, rather than hand-picking the best.
Check before publishing
If you collect reviews directly, check that the reviewer had a booking or bill, and remove ones you know are fake.
Keep records
Note when and why you remove a review, in case you are asked to explain.
Train staff
Make sure nobody posts reviews of the venue, or of competitors, from personal accounts.
The guidance warns that suppressing genuine negative reviews, selectively promoting positive ones or omitting information about how reviews were written can infringe the law[1]. Cherry-picking can happen through deleting negatives or through only inviting satisfied guests to review.
Grey areas managers ask about
Real situations are rarely as tidy as the examples in the guidance. These are the ones that come up most often in restaurants and pubs, with the approach that keeps you on the right side of the rules.
- A food blogger is invited for a free meal. Their write-up is fine, but if they also post a review on a platform, it must make clear the meal was free. Tell them so in your invitation, in writing.
- A regular offers to 'balance out' a harsh review. Thank them and decline. A review prompted by you to counter criticism, rather than by their own visit, risks looking like manipulation, and you cannot control what they write.
- A staff member's family visits and wants to review. Ask them not to. Even an honest review from a close connection is a conflict of interest under most platform policies.
- A guest says they will post a bad review unless you refund. Handle the complaint on its merits. If a refund is fair, give it; if it is not, explain why. Do not trade the refund for silence, either way.
- A competitor's staff seem to be reviewing you. Collect the evidence, report the reviews to the platform and keep your public replies neutral. Do not retaliate with reviews of their venue.
When in doubt, ask one question: would a reasonable guest reading this review feel misled if they knew how it came about? If the answer is yes, do not do it.
Why the regulator cares
Fake reviews distort choices and harm consumers and honest businesses. Government research estimated that 11% to 15% of reviews in three common product categories on UK e-commerce platforms are fake[6], and that fake product review text alone causes an estimated £50 million to £312 million of annual harm to UK consumers[7]. Those studies looked at products rather than restaurants, but the same incentives exist in hospitality, where a few stars can decide where a visitor eats.
Source: Department for Business and Trade, 2023[7]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lower estimate | £50,000,000 |
| Upper estimate | £312,000,000 |
Enforcement is serious. Breaches of banned practices can lead to monetary penalties of up to the higher of £300,000 or 10% of worldwide turnover, alongside compliance directions[2]. Most independent venues will never see a regulator, but platforms remove listings, penalise rankings and flag businesses that game reviews, and the reputational cost of being caught can be worse than a fine.
A compliance checklist for managers
- No staff, family or friends post reviews of the venue or competitors.
- No agencies or freelancers are paid to write or post reviews.
- No offers, freebies or discounts are linked to reviews on Google or Tripadvisor.
- Any incentive on another channel is clearly disclosed and open to all, whatever they write.
- Review requests go to all guests in the same way, not only those who seemed happy.
- Complaints are resolved on their merits, with nothing conditional on a review.
- Website review displays include genuine criticism, or use an unfiltered feed.
- Suspicious reviews are reported to the platform, with a note of the reason.
For the practical side of collecting more honest reviews, read asking for reviews without breaking the rules.
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to post fake reviews of my own restaurant?
Yes. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, submitting or commissioning fake reviews is a banned practice. That includes reviews posted by staff, family or agencies posing as ordinary guests.
Can I offer a discount for a review?
The Act allows incentives only if the review is labelled as incentivised and still reflects a genuine experience. Google prohibits incentivised reviews entirely, so for Google the answer is no.
Can I delete negative reviews from my website?
You can remove reviews you know are fake, but suppressing genuine negative reviews or showing only positive ones can mislead consumers and infringe the law.
What are the penalties for fake reviews?
Breaches of banned practices can lead to monetary penalties of up to the higher of £300,000 or 10% of worldwide turnover, together with compliance directions.
References
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Fake reviews guidance (CMA208) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Unfair commercial practices (CMA207) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Google Maps user contributed content policy (2026). Prohibited and restricted content (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Short guide for businesses: publishing consumer reviews and complying with consumer protection law (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business and Trade (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑
Department for Business and Trade (2023). Fake online reviews research: executive summary (opens in a new tab) ↑