Food safety, hygiene and allergens

Food poisoning complaints: how to respond

How to handle a guest who says your food made them ill: the first call, what to record, how to investigate, when to involve the council and how to reply.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Start from the right mindset
  2. The first conversation
  3. What to record
  4. Investigate the same day
  5. Staff illness: the cause you can control
  6. When to involve the council
  7. If an officer contacts you
  8. Replying to the guest
  9. Preventing the next one
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Take every illness complaint seriously and calmly. Do not argue about the cause, and do not admit liability on the first call.
  • Record the facts straight away: who, when, what they ate, symptoms and timings, who else was affected and how to contact them.
  • Investigate your own records, staff health and suppliers the same day, and keep any remaining food.
  • If food you supplied may be unsafe, you must act and inform the authorities. Good records are also your due diligence defence.

Start from the right mindset

A guest who says your food made them ill is usually unwell, worried and sometimes angry. They may be right, or the illness may have come from somewhere else. Food poisoning symptoms usually start within a few hours or a few days of eating the food that caused it, and sometimes not for a few weeks[1]. That means the last meal a guest ate is not always the one that made them ill, and it also means you cannot rule your kitchen out just because the illness started the next day.

Your job on the first contact is not to decide the cause. It is to listen, record the facts, show you take it seriously and start your own checks. Arguing about whether it was your food, or offering refunds to make it go away, both cause problems later.

If the guest describes severe symptoms such as vomiting blood, severe difficulty breathing, confusion or signs of dehydration in a young child, tell them to seek medical help straight away. The NHS lists when to call 111 or 999[1].

The first conversation

  1. Listen and thank them

    “I'm sorry you've been unwell. Thank you for telling us; we take this seriously and I'd like to take some details so we can look into it.”

  2. Take the facts

    Name and contact details, date and time of the visit or order, what each person ate and drank, when symptoms started, what they were, how long they lasted, whether others in the party were ill and whether they saw a doctor.

  3. Do not diagnose or blame

    Avoid ‘it can't have been us’ and avoid ‘that must have been the prawns’. Neither helps.

  4. Explain what happens next

    “I'm going to check our records for that service today and speak to the team. I'll come back to you by a specific day.”

  5. Give one point of contact

    Name the manager who will follow up, and make sure they do.

Complaints often arrive by phone, sometimes when the manager is not there. Whoever answers should take the details on a standard form and pass them to the manager the same day. If calls are answered by an AI assistant such as Ava, set complaints to go straight to the manager you choose; each call is logged with a summary and transcript, which is a useful record of what the guest said.

What to record

Illness complaint record (Example form)
FieldWhy it matters
Date and time of the complaint, who took itShows you acted promptly
Guest name and contact detailsFor follow-up and if the council investigates
Date, time and type of visit (dine-in, takeaway, delivery, function)Links to your records for that service
Food and drink eaten by each person, including shared dishesFinds common items across affected people
Symptoms, when they started and how long they lastedHelps judge whether the timing fits
Others affected, and whether they ate the same itemsMultiple cases from one service is a stronger signal
Medical contact or test results, if the guest offers themA confirmed result changes the next steps
What the guest is asking forApology, explanation, refund or compensation

Keep health information private. Store the form securely, share it only with people who need it, and never discuss a guest's symptoms in a public review reply.

Investigate the same day

  1. Pull the records for that service: probe logs, fridge logs, cooling and reheating records, cleaning sheets and delivery records.
  2. Check whether other guests who ate the same dishes have complained, and look at other complaints in the last few weeks.
  3. Ask staff on that shift whether anyone was unwell before, during or after it, and check your illness reporting log.
  4. Check the batch and supplier of the suspect items, and whether the supplier has issued any alert or recall.
  5. Keep any remaining food from the batch, sealed, labelled and refrigerated or frozen, in case the council wants samples.
  6. Write a short summary of what you found, what you changed and when.

Example: a fictional bistro in Oxford receives two separate calls about stomach upsets after the same Saturday dinner service. Both guests ate the seafood risotto. The manager pulls the records and finds the mussels delivery was logged at a high temperature and accepted. She removes the remaining stock, contacts the supplier and the council, keeps a sealed sample, and calls both guests back the next day to explain what is being done.

Staff illness: the cause you can control

Investigations often find that the problem was not the food on arrival or the cooking, but a member of staff who came to work while unwell. Norovirus in particular spreads easily from an ill food handler to guests. Your illness policy is part of your defence against complaints, and part of preventing them.

  • Make it a written rule that anyone with vomiting or diarrhoea reports it before their shift and stays away from work until they are free of symptoms for the period your policy sets.
  • Ask staff on arrival whether they are fit to work, and record the answer as part of the opening checks.
  • Make it financially and socially possible to report sickness. Staff who fear losing a shift's pay, or being criticised, are more likely to come in ill.
  • Send home anyone who becomes ill at work, and clean and disinfect the areas they used, including toilets and door handles.
  • Keep an illness log showing who reported what and when they returned. It is one of the first records an officer will ask for after an outbreak.

Example: during the investigation into a complaint, the manager of a fictional café in Norwich finds that a kitchen assistant had felt sick on the morning of the service but worked anyway because the café was short-staffed. The café rewrites its illness policy, adds a fitness-to-work question to the opening checklist and arranges cover from a sister site for future sickness.

When to involve the council

Food businesses have legal duties when food may be unsafe. If you consider or have reason to believe food you supplied may be injurious to health, you must immediately inform the competent authorities, withdraw the food from the market and, where it has reached consumers, recall it[2]. In practice, contact your council's food safety team if:

  • several unconnected guests report illness after eating at your premises around the same time;
  • a guest has a confirmed diagnosis linked to food, such as a positive test result;
  • your investigation finds a failure that could have made food unsafe, such as a fridge failure or a supplier problem;
  • you discover a staff member was working while ill with vomiting or diarrhoea.

Contacting the council early is better than being contacted by it. Officers are more likely to work with a business that has already acted and has records to show.

If an officer contacts you

Guests and GPs can report illness to the council, and officers may visit or ask for information. Be cooperative and organised. Have your food safety pack, logs for the relevant dates, staff illness records, supplier details and training records ready. If you face a prosecution, the Food Safety Act 1990 allows a defence where you can prove you took all reasonable precautions and exercised all due diligence to avoid the offence[3]. Your records are how you prove it.

Replying to the guest

Call or write back by the day you promised. Explain what you checked and what you found, in plain words. If you found a problem, say what you have changed. Notify your insurer before agreeing to compensation or admitting fault, but do not let that stop you being kind and clear. If the complaint is also posted online, reply briefly and politely, say you are looking into it and invite the guest to contact the manager directly; do not discuss symptoms or medical details in public.

Diners pay attention to how businesses handle hygiene. In 2025, 55% of consumers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland had checked a food business's hygiene rating in the previous year, up from no more than 44% in earlier survey waves[4]. A complaint handled well rarely becomes a story; one handled badly often does.

Consumers who checked a hygiene rating in the previous 12 monthsEngland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Earlier waves ranged from 41% to 44%.
Consumers who checked a hygiene rating in the previous 12 monthsColumn chart. Earlier waves (highest): 44%; May to August 2025: 55%.0%20%40%60%Earlier waves (highest): 44%44%Earlier waves (highest)May to August 2025: 55%55%May to August 2025Consumers who checked a hygiene rating in the previous 12 monthsColumn chart. Earlier waves (highest): 44%; May to August 2025: 55%.0%20%40%60%Earlier waves (highest): 44%44%Earlier waves(highest)May to August 2025: 55%55%May to August2025

Source: Food Standards Agency, 2025[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Earlier waves (highest)44%
May to August 202555%

Preventing the next one

Every complaint, whether or not your food was the cause, is a chance to test your system. Review the investigation with the head chef, brief the team on any changes and record them. For the records that make investigations quick, see due diligence records: what to keep and how long, and for buffet and carvery risks, see carvery and buffet food safety.

Frequently asked questions

Should I give a refund when a guest says they got food poisoning?

Be kind and take the complaint seriously, but avoid offering money on the first call. Record the facts, investigate and speak to your insurer before agreeing compensation or admitting fault.

How soon after eating does food poisoning start?

According to the NHS, symptoms usually start within a few hours or a few days of eating the food that caused them, and sometimes not for a few weeks.

Do I have to report a food poisoning complaint to the council?

If you have reason to believe food you supplied may be harmful to health, you must inform the authorities. Contact your council's food team if several guests are ill, there is a confirmed diagnosis or your checks find a failure.

What records help if a complaint becomes a claim?

Temperature logs, cleaning records, delivery checks, staff illness and training records, and your notes of the complaint and investigation. They support a due diligence defence.

References

  1. NHS (2026). Food poisoning (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2002). Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, Article 19: responsibilities for food business operators (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1990). Food Safety Act 1990, section 21: defence of due diligence (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Food Standards Agency (2025). Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (FHRS): Food and You 2 report, wave 11 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo