Guest experience and reviews

Turning first-time guests into regulars

A visit-by-visit plan for UK restaurants and pubs to bring first-time guests back: recognition, lawful follow-up, reasons to return and measures to track.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why regulars are worth the effort
  2. The first visit: make them known
  3. The 48 hours after: follow up lawfully
  4. Give them a reason to return
  5. The second visit: say welcome back
  6. Recognition without a big system
  7. Touchpoints and owners
  8. Personalisation without creeping guests out
  9. Example: a neighbourhood bistro's second-visit plan
  10. Mistakes that stop guests coming back
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. References

Key takeaways

  • Regulars matter more when demand is soft: for November 2026, 33.7% of accommodation and food businesses expected turnover to fall[1].
  • The second visit is the hardest. Win it with recognition on the first visit, a timely follow-up and a specific reason to come back.
  • Marketing emails and texts need prior consent under PECR, with a narrow soft opt-in for existing customers[2]; collect permission properly at booking.
  • Measure repeat-guest share and the time between first and second visits; act on the trend.

Why regulars are worth the effort

Most venues spend far more effort winning new guests than bringing back the ones they already have. Yet a regular books without comparing, forgives the occasional bad night, brings friends and fills the quiet midweek tables that new guests rarely choose. In a market where many smaller businesses report falling demand, that loyalty is protection. Guests are still spending: households spent £2.80 a week more on restaurants and hotels in the financial year ending 2025, a 6% rise[3]. The question is where that money goes, and regulars send theirs to venues that already know them.

The market backdrop explains the urgency. Among trading UK accommodation and food businesses, 30.7% said domestic demand fell in September 2026 compared with August, and for November 33.7% expected turnover to fall while 10.8% expected it to rise[1]. Only 11% of independent hospitality leaders were optimistic about the year ahead in Q3 2026, against 53% of leaders overall[4]. Independents that keep their regulars are less exposed to that swing.

Turnover expectations for November 2026, accommodation and food businessesONS Business Insights and Conditions Survey; remaining answers were not sure or not applicable.
Turnover expectations for November 2026, accommodation and food businessesBar chart. Expect turnover to fall: 33.7%; Expect it to stay the same: 41.5%; Expect turnover to rise: 10.8%.Expect turnover to fallExpect turnover to fall: 33.7%33.7%Expect it to stay the sameExpect it to stay the same: 41.5%41.5%Expect turnover to riseExpect turnover to rise: 10.8%10.8%Turnover expectations for November 2026, accommodation and food businessesBar chart. Expect turnover to fall: 33.7%; Expect it to stay the same: 41.5%; Expect turnover to rise: 10.8%.Expect turnover to fallExpect turnover to fall: 33.7%33.7%Expect it to stay the sameExpect it to stay the same: 41.5%41.5%Expect turnover to riseExpect turnover to rise: 10.8%10.8%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Expect turnover to fall33.7%
Expect it to stay the same41.5%
Expect turnover to rise10.8%

The first visit: make them known

The aim of a first visit is to make a stranger feel known. That starts before they arrive: the booking should capture a name, a contact and a reason for the visit if the guest is willing to share it. At the door, the host greets by name and knows it is a first visit.

Host script: 'Welcome, is it your first time with us? Lovely. Let me show you to your table, and Priya will look after you tonight. She'll tell you about a couple of things the kitchen is proud of.'

  • Mark first-time bookings on the host sheet so every server knows.
  • Have the server introduce one or two signature dishes or drinks. First-timers often order safely; a recommendation gives them a reason to remember you.
  • Note one personal detail on the booking afterwards, if the guest shared it: a favourite wine, an allergy, an anniversary date. Store only what is useful and appropriate.
  • Have the manager stop by the table briefly. A short 'thanks for trying us' is remembered.
  • Ask how they heard of you. It tells you which marketing works and starts a conversation.

The 48 hours after: follow up lawfully

A short thank-you message within two days reminds the guest of a good evening and invites a second visit while the memory is fresh. Whether you can send it depends on how you collected the contact. Under the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations, marketing emails and texts to individuals need their prior consent[2]. The soft opt-in lets a business market its own similar products to customers whose details it obtained during a sale or negotiation, provided they were given a simple way to opt out at the time and in every message[2].

In practice: a booking confirmation and a service message about the booking are not marketing. An email inviting them back with an offer is. Ask for marketing permission clearly at booking, with an unticked box, and keep a record of it.

Example follow-up email (fictional, sent only to guests who opted in): 'Thanks for joining us on Friday, Sam. We hope the lamb lived up to Priya's recommendation. Our autumn menu starts on 1 November, with the first game dishes of the year. If you'd like to try it, reply to this email or book here, and we'll save you a table by the window. Unsubscribe.'

Give them a reason to return

Guests return when there is something to come back for that they cannot get by simply remembering you fondly. Reasons work best when they are specific and dated.

  • Seasonal menu changes, announced with a date.
  • Events: a tasting evening, a quiz, a Sunday supper, a winemaker dinner.
  • A dish that rotates monthly, so there is always something new.
  • A regulars' table or a standing booking slot for guests who come every week.
  • Recognition rather than discounts: remembering the usual order, the favourite table, the dog's name.

Discounts can bring a second visit but rarely build habit, and regular discounting teaches guests to wait for the next offer. If you use one, make it a one-off welcome back, not a permanent price cut.

The second visit: say welcome back

The second visit is where a guest decides whether you are a place they go, or a place they went once. Recognition does most of the work. If the booking system shows a previous visit, the host should see it on the sheet and say so: 'Welcome back, lovely to see you again.' If a server looked after them last time and is on shift, seat them in that section.

  • Check the guest notes before service and brief servers on returning guests, especially second-timers.
  • Repeat what worked: the same table if they liked it, the wine they enjoyed, the dish they photographed.
  • Introduce something new, so the second visit is not a copy of the first.
  • Ask what brought them back. The answer tells you which part of the first visit to protect.

Recognition without a big system

You do not need expensive software to recognise regulars. Most booking systems already store visit history and notes. Where guests walk in, a simple shared notebook or a notes field on the till works for a small team: name, usual order, preferences. The habit matters more than the tool. Spend five minutes before each service reading who is booked, and make sure the team on the door knows at least the names of the ten guests they see most often. Standing bookings help too: a regular who books the same table every Thursday should not have to ask each week.

Touchpoints and owners

Guest journey touchpoints from first visit to regular
TouchpointWhat to doToolOwner
BookingCapture name, contact, occasion and marketing permissionBooking systemReservations
ArrivalGreet by name; flag first-timersHost sheetHost
At the tableRecommend signature items; manager check-inService routineServer, manager
After the visitThank-you message to opted-in guests within 48 hoursEmail toolMarketing or GM
Second visitRecognise them: 'welcome back'Guest notesHost
OngoingSeasonal and event news, a few times a month at mostEmail or socialMarketing

Personalisation without creeping guests out

Some venues are starting to use technology to personalise service. Of UK accommodation and food businesses using or unsure about AI in September 2026, 17.8% used it to provide or personalise services for customers[5]. Tools can help remember preferences, but the line between thoughtful and intrusive is easy to cross. 'Your usual Rioja?' is welcome. 'We noticed you haven't been in since your birthday in March' may not be.

Keep guest notes factual, useful and limited to what guests told you or would expect you to know. Guests can ask to see what you hold about them, so write nothing you would not be comfortable showing them. For more, read personal service without being creepy.

Example: a neighbourhood bistro's second-visit plan

Example (fictional): A 50-cover bistro finds that most first-time guests do not return within three months. The GM sets a plan: first-timers flagged at booking, a manager visit to every first-time table, a thank-you email within 48 hours to those who opted in, and a monthly 'chef's table' evening announced to the list. After a quarter, the share of first-time guests making a second booking within 90 days rises, and midweek covers grow.

The example's results are invented, but the measures are real ones you can track: share of first-time guests who return within 90 days, and the average gap between first and second visits. Both come from booking system data.

Mistakes that stop guests coming back

  • Treating a returning guest as a stranger. If the booking system knows they have been before, the host should too.
  • Emailing too often. Weekly offers turn a welcome into noise and lead to unsubscribes.
  • Inconsistency. A second visit that disappoints ends the relationship faster than a first.
  • Ignoring feedback. A guest who mentions a problem and sees nothing change does not return.
  • Making regulars wait. A regular who cannot get a table on a Friday may stop trying.

A fair welcome at the door and a safe, happy team underpin all of this; see dress codes and door policies and handling guests who are abusive to staff. Corkage nights can also bring regulars back midweek: see corkage and BYOB policies.

Frequently asked questions

How do we get first-time guests to come back?

Recognise them on the first visit, follow up within a couple of days if they agreed to hear from you, and give them a specific, dated reason to return, such as a new menu or an event.

Can we email guests after their visit?

Service messages about a booking are fine. Marketing emails need prior consent, or must fall within the soft opt-in for existing customers with a clear way to opt out. Ask for permission at booking.

Do loyalty discounts work for restaurants?

They can bring a second visit, but regular discounts teach guests to wait for offers. Recognition, consistency and reasons to return usually build stronger habits.

How do we measure whether guests are coming back?

Track the share of first-time guests who book again within 90 days and the average gap between first and second visits, using booking system data.

References

  1. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 166 dataset (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2003). The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003, regulation 22 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Office for National Statistics (2025). Family spending in the UK: financial year ending 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. NIQ (CGA by NIQ) and Zonal (2026). Hospitality's confidence rises after solid Q3, but Budget support crucial for stability (Business Confidence Survey with Zonal) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Office for National Statistics (2026). Business insights and impact on the UK economy, wave 165 dataset (AI sheets) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo