Key takeaways
- A tied tenant buys beer and often other drinks from the pub company, usually at above open-market prices, in exchange for lower rent and a building to trade from.
- A free house buys from anyone, which means better margins but more capital, more risk and no landlord support.
- The statutory Pubs Code covers pub companies with 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales, built on the principle that tied tenants should be no worse off than free-of-tie ones.
- Compare the two on total cost per year, not on rent alone: rent plus the tie premium plus repairs and ingoing costs.
The two models in plain words
In a tied pub, the building belongs to a pub company or brewery and the operator takes it on under a tenancy or lease. The tie is the clause that says the operator must buy some or all of their drinks, most often beer and cider and sometimes wines, spirits and services, from the landlord or a nominated supplier. In return the operator gets a pub to trade from, usually on lower rent and ingoing costs than a free-of-tie deal, and a level of support that varies widely by company.
A free house is any pub where the operator can buy drinks from whoever they like. That might be because the operator owns the freehold, or because they lease the building from a landlord who does not impose a tie. Free houses keep the full margin on every pint, but they carry the capital cost, the repairs and the commercial risk on their own.
Both models are common, and they sit inside a shrinking market. The British Beer and Pub Association counted 44,650 UK pubs in 2025, down from 55,400 in 2010 and 60,800 in 2000[1]. Whichever model you choose, the pub has to earn enough to survive in a sector that has been losing outlets for a generation.
Source: ICAEW Library & Information Service, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| 2000 | 60,800 |
| 2010 | 55,400 |
| 2025 | 44,650 |
What the tie actually costs
The cost of the tie is the gap between what you pay the pub company for tied products and what a free house would pay for the same products on the open market. Pub companies negotiate large volume discounts with brewers, then sell to tenants at a list price that is higher than a free trade buyer might get. That gap, often discussed as a price per barrel or per keg, is how the pub company earns part of its return from the property.
It is easy to underestimate because it is spread across every delivery. A tenant who looks at rent alone may think a tied deal is far cheaper. The honest comparison is total occupancy cost: rent, plus the tie premium on every barrel, plus any machine income share, plus insurance and repair obligations. Ask the pub company for the tied price list before you sign, and get a free trade quote for the same products from a wholesaler so you can see the gap for yourself.
What a tied tenant gets in return
- A building without buying a freehold, often with a much lower ingoing cost than a free-of-tie lease or a purchase.
- Rent that is meant to reflect the tie, so the rent should be lower than for the same pub free of tie.
- Support such as business development managers, training, marketing material, purchasing schemes and sometimes investment in refurbishment.
- Shared responsibility for repairs in some agreements, which is valuable in an old building.
- A route into the trade for people who could not raise the capital to buy a pub.
The value of these benefits depends entirely on the company and the agreement. A short tenancy with a supportive landlord who funds a kitchen refit can be a good deal. A long lease with full repairing obligations, a heavy tie and little support can be a poor one, even if the headline rent looks low.
Side by side
| Factor | Tied tenancy or lease | Free house (owned or free-of-tie lease) |
|---|---|---|
| Buying drinks | Tied products from the pub company or nominated supplier | Any supplier; negotiate your own prices |
| Drinks margin | Lower, because of the tie premium | Higher, and you choose the range |
| Rent or capital | Rent meant to reflect the tie; low ingoing | Higher rent free of tie, or the capital to buy |
| Repairs | Depends on agreement; tenancies often share, leases often full repairing | Usually all yours |
| Support | Business development manager, training, schemes | Whatever you buy in |
| Range | Limited to the list, with some guest options | Complete freedom, including local and craft brewers |
| Regulation | Statutory Pubs Code if the company has 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales | Ordinary landlord and tenant law |
| Exit | Assign or surrender under the agreement terms | Sell the business or the freehold |
How the law protects tied tenants
In England and Wales, the Pubs Code regulates the relationship between pub companies owning 500 or more tied pubs and their tied tenants, including people negotiating or considering a tied agreement[2]. The law that created it says the code must be consistent with two principles: fair and lawful dealing by pub-owning businesses, and that tied pub tenants should not be worse off than they would be without the tie[3]. That second principle is the formal version of the comparison in this article: if the tie costs more than the rent saving, something is wrong.
