Pubs, bars and drinks

The Pubs Code and the Market Rent Only option

Who the Pubs Code covers, tied tenant rights, the four events that let you request Market Rent Only, and how to judge whether going free of tie pays.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Who the Pubs Code covers
  2. Your main rights under the Code
  3. What Market Rent Only means
  4. The four events that open the MRO door
  5. How a request moves forward
  6. Does going free of tie pay?
  7. Records that make any request stronger
  8. Rights worth using even if you stay tied
  9. Example: a rent assessment proposal arrives
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. References

Key takeaways

  • The Pubs Code applies to pub companies with 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales and to their tied tenants.
  • Market Rent Only (MRO) lets an eligible tenant switch to a free-of-tie tenancy, paying market rent and buying drinks on the open market.
  • You can only ask for MRO after one of four events, such as a rent assessment proposal or a significant tied price rise, and strict deadlines apply.
  • Going free of tie pays only if the drinks saving beats the higher rent and any new costs; model it before you request.

Who the Pubs Code covers

The Pubs Code regulates the relationship between pub companies that own 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales and their tied pub tenants, including people who are negotiating or considering a tied agreement[1]. It is enforced by the Pubs Code Adjudicator, an independent office that handles disputes, issues guidance and can investigate breaches.

If your landlord owns fewer than 500 tied pubs, or your pub is in Scotland or Northern Ireland, the statutory code does not apply. Some smaller companies follow voluntary industry codes, but those are not the same thing, so check which rules your agreement sits under before relying on anything below.

The stakes are real. The number of pubs in the UK fell to 44,650 in 2025 from 55,400 in 2010[2], and company insolvencies among pubs and bars in England and Wales reached 736 in 2025 against 527 in 2019[3]. A tenant who understands their rights is in a stronger position to keep a pub viable.

Your main rights under the Code

Selected tied tenant rights under the Pubs Code, as described by the Pubs Code Adjudicator
RightWhat it gives you in practice
Information before you signDetails of tied obligations, rent, repairs and insurance before the tenancy starts, and a sustainable business plan
Rent proposalsA proposal with supporting information when a new or renewed tenancy is offered
Rent assessmentA rent assessment proposal at least every five years on an existing tenancy
Meeting recordsCopies of minutes of meetings about rent, repairs and business planning within 14 days
Insurance price matchingThe right to match the premises insurance you pay the pub company against the open market
Market Rent OnlyIn certain circumstances, the right to request a free-of-tie tenancy at market rent

Tenants' familiarity with these rights varies. In the Adjudicator's 2026 tied tenant survey, 85% of tenants asked said they were familiar with their right to meeting minutes, but only 70% with their right to request MRO and 67% with insurance price matching[4].

Tied tenants familiar with their Pubs Code rightsPCA Tied Tenants Survey 2026, Ipsos
Tied tenants familiar with their Pubs Code rightsBar chart. Meeting minutes within 14 days: 85%; Rights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancy: 79%; Rights on a rent assessment proposal: 75%; Right to request Market Rent Only: 70%; Premises insurance price matching: 67%.Meeting minutes within 14 daysMeeting minutes within 14 days: 85%85%Rights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancyRights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancy: 79%79%Rights on a rent assessment proposalRights on a rent assessment proposal: 75%75%Right to request Market Rent OnlyRight to request Market Rent Only: 70%70%Premises insurance price matchingPremises insurance price matching: 67%67%Tied tenants familiar with their Pubs Code rightsBar chart. Meeting minutes within 14 days: 85%; Rights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancy: 79%; Rights on a rent assessment proposal: 75%; Right to request Market Rent Only: 70%; Premises insurance price matching: 67%.Meeting minutes within 14 daysMeeting minutes within 14 days: 85%85%Rights on a rent proposal for a new orrenewed tenancyRights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancy: 79%79%Rights on a rent assessment proposalRights on a rent assessment proposal: 75%75%Right to request Market Rent OnlyRight to request Market Rent Only: 70%70%Premises insurance price matchingPremises insurance price matching: 67%67%

Source: Pubs Code Adjudicator and Ipsos, 2026[4]

Show the data
ItemValue
Meeting minutes within 14 days85%
Rights on a rent proposal for a new or renewed tenancy79%
Rights on a rent assessment proposal75%
Right to request Market Rent Only70%
Premises insurance price matching67%

What Market Rent Only means

MRO is the right to occupy your tied pub under a free-of-tie tenancy that is MRO-compliant[5]. Under that tenancy you are free to buy alcohol and other products and services on the open market[5]. In return you pay either the rent you agree with the pub company or the market rent, which can be independently determined if you cannot agree[5].

MRO is not a discount and it is not a way to keep a tied rent while dropping the tie. It is a switch to a different kind of deal: higher rent, in most cases, but full control over what you buy and from whom. Whether that leaves you better off depends on your volumes, your prices and your appetite for running purchasing yourself.

The four events that open the MRO door

You cannot ask for MRO at any time. The Adjudicator lists four circumstances that allow a request[5]:

  1. You receive a rent assessment proposal, which the Code requires at least every five years.
  2. Your pub arrangement is renewed, where the agreement is protected under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 or you have a contractual right to renew.
  3. You are notified of a significant increase in the price of a tied product or service.
  4. You show that a trigger event, as defined in the Code, has occurred.

