Key takeaways
- Long menus run to a pace, so bookings should too: choose fixed sittings or a tightly staggered start, and say which at booking.
- Payment protection is linked to far fewer no-shows: 0.80% with a deposit or card hold, against 2.47% without, in platform data[1].
- Date-specific catering bookings sit outside the statutory cancellation rules for distance contracts, but your own terms must still be fair[2][3].
- Collect dietary needs in writing well before the night; 86% of diners trust written allergen information[4].
Why tasting menus need different booking rules
A tasting menu is a performance with a script. The kitchen preps for an exact number of covers, the courses are timed against each other, and a table that arrives 40 minutes late either holds up the room or misses part of the meal. Food is bought and prepared days ahead, sometimes for dishes that cannot be reused. All of that makes a no-show or a last-minute change more expensive than at an à la carte restaurant, and it makes the booking process part of the experience.
The good news is that tasting-menu guests usually plan. They book ahead, they want to know what they are getting and they accept clear rules if those rules are explained well. The booking journey should do three things: fix the time, secure the commitment and collect dietary needs in good time.
Fixed sittings or staggered starts
| Approach | How it works | Suits | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single sitting | Everyone starts at the same time | Small rooms, counters, chef’s tables | Late arrivals miss courses |
| Two sittings | For example 18.00 and 20.30 | Venues that need two turns a night | Tight changeover between sittings |
| Staggered starts | Tables start every 15 minutes in a window | Larger rooms with a steady kitchen | Pacing slots must be strict |
| Hybrid | Fixed sittings for the full menu, staggered for a shorter one | Venues with two menu lengths | Two sets of rules to explain |
A single sitting creates a shared sense of occasion and makes the kitchen’s job predictable, but it is unforgiving of lateness. Staggered starts are kinder to guests and to the room, but need careful pacing so the kitchen is not firing course three for one table and course nine for another at the same moment. Whichever you choose, show it clearly in the widget: “All guests start at 19.00” is a rule guests can plan around.
Prepayment, deposit or card hold
Most tasting-menu venues take some form of payment protection, and the data suggests it matters. In the Resos No-Show Index, reservations with a deposit or card hold had a recorded no-show rate of 0.80%, against 2.47% for reservations with no payment requirement[1]. Resos describes these as raw descriptive rates, not a measured effect, because venues that take deposits may differ in other ways too. The gap is still large enough to take seriously.
Source: Resos, 2026[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| With a deposit or card hold | 0.8% |
| No payment requirement | 2.47% |
- Full prepayment: the guest pays for the menu at booking. Simplest for the kitchen; needs clear terms for cancellation and transfer.
- Deposit: a share of the menu price paid at booking and deducted on the night. A middle path for venues with some walk-in or à la carte trade.
- Card hold: card details taken at booking, charged only for a late cancellation or no-show. Lighter for the guest; the venue carries more risk of a failed charge.
Choose based on how much you lose when a table fails. If you buy ingredients for each booked cover and the menu cannot be sold à la carte, prepayment or a substantial deposit is reasonable. If the kitchen can absorb a missing table, a card hold may be enough.
Writing fair terms
Guests often believe they have a statutory right to cancel any online booking. For a table on a specific date, they usually do not: the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 exclude contracts for catering, and for services related to leisure activities, where the contract provides for a specific date or period of performance[2]. That puts the cancellation window in your terms, which is why the terms must be fair.
Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, terms that may be regarded as unfair include letting the trader keep sums paid when the consumer cancels without offering equivalent compensation when the trader cancels, and requiring a consumer who does not go ahead to pay a disproportionately high sum or pay for services not supplied[3]. For a tasting menu, that suggests a few principles:
- Give a cancellation window long enough to resell the table, often 48 to 72 hours for a tasting menu.
- Allow transfers to another named guest at no charge, and moves to another date where you can.
- If you cancel, refund in full or offer another date, whichever the guest prefers.
- If you resell a cancelled table, consider refunding the guest, even outside the window.
- Show the terms before payment, and repeat them in the confirmation and the reminder.
The dietary questionnaire
A tasting menu leaves little room for improvisation, so dietary needs must be known in advance. Food law requires businesses to declare 14 specific allergens[5] and to provide allergen information for every non-prepacked item that contains any of them[5]. Many guests have something to declare: 23% of adults in England, Wales and Northern Ireland reported a food hypersensitivity in 2025[6].
| Question | Why ask | When |
|---|---|---|
| Any food allergies in your party, and which allergens? | Safety; the kitchen must plan substitutes | At booking and in the reminder |
| Any intolerances or conditions such as coeliac disease? | Different handling from preferences | At booking |
| Any dietary choices: vegetarian, vegan, pescatarian, no pork, no alcohol in food? | Menu planning | At booking |
| Any strong dislikes you would like us to avoid? | Some kitchens accommodate a few | Optional |
| Is the drinks pairing for everyone? | Prep and stock | Optional, by the reminder |
| Special occasion? | Personal touches | Optional |
Ask in writing, and confirm in conversation on the night. Diners trust written information more: 86% were confident in allergen information given in writing in 2025, against 60% for verbal information[4]. Be honest about limits. If the kitchen cannot safely remove an allergen from a particular course, say so at booking and offer an alternative course or a different date.
From booking to the night
At booking
Show the start time, the menu length, the payment terms and the cancellation window. Collect the questionnaire or a link to it.
Confirmation
Repeat the time, terms and dietary answers, with a link to change them. Ask the guest to tell you if anyone in the party changes.
One week before
Send a reminder with the dietary answers attached and a deadline for changes, timed to the kitchen’s ordering.
48 hours before
Confirm numbers and any pairings. Call or message guests who have not confirmed dietary details.
On the day
Print the dietary sheet for the kitchen and floor by table and seat. Brief the team at pre-service.
After service
Record what worked, any issues and any notes for next time with the guest’s agreement.
Late arrivals at a fixed start
Lateness is the hardest part of a fixed sitting. Decide the rule in advance and say it at booking: “The menu starts at 19.00 for everyone. If you arrive late, we’ll serve you from the course the room has reached.” Some venues serve a condensed version of the missed courses; others do not. Either is fair if guests know beforehand. Train hosts to greet late guests warmly and get them settled quickly rather than discussing the clock, and to call any table that is more than ten minutes late to check they are on their way.
Transfers, resale and waitlists
The fairest way to protect a prepaid table is to make it easy to pass on. Let guests transfer a booking to a friend by changing the name, at no charge, up to the start time. Keep a waitlist for every sitting, and when a cancellation arrives inside the window, offer the seats to the waitlist straight away. If you resell them, refund or credit the original guest; you have lost nothing, and they will remember the gesture. Some venues allow guests to list their own seats for resale through the booking system, which takes the work off the team. Whatever you offer, say it in the terms, so guests who cannot make it know what to do instead of simply not turning up.
Example: an 18-seat counter
Example. A fictional 18-seat counter restaurant runs two sittings a night, at 18.00 and 20.45, with a ten-course menu. It used to take card details and charge only for no-shows, but often found out about allergies at the counter. It moves to full prepayment with transfers allowed to another guest, a 72-hour cancellation window and a refund if a cancelled seat is resold. A dietary questionnaire is required at booking, with a reminder a week before. Over the next season, seats lost on the night fall, dietary surprises at the counter become rare, and the kitchen orders to the exact number of covers for each sitting.
Frequently asked questions
Should tasting menus be prepaid?
Many venues prepay or take a substantial deposit because food is bought per cover. In platform data, bookings with a deposit or card hold had a recorded no-show rate of 0.80%, against 2.47% without[1].
Can guests cancel a prepaid tasting menu and get a refund?
There is usually no statutory cancellation right for a table on a specific date[2], so your terms decide. Keep them fair: a reasonable window, transfers allowed and a refund if you cancel or resell the seat.
How should we collect dietary requirements for a tasting menu?
In writing at booking, with a reminder before the kitchen orders, then confirmed at the table. Ask about allergens, intolerances, dietary choices and strong dislikes separately.
What happens if guests arrive late for a fixed start time?
Say the rule at booking. Many venues serve late guests from the course the room has reached; others offer a condensed version of missed courses.
References
Resos (2026). Restaurant no-show rate: the Resos No-Show Index (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2013). The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, regulation 28 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Consumer Rights Act 2015, Schedule 2: consumer contract terms which may be regarded as unfair (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2 Annual Report: Wave 11 (2025) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2: wave 11 key findings (opens in a new tab) ↑