If your landlord owns fewer than 500 tied pubs, or the pub is in Scotland or Northern Ireland, the statutory code does not apply, and your protection comes from the agreement itself and general law. That makes the pre-signing questions even more important.
What tenants say about the deal
Tied tenants of the large companies are surveyed each year for the Pubs Code Adjudicator. In 2026, overall satisfaction with the pub company fell to 56% from 61%[4], with dissatisfied tenants pointing to rising costs, repairs, communication and one-sided relationships. The same survey found 83% of tenants had sought professional advice about their tenancy, most often from an accountant with pub trade experience[4]. That is a sensible habit for anyone comparing tied and free offers.
Read the tie clause line by line
Ties differ far more than most first-time operators expect. Two pubs owned by the same company can carry different ties because they were let at different times. Before you compare offers, pin down exactly what the tie in front of you covers.
- Which products are tied: beer and cider only, or wines, spirits, soft drinks and even services such as insurance or machines too?
- How often the tied price list changes, how much notice you get, and whether increases are linked to anything you can check.
- Whether any discounts apply, for example for volume or for paying promptly, and whether they are written into the agreement.
- Whether you can buy guest or local beers, how many lines that covers and whether those are bought through the pub company.
- How income from gaming machines, if any, is shared with the landlord.
- Whether the landlord uses flow monitoring equipment on the beer lines, and what happens if it suggests you bought outside the tie.
- What happens to the tie if you renew, assign or surrender the agreement.
Write the answers down and attach them to your comparison. They turn a vague feeling that the tie is expensive into a number you can negotiate on.
How to decide
Work out total occupancy cost for both
For the tied offer, add rent, the tie premium on your forecast volume, insurance and repairs. For the free option, add the higher rent or finance cost, insurance and full repairs.
Test the trade forecast
Use the pub's actual trading history if you can get it, not just the landlord's projection. Wet sales volumes drive the tie cost, so a wrong volume makes the whole comparison wrong.
Value the support honestly
Training, marketing and investment are worth money only if you will use them. Ask existing tenants of the same company what support actually looks like.
Check flexibility
Can you stock guest ales, local spirits or a craft range? Range matters if your concept depends on it.
Read the exit terms
Find out how you would leave, what you would get back and what dilapidations you might owe.
Example: comparing two offers for the same pub
Example: a couple are offered a community pub on a tied tenancy at £28,000 a year rent, or free of tie at £40,000. They forecast 300 barrels of beer and cider a year. The tied price list is, on average, £120 a barrel above the best free trade quote they obtained, a tie premium of £36,000 a year. On that forecast the tied deal costs £64,000 a year in rent plus premium, against £40,000 free of tie, so the tie only makes sense if the support, repairs and lower ingoing cost are worth more than £24,000 a year to them. Under the tied offer, the landlord would also fund a £60,000 kitchen refit, and the couple lack the capital to do that themselves. They negotiate a lower tied rent, take the refit and plan to revisit the deal at the first rent review.
The point of the example is the method, not the numbers. Your own figures will differ, so build the comparison from your forecast, the landlord's price list and real free trade quotes.
Frequently asked questions
What does free of tie mean?
It means you can buy beer and other drinks from any supplier rather than the pub company. Rent is usually higher, because the landlord no longer earns a margin on your drinks.
Is a tied pub always cheaper to run?
No. The rent is usually lower, but the tie premium on drinks can outweigh the saving. Compare total occupancy cost, not rent alone.
Does the Pubs Code cover every tied pub?
No. It covers tied tenants of pub companies with 500 or more tied pubs in England and Wales. Smaller companies and pubs elsewhere in the UK fall outside the statutory code.
Can a tied pub sell guest beers?
Sometimes. It depends on the agreement. Some include a guest beer allowance or a range of approved local beers; ask before you sign.
References
ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pubs Code Adjudicator (2026). Pubs Code Adjudicator (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2015). Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015, section 42: Pubs Code (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pubs Code Adjudicator and Ipsos (2026). PCA Tied Tenants Survey 2026: headline findings (opens in a new tab) ↑