Guest experience and reviews

Refunds and the Consumer Rights Act for food and service

What diners are entitled to under the Consumer Rights Act when food or service falls short, from a fresh dish to a price cut, and how to set a policy.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Goods, services and a plate of food
  2. The remedies for poor service
  3. The remedies for faulty food and drink
  4. Common situations and fair responses
  5. What the Act does not give guests
  6. Allergens and the description of food
  7. Takeaway, collection and delivery orders
  8. Deposits, prepayments and cancellations
  9. Write a refund policy staff can apply
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • A restaurant meal combines goods (the food and drink) and a service (cooking and serving), and the Consumer Rights Act covers both.
  • Services must be performed with reasonable care and skill; the first remedy is usually to do it again, such as a fresh dish.
  • A price reduction, which can be the full price, applies when the problem cannot be fixed or is not fixed quickly without inconvenience.
  • Disliking a dish that is cooked properly and as described is not a legal ground for a refund, though goodwill may still be wise.

Goods, services and a plate of food

The Consumer Rights Act 2015 is the main law behind a diner's rights in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. A restaurant meal is unusual because it is both goods and a service. The food and drink are goods, which must be of satisfactory quality and match their description. The cooking, serving and the experience around them are a service, and every contract to supply a service is treated as including a term that the trader must perform the service with reasonable care and skill[1].

That mix explains most real disputes. A steak that is raw when ordered well done is a problem with the service. A dish with a hair in it, or one that is off, is a problem with the goods. A forty-minute wait for mains on a quiet Tuesday may also be a failure of care and skill. Knowing which kind of problem you are dealing with tells you what the guest can fairly expect.

The remedies for poor service

When a service falls short, the law's first answer is repeat performance: doing it again properly. In a restaurant that usually means cooking the dish again. A price reduction comes in when repeat performance is not possible, or when the trader was asked to do it again but did not do so within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience to the consumer[2].

The right to a price reduction is the right to require the trader to reduce the price by an appropriate amount, including a refund of anything already paid above the reduced amount, and the reduction may, where appropriate, be the full amount of the price[2]. So a guest whose replacement dish arrives after their companions have finished, or who cannot wait for one, may reasonably expect the dish off the bill entirely.

Full price

a price reduction under the Act may, where appropriate, be the full amount of the price[2]

The remedies for faulty food and drink

For goods, the Act gives a short-term right to reject. The usual time limit is 30 days, but for goods that can reasonably be expected to perish after a shorter period, the limit is the end of that shorter period[3]. Restaurant food perishes in minutes, so in practice the guest must raise the problem straight away, at the table or as soon as the takeaway arrives. Rejecting faulty goods means a refund for them, not just a replacement.

  • Food that is off, contaminated or contains a foreign object is not of satisfactory quality.
  • A dish that does not match the menu description, such as a missing advertised ingredient or the wrong cut of meat, does not match its description.
  • A drink that is flat, corked or served in the wrong measure can be rejected and replaced or refunded.
  • Allergen information is part of the description: a dish served as free from an allergen that contains it is both a safety incident and a breach.

Common situations and fair responses

How the Consumer Rights Act applies to common restaurant complaints
SituationKind of problemFair response
Steak cooked well done instead of medium rareService: care and skillCook it again; remove from the bill if the guest cannot wait
Hair or foreign object in the dishGoods: not satisfactory qualityRemove from the bill and offer a replacement
Dish missing an advertised ingredientGoods: not as describedReplace or reduce the price
Very long wait with no explanationService: care and skillApologise and reduce the bill in proportion
Guest dislikes a correctly cooked dishNo breachGoodwill: offer an alternative if you choose
Guest complains after eating all of itWeak claim unless there was a real faultListen, judge fairly, offer a proportionate gesture
Takeaway arrives cold or with items missingGoods and serviceRefund missing items; replace or refund cold food

The table describes what is generally fair, not a legal ruling on any individual case. When in doubt, think about what a reasonable guest would expect from a venue at your price point, and act quickly. Most disputes never become legal disputes if the response at the table is sensible, as covered in handling complaints at the table.

What the Act does not give guests

The Act protects against poor performance, not personal taste. A guest who orders a dish correctly described on the menu, receives it cooked properly, and simply does not like it has no legal right to a refund. Many venues still offer an alternative as goodwill, because the cost of a plate is small next to the cost of a disappointed regular, but that is a business choice.

Nor does the Act let a guest decide on their own to pay nothing for a whole meal because one element went wrong. A fair reduction reflects the problem: a cold side dish does not wipe out three courses and a bottle of wine. If a guest refuses to pay for food they ate without a genuine complaint, that is a different issue, covered in walkouts and guests who refuse to pay.

Allergens and the description of food

Allergen mistakes are the most serious refund cases because they can harm people. Businesses serving non-prepacked food, such as restaurant meals and takeaways, must supply allergen information for every item containing any of the 14 regulated allergens[4]. For food sold online or by phone, allergen information must be provided at two stages of the order process[5].

Confidence in allergen information when eating out, 2025Share very or fairly confident, England, Wales and Northern Ireland
Confidence in allergen information when eating out, 2025Comparison. Information provided in writing: 86%; Information given verbally by staff: 60%.86%Information provided in writingInformation provided in writing: 86%60%Information given verbally by staffInformation given verbally by staff: 60%Confidence in allergen information when eating out, 2025Comparison. Information provided in writing: 86%; Information given verbally by staff: 60%.86%Information provided in writingInformation provided in writing: 86%60%Information given verbally by staffInformation given verbally by staff: 60%

Source: Food Standards Agency, 2025[6]

Show the data
ItemValue
Information provided in writing86%
Information given verbally by staff60%

Guests trust written information more than spoken assurances: 86% were very or fairly confident in allergen information provided in writing in 2025[6], against 60% for information given verbally by staff[7]. Keep the allergen matrix accurate, train staff to point to it, and treat any allergen complaint as an incident to investigate before it is a refund to process.

Takeaway, collection and delivery orders

The same rights apply when food leaves the building, but the practical questions change. A collection customer who opens the bag at home and finds a missing main has a fair claim for that item. A delivery that arrives an hour late and stone cold is a problem with both the goods and the service. What differs is who handles the refund and how you check the facts.

  • Orders through your own website or phone line: you handle the complaint and the refund directly, so set a simple rule, such as refunding missing items in full and offering a replacement or refund for cold or damaged food.
  • Orders through a delivery platform: the platform usually handles the customer's refund under its own terms, then passes some or all of the cost back to you. Read the partner agreement so you know when you can dispute a charge.
  • Evidence: photograph packed orders at busy times and keep tickets, so you can check whether an item left the kitchen.
  • Allergens: if an allergen complaint comes in about a delivered order, treat it as an incident regardless of who processed the payment.

Phone orders deserve particular care, because what was said on the call is hard to prove later. Read the order back, including any allergy, and keep the record with the ticket.

Deposits, prepayments and cancellations

Booking deposits, prepaid set menus and event fees are covered by consumer law too. Terms that let you keep a deposit when a guest cancels must be clear, shown before payment and fair in their effect. A charge that roughly reflects your real loss, such as food bought for a set menu or a table you could not resell, is far easier to defend than one that simply punishes the guest.

  • State the deposit amount, what it covers and when it becomes non-refundable, in the booking flow and the confirmation.
  • Refund deposits promptly when you cancel or cannot provide what was booked.
  • Apply the deposit to the final bill and show it on the receipt.
  • For events, set out stage payments and cancellation charges in writing before any money is taken.

Write a refund policy staff can apply

  1. Define the standard

    Write what 'right' looks like for core dishes: temperature, doneness, portion, presentation.

  2. Set the first response

    Replace or recook first wherever the guest is happy to wait; remove from the bill where they are not.

  3. Give authority

    Decide what servers, supervisors and managers can refund or remove without asking.

  4. Handle takeaway separately

    Say who deals with refunds for collection orders and what to do when a delivery platform handles the payment.

  5. Record every refund

    Log the reason, value and who approved it, and review the log weekly for patterns.

Prices have been rising: restaurants and hotels prices in the UK consumer price index rose 3.8% in the 12 months to September 2026[8]. Guests paying more expect more, and a clear, fair refund policy is one of the cheapest ways to keep their trust.

Frequently asked questions

Am I entitled to a refund if my restaurant food is bad?

If the food is not of satisfactory quality or not as described, or the service was not performed with reasonable care and skill, yes: usually a replacement first, or a price reduction or refund where a fix is not possible or not provided quickly.

Can a restaurant refuse a refund if I just did not like the dish?

Yes. If the dish was cooked properly and matched its description, disliking it is not a legal ground for a refund, although many venues offer an alternative as goodwill.

How long do I have to complain about restaurant food?

The short-term right to reject is usually 30 days, but for perishable goods it ends when they could reasonably be expected to perish. For a restaurant meal that means raising it straight away.

Can a guest refuse to pay for the whole meal over one bad dish?

Usually not. A fair price reduction reflects the problem, so one faulty dish normally justifies removing that dish, not the whole bill.

References

  1. legislation.gov.uk (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 49: service to be performed with reasonable care and skill (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 56: right to price reduction (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. legislation.gov.uk (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 22: time limit for short-term right to reject (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2 Annual Report: Wave 11 (2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2 Annual Report: Wave 11 (2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. Office for National Statistics (2026). Consumer price inflation, UK: September 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo