Key takeaways
- A menu description that falsely describes food, or is likely to mislead about its nature, substance or quality, can be an offence under the Food Safety Act 1990.
- The test is what a reasonable guest would understand by the word, not what the kitchen meant by it.
- Keep evidence for every claim you make: invoices, specifications, farm or boat names and recipes.
- When a supplier changes, the menu changes the same day, including online menus and delivery app listings.
The legal test behind every menu word
Menus feel like marketing, but in law they are labels and advertisements. Under section 15 of the Food Safety Act 1990, anyone who gives or displays a label with food that falsely describes it, or is likely to mislead as to its nature, substance or quality, is guilty of an offence[1]. The same section applies to advertisements that falsely describe food or are likely to mislead[1], which covers your website, social posts and the description on a delivery app.
Consumer law adds a second layer. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 prohibits unfair business-to-consumer trading, and the Competition and Markets Authority's guidance gives examples of how different types of unfair practice can break the law[2]. A misleading description that leads a guest to order something they otherwise would not is the kind of practice that guidance is about. Trading standards officers enforce both regimes locally, usually starting with advice rather than prosecution, but a pattern of misleading claims is treated seriously.
Why guests notice
Diners read menus more closely than they used to, partly because more of them are changing what they eat. In 2025, 75% of consumers had made at least one diet change for health reasons in the previous year, most often eating less processed food, which 49% had done[3]. Someone choosing a dish because it says homemade is relying on that word.
Words also carry price. Guests expect to pay more for local, hand-dived or dry-aged, and they feel cheated when they find out the claim was loose. Complaints about menu claims often begin with a guest who knows the farm, the fishmonger or the frozen product on the cash-and-carry shelf.
The words that cause most trouble
| Word on the menu | What a guest is likely to assume | Evidence to keep | Safer wording if you cannot prove it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fresh | Not frozen, not preserved, recently prepared or caught | Delivery notes and dates; prep records | Name the method instead, such as made this morning |
| Homemade or made in house | Prepared from raw ingredients in your kitchen | Recipe cards showing the raw ingredients | Finished in house, or name the supplier |
| Local | From near the venue, within an area a guest would recognise | Supplier address and a defined radius or county | Name the county or the farm |
| Free-range, organic, wild | Meets the scheme or production method implied | Certification or supplier specification | Leave it out |
| Named breed or origin, such as Welsh lamb | All of the meat in the dish is that breed or origin | Specifications and invoices for every delivery | Name it only when every batch qualifies |
| Line-caught, hand-dived | The specific catch method was used | Supplier confirmation per delivery | Sustainably sourced only if you can show how |
Notice that the safer alternatives are not vaguer. They are more specific about what you know. Guests respond well to a farm name or a county, and a precise claim is easier to defend than a broad one.
Homemade and fresh: the two claims inspectors hear most
Homemade causes the most disputes because kitchens use it for dishes that are assembled rather than made. A cheesecake built on a bought base, a curry made from a paste, or chips cut from frozen potatoes may all be good food, but a guest who reads homemade expects you to have made the thing from its raw ingredients. If a key component is bought in, say so, or describe what you did: house-finished, our own recipe, or simply the dish name without the adjective.
Fresh is the other common problem. Fish that was frozen at sea can be excellent, but calling it fresh tells a guest something different. If you use frozen fish because it is better or more consistent, describe it honestly. Many venues now say frozen at sea on purpose because it signals quality.
Substitutions in the middle of service
The most common way an honest menu becomes misleading is a substitution. The farm's lamb does not arrive, the kitchen uses another supplier's, and the menu still says Welsh lamb. The fix is a routine, not a new menu: the head chef tells front of house, servers tell guests before they order, and the online menu is edited the same day.
- Server script: Tonight the lamb is from a different farm than the menu says, because our usual delivery did not arrive. It is the same cut, cooked the same way.
- Specials board: write the substitute supplier next to the dish rather than removing the whole item.
- Delivery apps: pause the item or edit the description; app listings are adverts in their own right.
Allergen, dietary and calorie claims are stricter
Free-from and dietary claims carry the highest risk because a guest may rely on them for their health. Food law requires businesses to declare 14 specific allergens[4], and businesses serving non-prepacked food must supply allergen information for every item that contains any of them[5]. Calling a dish vegan, dairy-free or gluten-free goes further than allergen information: it is a promise about the whole dish, including cross-contact in the kitchen. Only use those words when your controls support them, and train servers to explain what the kitchen can and cannot guarantee.
Larger businesses in England must also print calorie information. The rules apply to food businesses with 250 or more employees[6], menus must include the statement that adults need around 2000 kcal a day[7], and the fixed penalty for breaching the rules is £2,500[8]. A calorie figure is a factual claim too, so recalculate it when the recipe or portion changes.
Photos, adverts and online menus
Photos on delivery apps and social media are part of the description. A burger shot with three patties when the dish has two, or a portion of prawns twice the size of what is served, can mislead in the same way words can. Keep photos current, take them from real portions, and update them when the dish changes. Check that your website menu, booking platform menu and app listings say the same thing, because guests compare them and so do officers.
When a guest asks where something comes from
Servers are the ones who get asked, and an improvised answer can create a claim the menu never made. A server who says the fish came in this morning when it was delivered frozen on Tuesday has just misdescribed it. Give front of house a short source sheet for each menu, updated with every change, so they answer from facts rather than guesses.
- For each dish, list the main protein, its supplier and origin, and whether it arrives fresh or frozen.
- Mark which sauces, breads and desserts are made in house from raw ingredients and which are bought in.
- Note any claim that changes with deliveries, such as a named farm or catch area, so servers know to check with the kitchen.
- Give a fallback line: I am not certain, so I will check with the chef rather than guess.
This sheet doubles as your evidence index. When an officer or a guest asks, the answer and the paperwork are in the same place.
A five-step menu audit
List every claim
Highlight every adjective and origin word on each menu, board and listing: fresh, local, homemade, named farms, breeds, regions, catch methods and dietary labels.
Match each claim to evidence
For each highlighted word, find the invoice, specification, certification or recipe card that proves it. If you cannot find it in five minutes, an officer will not find it either.
Rewrite the unsupported claims
Change the wording to something specific and true, or remove it. Avoid replacing one vague word with another.
Set a substitution rule
Write down who updates which menu when a supplier or ingredient changes, and how quickly.
Repeat each menu change
Run the audit whenever the menu changes and at least once a season, and keep a dated copy of each menu with its evidence file.
Example: the local beef that stopped being local
Example: a gastropub's menu says local beef, braised for eight hours, because for two years the beef came from a farm six miles away. In March the farm stops supplying, and the kitchen switches to a national wholesaler. Nobody changes the menu. In June a regular who knows the farmer asks about it, then posts a review saying the pub is lying about its beef. The licensee runs the audit, changes the description to slow-braised British beef chuck, adds the wholesaler's specification to the evidence file and replies to the review explaining the change and the date it was fixed. Had the substitution rule existed in March, the problem would never have reached a review site.
Frequently asked questions
Can I call a dish homemade if I use a bought-in sauce?
Be careful. A guest is likely to assume homemade means made from raw ingredients in your kitchen. If a key part is bought in, describe what you did instead, or name the supplier.
What counts as local on a menu?
There is no single legal definition, so the test is what a reasonable guest would understand. Naming the county, town or farm is clearer and easier to prove.
Who enforces menu descriptions?
Local trading standards and food safety officers, using food law and consumer protection law. Most start with advice, but repeated misleading claims can lead to formal action.
Do delivery app descriptions count?
Yes. Descriptions and photos used to sell food online are advertisements, and they can mislead in the same way as a printed menu.
References
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (1990). Food Safety Act 1990, section 15: falsely describing or presenting food (opens in a new tab) ↑
Competition and Markets Authority (2025). Unfair commercial practices (CMA207) (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2025). Food and You 2: wave 11 key findings (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑
Food Standards Agency (2026). Allergen guidance for food businesses (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2022). The Calorie Labelling (Out of Home Sector) (England) Regulations 2021 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2022). The Calorie Labelling (Out of Home Sector) (England) Regulations 2021 (opens in a new tab) ↑
legislation.gov.uk (The National Archives) (2022). The Calorie Labelling (Out of Home Sector) (England) Regulations 2021 (opens in a new tab) ↑