Strict timescales apply to requesting MRO, to each step in the procedure and to referring a dispute to arbitration or an independent assessor[5]. Miss a deadline and you may have to wait for the next event, which could be years away. As soon as any of the four events happens, put the date in a diary and get advice the same week.

How a request moves forward

  1. Confirm that an MRO event has happened

    Check the letter or notice you received against the four events. Keep the original and note the date you received it.

  2. Get advice and model both options

    Ask an accountant with pub trade experience to compare your current tied position with a free-of-tie forecast. A solicitor or surveyor who knows the Code can check the process and any proposed terms.

  3. Send the request in writing, on time

    Follow the Adjudicator's guidance on what the request must contain and how it must be sent. Keep proof of delivery.

  4. Review the pub company response

    The company responds with its proposed terms. Compare them with an ordinary free-of-tie lease for a similar pub, because unusual terms can make MRO unattractive in practice.

  5. Negotiate the rent, or have it assessed

    If you cannot agree the rent, the market rent can be independently determined. Disputes about the process can be referred to the Adjudicator.

Use the Adjudicator's own MRO factsheet for the exact deadlines at each step. They are strict and they change the outcome, so do not rely on memory or on what happened to another tenant.

Does going free of tie pay?

Most of the decision is arithmetic. Start with your annual tied volume and multiply it by the gap between the tied price list and the best free trade price you can get for the same or similar products. That is your tie cost. Then estimate the free-of-tie rent. If the rent increase is smaller than the tie cost, MRO looks attractive on paper.

Then add the things the arithmetic hides. Without the tie you lose any support, purchasing schemes or repairs contributions the company provided. You need your own supplier accounts, credit terms and possibly new dispense equipment. Duty changes affect both sides of the sum: Alcohol Duty rises with RPI by 4.55% on 1 February 2027[6], which will push up open-market prices as well as tied ones, so model the rise in both scenarios.

  • MRO tends to suit pubs with strong wet volumes, a clear identity and an operator comfortable negotiating with suppliers.
  • It tends to suit less well when volumes are low, the building needs heavy investment the landlord would otherwise fund, or the operator values the support.
  • In every case, the decision should rest on your own trading figures for the last two or three years, not on a forecast written to justify a choice already made.

Records that make any request stronger

Whether or not you ever ask for MRO, the tenants who do best under the Code are the ones with good records. A rent negotiation, a dispute about repairs and an MRO request all turn on evidence, and the pub company will have its own figures ready.

  • Monthly wet sales in barrels and in money, split by beer, cider, wines, spirits and soft drinks, for at least the last three years.
  • Every tied price list you have received, with the date it arrived, so you can show how prices moved over time.
  • Free trade quotes for comparable products, refreshed at least once a year, so the tie gap is always current.
  • Minutes of every meeting with your business development manager, which you are entitled to receive, and your own notes if the minutes are incomplete.
  • Repair requests, photographs and the company's responses, with dates.
  • Your own rent review and renewal dates, with a reminder set months ahead.

Rights worth using even if you stay tied

Plenty of tenants decide the tie suits them and never request MRO. The other rights still earn their keep. Ask for minutes after every meeting about rent, repairs or business planning, and correct them in writing if they are wrong. Price-match your premises insurance every year, because the saving is often easy money. Treat the rent assessment proposal as the start of a negotiation, not a final figure, and back your response with your trading records. The Code works best for tenants who use it routinely rather than only when something has gone wrong.

Example: a rent assessment proposal arrives

Example: a tenant of a large pub company in the Midlands receives a rent assessment proposal in February, suggesting a modest rise in tied rent. The pub sells around 260 barrels a year. Her accountant compares the tied price list with free trade quotes and finds a gap of about £110 a barrel, so the tie costs her roughly £28,600 a year. A local surveyor suggests a free-of-tie rent around £15,000 higher than the proposed tied rent. On those figures MRO would leave her about £13,600 a year better off before new costs. She budgets £4,000 a year for lost support and dispense maintenance, still comes out ahead, and sends her MRO request within the deadline the Code sets. Whatever the outcome, the modelling also strengthens her hand in the rent negotiation.

Frequently asked questions

Can any tied tenant ask for Market Rent Only?

Only tenants of pub companies with 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales, and only after one of the four MRO events, such as a rent assessment proposal or a significant tied price increase.

Does MRO mean lower rent?

Usually not. MRO means a free-of-tie tenancy, so rent is normally higher, but you can buy drinks on the open market. It pays when the drinks saving is larger than the rent increase and any new costs.

What happens if we cannot agree the market rent?

The market rent can be independently determined if you and the pub company cannot agree, and disputes about the process can be referred to the Pubs Code Adjudicator.

Are there deadlines for an MRO request?

Yes, strict timescales apply to the request and every later step. Check the Adjudicator’s MRO guidance as soon as an MRO event happens.

References

  1. Pubs Code Adjudicator (2026). Pubs Code Adjudicator (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. The Insolvency Service (2025). Company insolvency statistics September 2026: industry tables (Table A1b, England and Wales) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Pubs Code Adjudicator and Ipsos (2026). PCA Tied Tenants Survey 2026: headline findings (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Pubs Code Adjudicator (2026). Know your rights: Market Rent Only (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. HM Revenue & Customs (2027). Alcohol Duty uprating and Small Producer Relief changes (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo