Key takeaways
- Annual appraisals rarely work on rotas; a 15-minute one-to-one every four to six weeks and a short quarterly review work better.
- Use the same few headings each time: what went well, one thing to improve, support needed, and the next skill to learn.
- Recorded reviews matter more from January 2027, when unfair dismissal rights start after 6 months’ service.
- Hospitality has more open jobs than most sectors, so reviews are a retention tool as much as a performance tool.
Why annual appraisals fail in hospitality
The classic annual appraisal assumes a stable team, a nine-to-five diary and a manager who remembers the whole year. Hospitality has none of those. Staff work different shifts from their manager, many are part-time or seasonal, and plenty will not be with you in twelve months’ time. By the time an annual review comes round, the useful moment for feedback has long passed.
Short, regular conversations fit the way venues actually run. They catch problems early, they give people a reason to stay, and they create a record of support and feedback that makes later decisions fairer. They also fill a training gap: only 42% of accommodation and food SME employers provided training in 2025[1], and a regular review is often where training needs first come to light.
Reviews are a retention tool
Good staff have options. The job openings rate in UK accommodation and food services was 2.8% in July to September 2026, against 2.1% across all industries[2], and hospitality had the highest vacancy rate of any sector in the Low Pay Commission’s 2025 report[3]. A server who feels unnoticed can find another job within days.
Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[2]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Accommodation and food services | 2.8% |
| All industries | 2.1% |
A regular conversation in which someone hears what they are doing well, what they could learn next and what the manager will do to help is one of the cheapest retention measures available. It also gives early warning: people who are thinking of leaving often say so, indirectly, when asked how things are going.
A review rhythm that fits the rota
| Conversation | How often | How long | What comes out of it |
|---|---|---|---|
| One-to-one | Every four to six weeks | 15 minutes | Feedback, one improvement, one skill to learn, support agreed |
| Quarterly review | Every three months | 30 minutes | Progress against role checklist, training plan, any pay or role change discussed |
| Probation reviews | At set points in the first months | 20 to 30 minutes | Recorded decision to continue, extend or end probation |
| Ad hoc feedback | On the shift, when it happens | A minute or two | Praise or correction in the moment, noted if it matters |
Book the one-to-ones into the rota as paid time, usually at the start or end of a shift. Fifteen minutes before a lunch service is far more realistic than an hour on a day off. For part-time and casual staff, keep the same rhythm but stretch the interval, so everyone is reviewed, not just full-timers.
Running a 15-minute one-to-one
Prepare for two minutes
Look at the last note, any guest feedback, the role checklist and anything you have noticed on shift.
Start with them
Ask how things are going and what has been good or hard since you last spoke. Listen first.
Give specific praise
Name something they did well and why it mattered: ‘The way you handled the allergy question on table nine was exactly right.’
Agree one improvement
Pick one thing, describe it concretely, and agree what better looks like. One is enough.
Agree support
Ask what would help: a buddy shift, training on the coffee machine, a change to their section or hours.
Choose the next skill
Pick something from the role checklist to learn before the next one-to-one.
Write three lines
Note the praise, the improvement and the support, with the date. Share it with them.
Feedback script for a difficult point: ‘I want to talk about the start of shift. On Friday and Saturday you arrived after the briefing had started, and you missed the specials. I need you set up and at the briefing by five. Is something getting in the way that I can help with?’
Questions that get honest answers
- What part of the job are you enjoying most at the moment?
- What is the most frustrating part of a typical shift?
- Is there anything that would make your job easier that we have not thought of?
- What would you like to learn next?
- Are your hours and shift pattern working for you?
- Is there anything I do as a manager that makes your job harder?
- Where would you like to be in a year, here or elsewhere?
The last question can feel risky to ask. It is better to hear that someone wants to be a sous chef in a year, and plan for it, than to find out when they hand in their notice.
Reviews in the kitchen
Kitchens often skip reviews because the head chef is on the pass for every service. Yet kitchen staff are the hardest to replace and the most likely to leave for a better-organised kitchen. Keep the same format but make it practical: review a dish or a section together, look at the prep list and the temperature records, and agree the next technique or section to learn.
Split the work. The head chef reviews the sous chef and chefs de partie; the sous chef reviews commis chefs and kitchen porters. Each manager has only a handful of conversations to hold every few weeks, which is realistic even in a busy kitchen.
Helping managers run good reviews
Many supervisors and junior managers have never had a good review themselves, so they do not know what one looks like. Show them. Run a one-to-one with each manager using the same format, then sit in on one they run and give them feedback afterwards.
- Give every manager the same one-page template and the role checklists.
- Agree what good notes look like with two or three anonymised examples.
- Check monthly that one-to-ones are happening, not just scheduled.
- Ask staff in your own conversations whether their one-to-ones are useful.
The quarterly review and pay
The quarterly review is a little more structured. Go through the role checklist, confirm the skills signed off, agree a training plan for the next quarter and discuss any change in role or responsibility. If your venue has a pay ladder linked to skills, this is where progress up the ladder is decided.
Keep pay discussions consistent. If you link pay steps to skills, write down what each step requires and apply it the same way to everyone. Inconsistent pay decisions are one of the fastest ways to lose trust in reviews, and they can lead to complaints of unequal treatment.
Records and fairness
From 1 January 2027, employees can claim unfair dismissal after 6 months in a job instead of 2 years[4]. Short written notes from regular one-to-ones become valuable evidence that someone was given feedback, support and time to improve before any formal step. They also protect good employees, because their progress is recorded and visible to the next manager.
Keep notes factual and brief, store them securely, and let the employee see them. Avoid opinions about personality; describe behaviour and its effect. If a performance issue becomes serious, move to your capability or disciplinary process rather than letting it run on through one-to-ones.
Example: one server over three months
Example: Mia, a fictional server at a 70-cover restaurant, has her first one-to-one six weeks after probation. Her manager praises her warmth with guests and agrees one improvement: entering orders into the till straight away instead of at the end of a round. Support agreed is a quick refresher on the till shortcuts. At the next one-to-one the delay has gone, and they agree her next skill is running the bar on Sundays. At the quarterly review she has signed off the bar checklist, moves up a pay step under the venue’s skills ladder, and says she wants to train as a supervisor. Her manager adds her to the next supervisor course.
Manager checklist
- Every team member has a one-to-one date in the next six weeks.
- One-to-ones are booked in the rota as paid time.
- Each note has praise, one improvement, support and the next skill.
- Role checklists exist for each role and are used in quarterly reviews.
- Pay steps, if used, are written down and applied consistently.
- Notes are stored securely and shared with the employee.
- Serious issues move to the formal process rather than staying in one-to-ones.
Frequently asked questions
How often should hospitality staff have a performance review?
A short one-to-one every four to six weeks and a fuller review each quarter work better than an annual appraisal on rotas.
How long should a one-to-one take?
About 15 minutes, booked into the rota as paid time at the start or end of a shift.
Should part-time and casual staff have reviews?
Yes, on the same rhythm but with a longer interval if needed, so everyone gets feedback and support.
Why keep notes of one-to-ones?
They record feedback, support and progress, which makes later pay and capability decisions fairer and easier to explain.
References
Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Office for National Statistics (2026). VACS02: Vacancies by industry (October 2026) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Low Pay Commission (2025). National Minimum Wage: Low Pay Commission Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑
Acas (2027). Employment Rights Act 2025: what is changing and when (opens in a new tab) ↑