Guest experience and reviews

Loyalty schemes: points, perks or nothing?

Stamp cards, points, perks, paid memberships and simple recognition compared for UK restaurants and pubs, with the costs to model and the consent rules.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Start with the question, not the app
  2. The options compared
  3. Stamp cards
  4. Points and apps
  5. Perks and recognition
  6. Or no scheme at all
  7. Decision criteria
  8. Testing a scheme before committing
  9. Data and consent
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • Stamp cards suit high-frequency cafés; points suit groups with an app; perks suit restaurants where regulars visit monthly.
  • Model the full cost: rewards given to guests who would have come anyway, plus software, training and staff time.
  • Any scheme that sends emails or texts must follow PECR consent rules; collecting data is not the same as permission to market.
  • For many independents, recognising regulars personally beats a formal scheme.

Start with the question, not the app

Loyalty software is easy to buy and hard to make pay. Before choosing a format, be clear what you want the scheme to change. More visits from people who already like you? Visits on quiet days? Bigger spend per visit? Contact details for marketing? Each goal points to a different design, and some are better achieved without a scheme at all.

Budgets are under pressure on both sides of the table. Prices in the restaurants and hotels division of the consumer price index rose 3.8% in the 12 months to September 2026[1], and 84% of hospitality leaders were concerned about food and drink inflation in Q3 2026[2]. A scheme that hands out discounts to guests who would have come anyway can quietly eat a margin that is already thin.

The options compared

Restaurant and pub loyalty approaches compared
SchemeHow it worksBest forWatch out for
Stamp cardBuy a set number, get one freeCafés and coffee-led venues with frequent visitsFraud, lost cards, rewarding habits you already had
PointsEarn points per pound, redeem for rewardsGroups with an app or till integrationComplexity; guests rarely understand point values
Perks and tiersMembers get benefits such as priority booking or a birthday dessertRestaurants with monthly regularsPerks that cost little but feel exclusive work best
Paid membershipGuests pay for ongoing benefitsStrong brands with very loyal followingsHard to sell; must deliver clear value
Partner or app-based schemesA third-party app offers discounts across venuesFilling quiet periodsAttracts deal hunters rather than loyal guests
No formal schemeRecognise regulars personallyIndependents with a strong teamDepends on staff memory and good booking notes

Stamp cards

The stamp card is simple, cheap and understood by everyone. It works where guests visit often and the item is low cost to you, such as coffee. Its weakness is that most of the free items go to people who were coming every day anyway. Digital stamp cards on a phone remove lost-card and fake-stamp problems, but add software and a sign-up step.

Example: a café sells a coffee for £3.20 with an ingredient cost of about 40p. A stamp card gives the tenth coffee free, so the real cost is roughly 40p of ingredients for every nine paid coffees, or about 1.4% of that revenue, plus the card printing. That is cheap if the card adds even one extra visit a month for a share of regulars, and pointless if it changes nothing.

Points and apps

Points schemes make sense for groups with several sites, an ordering app and the data team to use what they collect. For a single restaurant, they often add complexity that guests and staff struggle with. If you go down this route, make the earning rule simple enough to say in one sentence, let guests see their balance easily, and offer rewards they actually want, such as a dish or a drink, rather than a percentage off a future bill.

Technology helps when it is easy to use. Of UK accommodation and food businesses using or unsure about AI, 17.8% used it to provide or personalise services for customers in September 2026[3]. Personalised offers can work well, but only if they are built on data guests agreed to share and feel comfortable with.

Paid memberships and subscriptions are the far end of the same spectrum. A small number of venues with devoted followings sell an annual membership with benefits such as a monthly dinner, priority access to events or a discount on wine. They can bring in cash up front, but they create an obligation you must keep delivering on for the whole year, and members who feel short-changed are vocal about it. Treat any money taken in advance like a voucher liability in your accounts.

Perks and recognition

For many restaurants and pubs, perks beat discounts. Priority booking for busy nights, first sight of a new menu, an invitation to a tasting evening, a favourite table held, or a dessert on their birthday all cost little but feel valuable. They reward the relationship rather than the transaction, and they do not train guests to wait for the next discount.

6%

rise in household spending on restaurants and hotels in the financial year ending 2025, to £2.80 more a week[4]

Household budgets are large but stretched. Average UK household spending was £676.60 a week in the financial year ending 2025[5], and spending on restaurants and hotels rose by £2.80 a week, or 6%[4]. Guests are still choosing to eat out; perks give them a reason to choose you rather than the newest opening.

Or no scheme at all

Some of the most loyal followings in hospitality are built without any scheme. The bartender who remembers your drink, the manager who holds your usual table, the server who asks how the new job is going: that is loyalty in its most powerful form, and no app replicates it. The risk is that it depends on particular staff. When they leave, the relationships go with them unless the knowledge is recorded.

The practical middle ground is recognition backed by good booking notes: regulars flagged in the booking system, preferences recorded with consent, and a team briefed on who is coming in. Our guides to recognising regulars with booking data and personal service without being creepy cover how.

Hospitality leaders optimistic about their own business's next 12 months, Q3 2026
Hospitality leaders optimistic about their own business's next 12 months, Q3 2026Comparison. All hospitality leaders: 53%; Independent hospitality leaders: 11%.53%All hospitality leadersAll hospitality leaders: 53%11%Independent hospitality leadersIndependent hospitality leaders: 11%Hospitality leaders optimistic about their own business's next 12 months, Q3 2026Comparison. All hospitality leaders: 53%; Independent hospitality leaders: 11%.53%All hospitality leadersAll hospitality leaders: 53%11%Independent hospitality leadersIndependent hospitality leaders: 11%

Source: NIQ (CGA by NIQ) and Zonal, 2026[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
All hospitality leaders53%
Independent hospitality leaders11%

Independents in particular need to watch the cost of any scheme. In Q3 2026, 53% of hospitality leaders felt optimistic about their own business's next 12 months[6], but only 11% of independent hospitality leaders did, the lowest point since the pandemic[7].

Decision criteria

  1. How often do regulars visit?

    Weekly or more: stamps or points can work. Monthly or less: perks and recognition usually work better.

  2. What is the goal?

    More visits, quieter days, bigger spend or marketing contacts. Pick one main goal and design for it.

  3. Who will run it?

    Someone must answer questions, fix problems and review results. If nobody has time, choose the simplest option.

  4. Does it fit your systems?

    Check that it works with your till and booking system, and that staff can use it in a few seconds at the bar.

  5. Can you measure it?

    Agree how you will tell whether it worked, such as visit frequency of members against non-members, before you launch.

Testing a scheme before committing

Treat any new scheme as a trial with an end date. Agree a three-month test, decide in advance what success looks like, and be prepared to stop. Most venues find out within a season whether guests care.

Example: a pub with a strong Sunday lunch trade but quiet Tuesday evenings tries a simple perk for members: book any Tuesday and the table gets a free bowl of chips. Over twelve weeks it tracks Tuesday covers against the same weeks last year, the number of members who booked, and the cost of the chips. Tuesday covers rise and most of the bookings come from members who rarely visited midweek before, so the pub keeps the perk and drops a points app it had been considering.

  • Signs it is working: members visit more often than similar non-members, new members keep coming back, and staff find it easy to use.
  • Signs it is not: most rewards go to guests who already visited weekly, sign-ups stall after launch, staff forget to mention it, or guests complain about how it works.
  • Signs it is costing too much: rewards and software cost more each month than the margin on any extra visits you can see.

If you decide to close a scheme, give members notice, honour rewards already earned, and tell them what you will do instead. Ending a scheme badly can undo the loyalty it built.

Most schemes collect names, emails and visit history, and most owners want to use them for marketing. Signing up to a loyalty scheme is not automatically permission to send promotions. Under PECR, marketing emails and texts to individuals need their prior consent[8], unless the soft opt-in applies, which lets a business market its own similar products to customers whose details it obtained during a sale or negotiation[9], with a clear chance to opt out each time.

  • Ask for marketing consent separately from scheme membership, with an unticked box.
  • Explain in one line what you will send and how often.
  • Keep only the data the scheme needs, and delete inactive accounts after a set period.
  • Make leaving the scheme and opting out of marketing easy.

For the wider question of what to keep and how, see building a guest database you can use.

Frequently asked questions

Do restaurant loyalty schemes work?

They can, when they match how often guests visit and what the venue wants to change. Stamp cards suit frequent visits, perks suit monthly regulars, and many independents do best with personal recognition backed by good booking notes.

What is the best loyalty scheme for a small restaurant?

Often a simple perks approach or no formal scheme: priority booking, a birthday dessert or a favourite table held, rather than points or discounts that reward guests who would have come anyway.

Can I email loyalty scheme members?

Only with marketing consent or within the soft opt-in, and with an easy opt-out in every message. Joining a scheme is not automatically consent to marketing.

How do I know if my loyalty scheme is working?

Compare visit frequency and spend of members with similar non-members, and track the cost of rewards and software against any extra visits.

References

  1. Office for National Statistics (2026). Consumer price inflation, UK: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) and Zonal (2026). Hospitality's confidence rises after solid Q3, but Budget support crucial for stability (Business Confidence Survey with Zonal) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 165 dataset (AI sheets) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Office for National Statistics (2025). Family spending in the UK: financial year ending 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2025). Family spending in the UK: financial year ending 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) and Zonal (2026). Hospitality's confidence rises after solid Q3, but Budget support crucial for stability (Business Confidence Survey with Zonal) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) and Zonal (2026). Hospitality's confidence rises after solid Q3, but Budget support crucial for stability (Business Confidence Survey with Zonal) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  9. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo