Staffing, pay and employment law

Tronc schemes: how they work and the NI position

How an independent tronc and troncmaster work in UK hospitality, when National Insurance is not due on tips, how PAYE still applies, and common pitfalls.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. What a tronc actually is
  2. The National Insurance conditions
  3. Compulsory versus optional service charges
  4. What is at stake: a worked Example
  5. Setting up an independent tronc
  6. Pitfalls that break the exemption
  7. How a tronc fits with the tips law
  8. Who should not be the troncmaster
  9. Running the tronc month by month
  10. Explaining the tronc to staff
  11. Tronc health check
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • A tronc is a pool for sharing tips run by a troncmaster. Income tax still applies through PAYE, which the troncmaster operates[1].
  • National Insurance is not due on tronc tips if the employer does not decide, directly or indirectly, how they are allocated, among other conditions[1].
  • Compulsory service charges always attract National Insurance, however they are shared[1].
  • With employer NICs at 15% since April 2025[2], a genuine tronc can save a busy venue a meaningful sum, but only if the independence is real.

What a tronc actually is

A tronc is an arrangement for pooling and sharing tips, gratuities and service charges among staff. The person who runs it is the troncmaster. In many venues the troncmaster is a senior employee such as a head waiter or a restaurant manager, and sometimes a committee of staff or an external tronc service. HMRC's guidance on tips, gratuities, service charges and troncs, known as E24, sets out how each type of payment is taxed[1].

A tronc does not change who the money belongs to. Since the tips law, all tips must be given to workers without deductions[3], whatever route they take. What a tronc can change is the National Insurance treatment, and that depends entirely on who decides how the money is shared.

The National Insurance conditions

E24 explains that tips paid through a tronc can be exempt from National Insurance contributions. One key condition is that the employer does not determine, directly or indirectly, the allocation of those tips. The exemption also depends on the troncmaster allocating money that the employer has not itself paid out to staff, and on the employer not passing that money on to employees, directly or indirectly[1].

Income tax is a separate question. Tips distributed through a tronc are still taxable under PAYE. Where the tronc is independent, HMRC says the troncmaster is personally responsible for all aspects of operating a PAYE scheme for it. Where the employer is involved in deciding the distribution, the employer is responsible for PAYE instead[1].

Tax and National Insurance on tips and service charges (summary of HMRC E24)
PaymentIncome taxNational InsuranceWho runs PAYE
Tips shared by the employer through payroll, employer decides sharesYesYesEmployer
Tips shared through an independent tronc, troncmaster decidesYesNo, if the E24 conditions are metTroncmaster's tronc PAYE scheme
Compulsory service charge, however sharedYesAlways dueDepends on the route
Optional service charge presented as entirely optionalYesTreated as a tip; follows the tip rules aboveDepends on the route

Compulsory versus optional service charges

Where a customer must pay a service charge, National Insurance contributions are always due on the payments, whatever method is used to share them. HMRC accepts a service charge as voluntary where it is clearly presented to the customer as an entirely optional payment, and then treats it as a tip[1]. So the wording on your menu and bill decides the National Insurance position before the tronc even comes into it. The VAT side of the same choice is covered in service charges: discretionary, compulsory and VAT.

What is at stake: a worked Example

From 6 April 2025, the employer National Insurance rate rose from 13.8% to 15%, and the secondary threshold fell from £9,100 to £5,000 a year[2]. In 2026 to 2027 employers pay National Insurance on earnings above £96 a week[4]. Most tipped staff in a busy venue already earn above that threshold from basic pay, so tips paid through payroll attract employer National Insurance on almost every pound.

Example: employer NI on £60,000 of tips a yearExample at the 15% employer rate; assumes staff already earn above the secondary threshold
Example: employer NI on £60,000 of tips a yearComparison. Shared by employer through payroll: £9,000; Shared through an independent tronc: £0.£9,000Shared by employer through payrollShared by employer through payroll: £9,000£0Shared through an independent troncExample: employer NI on £60,000 of tips a yearComparison. Shared by employer through payroll: £9,000; Shared through an independent tronc: £0.£9,000Shared by employer through payrollShared by employer through payroll: £9,000£0Shared through an independent tronc

Source: ICAEW Library & Information Service, 2025[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Shared by employer through payroll£9,000
Shared through an independent tronc£0

Example: a restaurant collects £60,000 a year in optional service charges and card tips. If the owner decides the shares and pays them through payroll, employer National Insurance at 15% is about £9,000, and employees pay their own National Insurance on top. If the same money goes through a genuinely independent tronc that meets the E24 conditions, no National Insurance is due on it. Income tax is still deducted through the tronc PAYE scheme.

