Staffing, pay and employment law

Working out the cost of staff turnover

A worked Example of what it costs a UK restaurant to replace one chef and one waiter, built from ONS pay data, with a model you can use for your venue.

Ava research teamPublished 7 min read

On this page
  1. Why put a number on it
  2. The six parts of turnover cost
  3. The pay rates the Example uses
  4. Example: losing one chef
  5. Example: losing one waiter
  6. From one leaver to the annual figure
  7. Adjust the model to your venue
  8. What the numbers usually show
  9. Presenting the figure to an owner
  10. Keep a simple leavers log
  11. Use the figure well
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. References

Key takeaways

  • Turnover cost is mostly hidden: cover during the vacancy, manager time, training and weeks of lower productivity, not just the advert.
  • In our worked Example, replacing one chef costs about £3,000 and one waiter about £980, using ONS median pay[1].
  • Employer National Insurance at 15%[2] and at least 3% employer pension[3] add to every extra hour paid.
  • Multiply by your own leavers to see the annual figure, then compare it with the cost of the fixes that keep people.

Why put a number on it

Hospitality has always lived with high staff turnover. The Low Pay Commission describes it as a sector that traditionally runs with high rates of staff turnover, and it still has the largest vacancy rate of any sector, at 3.1%[4]. Because leaving and hiring happen all the time, the cost becomes part of the background and nobody adds it up. Once it has a number, it can be compared with the cost of the things that reduce it: better rotas, training, a pay step for experienced staff.

The method below uses hours and pay rates rather than guesses. Swap in your own figures; the structure stays the same.

The six parts of turnover cost

  1. Recruitment: adverts, agency fees if used, and manager time spent screening, interviewing and running trials.
  2. Vacancy cover: overtime premiums, agency staff or a reduced menu while the job is empty.
  3. Onboarding admin: contract, right to work check, payroll set-up, uniform.
  4. Training time: the hours a head chef, supervisor or buddy spends teaching the new starter.
  5. Lower productivity: a new starter does less, more slowly, for the first weeks.
  6. On-costs: employer National Insurance and pension on the extra hours paid.

There are also costs that are real but harder to price: mistakes and waste while someone learns, guests who receive slower service, and the strain on the team who cover, which can trigger the next resignation. Leave them out of the main figure, but mention them when you present it.

The pay rates the Example uses

The Example uses ONS median hourly pay for April 2026: £15.19 for chefs, £12.81 for waiters and waitresses, and £15.75 for restaurant and catering managers and proprietors[1]. For on-costs it uses employer National Insurance at 15%, the rate since 6 April 2025[2], and the minimum employer pension contribution of 3% under automatic enrolment[3], so 18% in total, assuming everyone already earns above the thresholds. Everything else in the Example is a labelled assumption for a fictional venue.

Example: losing one chef

Example: a 70-cover restaurant loses a chef de partie who worked 45 hours a week. The job takes four weeks to fill. Existing chefs cover 20 hours a week at time and a half, and the menu is shortened for the rest.

Example: cost of replacing one chef de partie
Cost itemWorkingCost
AdvertisingExample assumption for job boards and social posts£250.00
Manager time on recruitment10 hours at £15.75£157.50
Paid trial shift5 hours at £15.19£75.95
Overtime premium during the vacancy20 hours a week for 4 weeks at half of £15.19£607.60
Head chef training time20 hours at £15.75£315.00
Lower productivity, first monthHalf of 45 hours for 4 weeks at £15.19£1,367.10
On-costs on extra pay18% of £1,156.05 (manager time, trial, overtime, training)£208.09
TotalSum of the items above£2,981.24
Example: where the £2,981 chef replacement cost goesExample built from ONS April 2026 median hourly pay and stated assumptions
Example: where the £2,981 chef replacement cost goesStacked bar chart. Lower productivity: £1,367; Vacancy overtime: £607.6; Recruitment and trial: £483.45; Training time: £315; On-costs: £208.09.Lower productivity: £1,367 (46%)Vacancy overtime: £607.6 (20%)Recruitment and trial: £483.45 (16%)Training time: £315 (11%)On-costs: £208.09 (7%)Example: where the £2,981 chef replacement cost goesStacked bar chart. Lower productivity: £1,367; Vacancy overtime: £607.6; Recruitment and trial: £483.45; Training time: £315; On-costs: £208.09.Lower productivity: £1,367 (46%)Vacancy overtime: £607.6 (20%)Recruitment and trial: £483.45 (16%)Training time: £315 (11%)On-costs: £208.09 (7%)
  • Lower productivity £1,367 46%
  • Vacancy overtime £607.6 20%
  • Recruitment and trial £483.45 16%
  • Training time £315 11%
  • On-costs £208.09 7%

Source: Office for National Statistics, 2026[1]

Show the data
ItemValue
Lower productivity£1,367
Vacancy overtime£607.6
Recruitment and trial£483.45
Training time£315
On-costs£208.09

The advert is less than a tenth of the total. The biggest item is the month in which the new chef is learning the menu and the kitchen, which is why a good onboarding plan and a written recipe book save money directly. The figure also leaves out sales lost while the menu was shortened, which for many kitchens would be larger than everything else combined.

Example: losing one waiter

Example: the same restaurant loses a server who worked 30 hours a week. The job takes two weeks to fill, with colleagues covering 15 hours a week at time and a half.

Example: cost of replacing one server
Cost itemWorkingCost
AdvertisingExample assumption£100.00
Manager time on recruitment5 hours at £15.75£78.75
Paid trial2 hours at £12.81£25.62
Overtime premium during the vacancy15 hours a week for 2 weeks at half of £12.81£192.15
Training time8 hours at £15.75£126.00
Lower productivity, first two weeksHalf of 30 hours for 2 weeks at £12.81£384.30
On-costs on extra pay18% of £422.52£76.05
TotalSum of the items above£982.87

Front-of-house roles are cheaper to replace one by one, but they turn over far more often, so the annual total can be larger than for the kitchen.

From one leaver to the annual figure

  1. Count leavers by role group

    From payroll, count last year's leavers in the kitchen, front of house, bar and management.

  2. Price one leaver per group

    Use the tables above with your own pay rates, vacancy lengths and training hours.

  3. Multiply and add

    Leavers in each group times the cost per leaver, then add the groups together.

  4. Separate early leavers

    People who leave within 90 days cost almost the full amount and add little; count them separately.

  5. Compare with fixes

    Set the annual cost against the cost of what would reduce it, such as a training programme or a pay step.

Example: a venue with 25 staff had 15 leavers last year: 3 chefs and 12 front-of-house staff. At the Example costs, that is 3 times £2,981 plus 12 times £983, or about £8,940 plus £11,800: roughly £20,700 a year, before lost sales. If a better rota and a structured first month kept even four of those people, the saving would pay for a great deal of training.

Adjust the model to your venue

The Example is deliberately simple. Real venues differ in ways that change the answer a lot, so adjust the inputs before you rely on the figure.

  • Agency cover instead of overtime: replace the overtime premium with the agency's charge for the hours covered, minus the pay you would have paid the leaver.
  • Longer vacancies: senior chefs and general managers can take months to replace, and the cover cost scales with every week.
  • Senior roles: a head chef or general manager leaving often takes others with them and may require a recruiter; price those risks separately.
  • Seasonal venues: a leaver in June costs more than one in January, because cover is scarce and the season's sales are at stake.
  • Notice periods: if the leaver works a notice period and helps train a replacement, part of the training cost disappears.
  • Holiday on extra hours: overtime worked to cover the gap also builds holiday for casual staff; add the holiday that accrues on those hours if you want a fuller figure.

What the numbers usually show

When venues work through this exercise, a few patterns come up again and again. The productivity loss in the first weeks is usually the largest single item, which means onboarding quality has more effect on the total than recruitment spending. People who leave in their first 90 days account for a large share of the cost, because the venue pays almost everything and gets little back. And the cover cost during vacancies falls on the same few loyal staff, which can push them towards the door too.

That points to three practical priorities: hire carefully for the roles that turn over most, invest in the first month for every new starter, and keep enough slack in the rota that one resignation does not overload everyone else.

Presenting the figure to an owner

Owners and finance directors respond to a clear, conservative number with its workings attached. Show the cost per leaver for each role group, the number of leavers last year and the total, and state the assumptions you made. Then put one proposal next to it, with its cost and the reduction in leavers it would need to pay for itself. A training programme that costs less than the turnover of three front-of-house staff is an easy decision once both numbers are on the same page.

Keep a simple leavers log

The model is only as good as the data behind it. Keep a one-line record for every leaver: role, start date, leaving date, reason given, how long the vacancy lasted, how it was covered and how many training hours the replacement needed. Ten minutes per leaver gives you a far better figure next year than any estimate, and it shows which roles, managers or months generate the most turnover. Review the log every quarter alongside the rota and the exit reasons.

Use the figure well

Present the number with its assumptions, so owners and investors can challenge them, and update it every year. Track the same measures each quarter: leavers by role, 90-day retention and exit reasons. When labour costs are under pressure, and 29% of accommodation and food SME employers reduced headcount over the year to 2025[5], the case for spending on retention is easier to make with a figure on the table.

For the fixes themselves, see staff retention in hospitality and rota planning from forecast covers. For hiring people more likely to stay, see front-of-house interview questions that work.

Frequently asked questions

How do you calculate the cost of staff turnover?

Add recruitment costs, cover during the vacancy, onboarding admin, training time, lower productivity while the new starter learns and employer on-costs on the extra hours. Multiply by the number of leavers in each role group.

What does it cost to replace a chef?

It depends on pay, vacancy length and training time. Our worked Example, using ONS median chef pay, comes to about £3,000 for a chef de partie before any lost sales.

Is front-of-house turnover cheaper than kitchen turnover?

Each front-of-house leaver usually costs less to replace, but those roles tend to turn over more often, so the annual total can be larger.

What on-costs should I include?

Employer National Insurance at 15% above the secondary threshold and employer pension contributions of at least 3% on qualifying earnings, plus holiday accrued on extra hours if you want a fuller figure.

References

  1. Office for National Statistics (2026). ASHE 2026 provisional, Table 14.6a: hourly pay excluding overtime by occupation (SOC 2020), all employees (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. ICAEW Library & Information Service (2025). Hospitality: industry profile (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. GOV.UK (2026). Workplace pensions: what you, your employer and the government pay (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. Low Pay Commission (2025). National Minimum Wage: Low Pay Commission Report 2025 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Department for Business and Trade (2025). Longitudinal Small Business Survey 2025: SME employers (businesses with 1 to 249 employees) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

See Ava handle your calls.

Book a short demo. We’ll walk through your calls and workflow, and agree what Ava should take care of.

Book a demo