Setting up an independent tronc

  1. Choose the troncmaster

    Pick someone staff trust, who is not the owner or a director and who can make allocation decisions without being told what to do. Some venues use a staff committee or an external tronc administrator.

  2. Write the tronc rules

    Set out how the tronc is funded, how shares are calculated and when they are paid. The rules should sit alongside your tipping policy and be consistent with it.

  3. Register the tronc PAYE scheme

    The troncmaster sets up and runs a PAYE scheme for the tronc, so income tax is deducted from tronc payments and reported to HMRC.

  4. Separate the money

    Transfer tips and optional service charges to the tronc promptly and in full. The employer should not hold the money back or decide individual amounts.

  5. Keep records

    The troncmaster keeps allocation sheets, payment records and minutes of any decisions. The employer keeps the tipping record the tips law requires.

  6. Review the independence

    Once a year, check that nobody from ownership or senior management is setting shares, vetoing decisions or influencing points in practice.

Pitfalls that break the exemption

  • The owner or operations director sets the points system or approves each month's shares, even informally.
  • The troncmaster is told to reward or penalise individuals as part of performance management.
  • Tronc money is used to top up pay or to reach minimum wage. Tips do not count towards minimum wage pay in any case[1].
  • Compulsory service charges are run through the tronc on the assumption that National Insurance is not due.
  • The tronc rules exist on paper but the payroll team still calculates and pays the shares as part of normal wages without the troncmaster's decisions.
  • Records are thin, so the venue cannot show HMRC who decided what.

If HMRC concludes the employer was in fact deciding the allocation, National Insurance can become due on the payments, so the cost of getting it wrong can be larger than the saving. Take advice from an accountant or tax adviser who knows hospitality before you start, and again if your structure changes.

How a tronc fits with the tips law

A tronc does not replace your obligations under the tips law. Tips must still be shared fairly and transparently, paid by the end of the month after the customer paid them, and recorded for three years. The tipping policy should explain that a tronc is used, who the troncmaster is and how they decide shares. The detail is in the tips law explained and writing a written tipping policy.

Who should not be the troncmaster

The independence test is about practice, not job titles. A troncmaster who is also the owner, a director or the person who sets pay will struggle to show that the employer is not deciding the allocation. The same applies to a general manager whose own bonus depends on keeping labour costs down, if the owner expects them to use the tronc to manage pay. Many groups choose a senior front-of-house employee with no say over wages, a small elected staff committee, or an external tronc service that applies rules the staff have agreed.

Running the tronc month by month

A tronc works best on the same monthly rhythm as the tipping record. At month end, the venue reports the total card tips and optional service charges received and transfers that amount to the tronc account or the tronc payroll. The troncmaster takes the hours worked from the rota system, applies the tronc rules and signs off each person's share. The tronc PAYE scheme deducts income tax, the payments go out by the deadline, and the troncmaster files the allocation sheet with the month's records.

Keep the employer's role mechanical: report the money and pass it on. If a manager wants to reward someone for great service, do it through a separate, normal payroll bonus that carries National Insurance, not by asking the troncmaster to adjust shares.

Explaining the tronc to staff

Staff often hear that a tronc is a tax trick for the owner. Explain it plainly: the money is theirs, it is shared under rules they can see, income tax is still deducted, and because National Insurance does not apply to a genuine tronc, more of each tip reaches their pocket. Show them the rules, tell them who the troncmaster is, and invite questions at a team meeting before the first payment.

Tronc health check

  1. Named troncmaster who is independent of ownership in practice.
  2. Written tronc rules consistent with the tipping policy.
  3. Tronc PAYE scheme registered and run by the troncmaster.
  4. Only tips and optional service charges in the tronc; compulsory charges handled through payroll with National Insurance.
  5. Money moved to the tronc promptly and in full, with no employer adjustments.
  6. Allocation records and decisions kept for at least three years.
  7. Annual review with your accountant.

Frequently asked questions

Do you pay National Insurance on tronc payments?

Not if the tronc meets HMRC's conditions, including that the employer does not determine, directly or indirectly, how the tips are allocated. Income tax is still due through PAYE.

Who can be a troncmaster?

Usually a senior employee, a staff committee or an external administrator. The key test is independence: the employer must not decide the allocation directly or indirectly.

Can a compulsory service charge go through a tronc without National Insurance?

No. HMRC says National Insurance is always due on compulsory service charges, whatever method is used to share them.

Does the troncmaster run payroll?

The troncmaster is responsible for operating a PAYE scheme for the tronc so income tax is deducted from tronc payments. Many use a payroll bureau to do the processing.

References

  1. HM Revenue & Customs (2025). Guidance on tips, gratuities, service charges and troncs (E24) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Tips at work (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. HM Revenue & Customs (2026). Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo